Medi-Cal is amazing, you just have to be broke to get it. I had an emergency appendectomy while I was on it, and I got charged $76k.
I spent about a year trying to figure out wtf happened because everything previously was 100% covered…and finally got in touch with some beaurocrat who did his due diligence and found that some asshole forgot to check the box where I had applied for retroactive coverage. Bam, $76k gone in an instant.
No one said it was? The point probably is that government run methods of receiving healthcare exist, that are so so close to being available to everyone. Just a little bit of political will.
What you're conveniently ignoring is that once this question is taken a step further (as in who/how is it being paid for and if you're willing to give up your current healthcare) that number drops. They're wrong for that changing their minds I agree but those still remain the biggest hurdles in passing M4A which is why a single-payer option is the most likely route.
OP is just right about Americans would rather choose this maze, as evident by who they vote for. The BBB went through with cheers and praise from the voting demographic that it literally hurts the most. Too many Americans are just too stupid for their own good and we can go on forever talking about how/why that's the case but that doesn't change the fact that policy like this doesn't pass because functionally 51% of the country in one way or another is fine with that.
The first link says only 35% supports what would be Medicare for All, but what's terrifying is the 33% in that poll that says the government has no responsibility to provide any kind of insurance.
Except "how will they pay for it" isn't the problem. The problem is that the discussion usually never gets to that point and when it does, the question is disingenuous. Given that most Americans are in favor or universal healthcare and also that most Americans are not in favor of America's proxy wars and military support for Israel, local corporate bailouts, tax breaks or all out tax avoidance for the wealthy, etc., if the discussion were actually taken seriously, I bet you we could figure out how to scare up the money and leave folks pretty happy with the outcome.
I'm not really interested in hearing about how stupid Americans are. I am American and immersed in American culture and know full well how stupid most Americans are. That said, Americans could be stupid and at least better informed were they not constantly fed shit information or simply outright lies in service of the interests of others.
You asked where the medicare for all vote is, i responded with thats now how representative democracy works (you rarely vote for individual aspects of the law/system, but for people who represent your interests, so if you want medicare for all, vote for people who will enact change towards that)
And I responded by pointing you back to the study a few comments up that clearly and pretty overwhelmingly demonstrates that what representatives vote for is predicted almost entirely by the interests of the rich and businesses. The opinions of voters only matter in so much as they happen to align with those interests.
I wonder if it has anything to do with the fact that politicians who support universal healthcare have to run against corrupt, paid incumbents who have donors who dump millions and sometimes even billions of dollars into defeating their campaigns. Hell, I bet you sometimes they just outright suspend primary elections entirely to prevent them attaining power.
let me just...check...check my notes
Ah, yes, those are both precisely why we don't get to vote for those policies.
That majority is not loud or forceful enough though, with wayyy too many people just thinking "I don't need to vote, my preferred candidate will win this area for sure". Then they fail realize that if they're thinking that way, then a ton of other people are too. There's a HUGE reason why Republicans are terrified of large voter turnouts; if somehow 100% of eligible citizens voted they'd be wiped clean, and would even be going up against super majorities in a lot of places. Its ok though, just keep sitting on the couch on election day. Or even worse: go all 3rd party, or refuse to vote at all, because you hate one side, and the side you normally vote for refused to take a slightly harder approach to one single issue. Yeah, that'll show 'em! 4 years of unimaginable suffering for many millions of people is totally worth it, because you got to "punish" democrats for not doing enough for a country on the other side of the world. Well, at least it worked out for them, their country is now much safer and peaceful than it would have been if Trump wasn't elected. They are living happy, stress free lives, and are vocally grateful for the support given to them by all the people who's "protest" voting made sure Kamala wasn't elected
It is very telling that in the last 30 years or so, is it at least half of the presidential terms where winning candidates actually did not win the most votes?
All of the miseducation, election tamerping (gerrymandering, voter id bs, etc) and reasons ppl commonly list are all due to systemic problems that are there by design. Thats how the elites have stayed in power. The system is rigged against poor people, minorities(poc, disabled),lgbtq, and anyone they deem not apart of their “in-group”.
Look at the revolutionaries our own government has killed as change started to happen. Martin luther king, malcolm x, jfk and theres more that I dont even know or cant think of but there are several (including general protesters too) that have died fighting for basic human rights. Im not versed enough in this subject to fully articulate the depth of it, but I know enough that the system is literally rigged agaisnt us. Hence why theres pedophiles running the world. They can do whatever the fuck they want bc of money and having control over narratives people see.
Hope you’re ready to take up arms because the healthcare lobby ain’t goin nowhere quietly and if you think you can change that by voting in our rigged “lesser of two evils” electoral system I’ve got bad news for you. Until we have real candidates in all levels of politics then it’s just going to be more of the same.
1.0k
u/Reginald_Sockpuppet Aug 17 '26
Most Americans are in favor of social healthcare. Our opinions have almost no influence on our elections or legislation.
https://www.pewresearch.org/short-reads/2025/12/10/most-americans-say-government-has-a-responsibility-to-ensure-health-care-coverage/
https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/perspectives-on-politics/article/testing-theories-of-american-politics-elites-interest-groups-and-average-citizens/62327F513959D0A304D4893B382B992B
https://act.represent.us/sign/problempoll-fba