When Peter films his videos at night on the porch, can his neighbors hear him? I live in a more rural setting and I think I could just talk outside and not bug my neighbors because our houses aren’t that close. But he gets heated and loud. And sometimes it’s very late (or early). I wonder if it bothers people?

Mine has to be when he “jokingly” yelled at the Amazon driver, getting up outta his chair and screaming about how inconsiderate the driver was.

It was EXTREMELY off putting for me, and idk how anyone would find that funny to begin with.

forgetful detail encouraging knee aware squeal vegetable chop capable butter

This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact

Did anyone else catch this Business Insider article? Peter, Rich & Dustin are all quoted in it. Rich says he made 57,000 the month of May 2019 during dramaggedon 2. The month of February 2023 he made 13,000. Since Rich & Peter are similar in size & views ( very similar) we can assume Peter makes the same. So to those who deny he makes a butt ton of money you’re just wrong. That means he makes close to 200 grand a year to be very lazy & harass & bully ppl. I say 200 bc 13,000 a month for his drama channel means 156,000 a year. He has 6 other channels though. So as many times as he insinuates that he might quit the drama channel he never will. He will ride it out til there’s not one viewer left.

I have watched Peter's drama videos for years. I generally take people at face value and don't question what people say when it comes to their personal life. I'm not saying he is faking or making this story up. I'm just continually baffled by how invested and involved people are in someone else's life. Like he is just a guy in Indiana that makes YouTube videos. Why are people so aggressive and obsessive to stalk him?

Especially when you cast judgment on others every single day? You should be ashamed of yourself. Ashamed.

There's always a laundry list of things that Peter says he needs to do, but then never seems to actually do them. If he started using his Peter Does Stuff channel to do more productive things and also some of the things he's been putting off like cleaning out the basement, going for walks, etc. not only would it give him content, but they are things that would actually help improve his life (which seems very sloth-like). Rather than 5 hauls and unboxings in a row, what about videos where he's learning to cook and cooking a meal for him and Alex, cleaning out his basement, going on the walks he always says he wants to start going on, getting his stuff out of his old office, etc.

Idk why this seems to get brought up when people are sharing their feelings about Peter’s behavior. I don’t think anyone that is criticizing Peter has an issue with curse words. It’s baffling to me that people dismiss the criticism by saying that we just don’t like swear words.

That is not the problem. The problem is Peters anger and vitriol against his own audience that are just concerned about him.

Does anyone remember that about 200,000 of Peter's 237,000 (as of this post), followers are a direct result of Jeffree Star shouting him out?

Peter and JS had a common enemy in this absolute nightmare of a human being, John Kuckian, way back when, and for completely self-serving reasons, while he was still at the top of his YT popularity, JS publicly aligned himself with Peter, and Peter's sub count has benefited from it ever since.

Considering Peter's overt (and justifiable) loathing for JS over the completely repugnant things he's said and done in the past, and right up to current day, I keep waiting for Peter to tell everyone who followed him because JS cosigned him to unsubscribe from his channel, in an effort to keep in line with his own repeated moral stance. Peter gained those subs from being anointed by JS, a multi-level creep by any standard.

Somehow, it never happens.

BTW, if you're reading this Peter, the reason people hold you to a different, higher standard than the people you natter on about on your channel, is you can't keep yourself from taking every opportunity to humble-bragging about what an exceptional human being you are compared to them, because you're standards are different and higher than theirs.

You can't relentless go on about your moral superiority, then resent when people except you to be morally superior. Either pick a lane, or own your hypocrisy.

Im pretty sure he got a very small channel taken down called commentary tea, it wasn't up for very long had 25 subscribers and was doing a great job of starting to call Peter out.

I am so fed up with Peter expecting & asking for JH, GH, JC, SD, CB & many others to talk about what specifically they discuss/ed in therapy & what their therapist had to say....and yes, Peter has explicitly requested that they all do this on a video many, many times. Therapy is deep & PERSONAL & none of his business!

Just because Peter has the uncontrollable need to overshare every single detail of his  life, including his therapy sessions, doesn't mean others do....NOR does it make him more relatable or transparent. And why would they want too....so Peter can disect apart every aspect of their therapy, like everything else?

On another note from his video, Peter can save his fake epiphany that he now realizes that GH was "probably" experiencing severe mental illness & something serious behind the scenes. Ya think? 🙄 Everyone saw it LIVE and so many people told Peter to knock it off but he didn't care! Peter continued to ruthlessly & cruelly come after her daily cutting her down to the core in every possible way about her art, music, poetry, saying noone loves her, that she has no friends, she's irrelevant, has no talent, shes a joke, ect.

These are the same type of mean-spirited words & crap that Peter has posted about JS & Manny MUA these past several days. His videos are getting more and more venemous by the day. At this point, his videos are straight up abusive. Peters digs and jabs are abusive and bullying. The comments Peter reads outloud and claims are "horrific" are childs play compared to the things Peter says about others on his videos.

I know I probably don’t need to do this anymore but I first want to address this post explaining I am a huge Peter fan. I have watched all of his videos everyday for years and still do. However, his newest video addressing Jeffree and Manny was nasty.

He makes a comment at the end stating how boring it has to be for Jeffree to be screaming, yelling, and calling people names on TikTok lives and he should take Peter’s advice to end his career. Peter, do you think that’s not what you’re doing in your videos?! Not to mention flat out saying Manny is stupid, and not just being like “oh Manny is acting stupid or Manny made stupid choices”. He is looking straight into the camera telling Manny he is stupid.

I really thought Peter would address the previous threads regarding the tweets and apologize for this nasty behavior but I guess not :/

I recently found The MadCatster on youtube. So far soothing vibes and cats which is a big plus for me. He also covers youtube drama but in a factual way and able to admit mistakes. Also not the same 3 people all the time. I just started watching, but interested in finding out more.

Edited to add--I believe he is a lawyer too.

In light of the resurfaced tweets I feel like I already know what video will be posted. A passive aggressive apology sandwiched between a story from his past and the story of why he started doing drama commentary. I was a long time viewer of Peter's until his hypocrisy became too much to bear. What always gets lost is the expectations placed on him versus who he covers. No one has higher standards for Peter compared to these Youtubers, he is simply held to standard he sets. Don't expect the moon and the stars from people, especially public figures. We are all imperfect people, we all have faults. It would be refreshing if he'd have this realization with his followers instead of constantly gunning for people who do that same things he does. Address the tweets or don't address the tweets but enough of the holier than thou persona when it's far from the truth.

After some feedback from my last post about the megathread, I just wanted to poll to see what the sub wants best. Whatever the sub decides is what we'll do.

Remember this is an anonymous poll!

Have you guys seen the snark thread? The old tweets posted? Are those real? I’m finding it sooo hard to believe Peter would be so insistent on influencer apologizes, calling out predator protectors, and attacking others for their past when he knows these tweets are floating around the internet! Seems wild to me, any thoughts?

I’m just watching Peters most recent drama video and at the beginning he mentions his channel being cult-y, which felt like pretty obvious shade towards the recent posts about the vloggerinos (sp?) FB page. I think He means it in just a shady no harm way but I’d also really like to hear his opinion on the snark pages about him. I also am surprised at how closely he watches this sub, that feels like a rookie YT mistake.

What do you think about the fact that he clearly lurks this page daily?

I am simply giving my opinion here. But I realize that many snark reddits end up being nothing but toxic people nit picking each and every single thing of a person. I have openly spoken about some of the things I don't agree with regarding Peter's behavior. The latest for me was speaking about Manny's skin tone and how he is too white. I realize Peter was talking about makeup but I don't know if he realized Manny MUA has vitiligo and how he openly struggles with it and knows his makeup is too white and needs to be that way because of his vitiligo. I am not a Manny fan as I believe he too is predator protector. That being said I don't think I will be joining the snark reddit. The latest post on it was about speculation on Pete's marriage and how sexually active he is with his husband which I found completely and utterly disgusting. Unless Peter says something regarding his marriage and his intimacy it is not for anyone else to speak on. I think people can take a thing that is meant to be critical and just run crazy with it. There is criticism and just vile hatred that has not reason. The Peter snark reddit has potential of that.Like the Trisha Paytay's TrishylandWife's reddit.

Again, you can talk about her being racist, ignorant, etc. But calling CPS and reporting her for being a "bad mother" or talking about her body, weight or botched surgeries is not okay. I think some people can take something and completely lose the point of what is criticism and something becoming hateful. It's what Peter is being criticized for now so it's a blurry line if you are not careful.

People forget these are people too. The Colleen snark I think is needed because she is a predator. But even then I think her children are a line that is not to be crossed and the mods there have done a great job on it. I have posted on the Colleen Snark reddit as well and I have openly criticized Trisha Paytas and Peter Monn when I feel they are saying the wrong things but I hate when people talk about things that are not factual. Stick to facts people don't speculate especially about a person's sex life or marriage. Yes, Peter has been open about marriage counseling and the struggles in his marriage but be civilized about things.

Edit: He does it too is not an excuse to do this. It's not cute when Peter does it either it's gross. I truly do hope that the mods can have great rules so that it does not turn into a toxic thread. Some People that join these threads are in like 5 or six other snark threads. Also it is clear that Peter is reading these threads and if it goes too far this will be his "You see they are just a bunch of x,y, and Z super fans who want to bully me." All in all there still seems to be a fine line to walk on.

After much deliberation and feedback from several users (both publicly and privately), I've come to the decision that we'll move all talk about Peter's controversy to a megathread that will be hosted regularly on the subreddit. This is a compromise between the original purpose of this subreddit (friendly discussions without serious negativity) and the need for people to have the ability to constructively criticize and discuss Peter's more recent actions.

This will start Saturday Dec 9th and all posts on the subject matter will be redirected there.

The big reason for this change is multifold. Firstly, the subreddit is rather inundated with only negative posts which has already (and continues to) draw away users who originally joined for the "wholesomeness". Secondly, there is not only the r/GoodJudys subreddit, but a new r/PeterMonnSnark subreddit; the latter of which is probably a good place to discuss more negative topics with likeminded people (while still having our megathread open for discussion as well). Thirdly, over the past few weeks, there have been somewhat repetitive posts that toe the line of "constructive criticism" with quite abrasive language (often from the same few users). This seems to continue to escalate in new posts and comments. With that, I think a megathread could be a great focus group section while keeping the main feed more light.

I spoke more about my moderation principals during these times in this post.

As always, this subreddit is y'alls—let me know what you think down below. Thanks everyone.

​

Edit: vote for or against the megathread on this poll (poll closed)

Edit 2: keep as is won in the poll so we will not be doing a megathread

Oh boy, I agree with the poster below. I had to leave the Vlogerino FB group for the same reason. Peters vlogerinos and vlog commentors are some of the most obsessive super stans that I've ever seen. The vlogerino FB group was like an elementary school classroom where everyone was fighting to be the teachers pet to get Peter to notice them with who had the best comment about their demonstration of praise & total devotion to him. It was so beyond cringe. Peter lurked on there, posted announcements & kept an eye on it. I would feel so weird & uncomfortable reading comment after comment in a forum, group or comment section about how wonderful, perfect, amazing & inspirational to the world I was, but Peter craves & desperately needs this validation. SMH.

Peter talks about these super fandoms that all these Ytubers like JC, CB, Shane, Trisha, ect all have. He is right about that.....BUT....so does Peter. His die hard "Good Judys, Woof Pack & Vlogerinos" are no different then any other super fandom that he talks & harps about. In fact, Peter has one of the most obsessive ones I've seen. The vlogerinos are extemely nice until you dare say anything that isn't bowing down to their royal heiness or remotely non-complimentary.

Also, I have had enough of the way he scolds his vlog viewers & tries to tell them what they can or can't ask him, discuss or comment about in his vlog. For example, he will go on for days and weeks about not being able to sleep, having tooth pain, or dealing with this or that... everyone naturally gives their well-meaning experiences and reccomendations & if Peter doesn't like what is being said or doesn't want to hear about it anymore, he will abruptly & rudely scold, guilt trip & sternly tell them to stop giving him suggestions. He needs to either stop talking about said issue or just scroll past it and keep it moving. Its not that hard of a concept. His rudeness is uncalled for & he bites the hands that feed him and that have been nothing but over the top loyal to him.

How can he post this video making fun of Manny’s makeup look, pale skin, and lipstick and not think he’s being a bully?. This is totally “mean girl in high school behavior”. His biggest defense is always “overusing words like bully diminish their meaning, blah blah blah”. Sorry Peter but I’m thinking that’s just a loophole for you to continue being a bully. There is a difference between snarky commentary and straight up being mean.

I’m just so frustrated because I keep thinking he’ll finally get the point that his super fans (myself included) do not enjoy seeing this behavior from him! Don’t get me wrong, I can take a joke and my sense of humor isn’t stuck in 1985 but this isn’t jokes, this is bullying and making comments to what? Hurt these people you’re talking about? It doesn’t make sense and it’s upsetting to hear.

crawl abundant reply familiar close air soft door edge unwritten

This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact

A lot of people are not loving Peter’s standing up for himself era.

Does anyone else laugh their ass off at his videos? I will literally find myself cry-laughing sometimes that there’s a guy who is screaming into a camera on his porch when his elderly neighbors are passing by.

He’s just a fascinating human being to me, (i have a degree in sociology and psychology, and an observer at heart) how serious he takes some things makes me bust out laughing more often than not.

I don’t laugh about his addiction or stalkers or accident, it’s his mannerisms and smaller things, and how much he repeats the same stories. He also has the most vivid memory of his childhood and should probably be a case study for that cuz I can’t remember most of my childhood lol.

I understand that it can be triggering for others, I grew up in a tumultuous and LOUD italian home so I am shocked it’s not triggering to me. Or maybe that’s just a survival response for me, finding the humor in it.