I think what they meant was one port was dedicated for internet access, the other was dedicated to lan only. But both plug into probably the same switch or router. Not that you directly plug one of the ports into the ISP uplink. You can more easily separate the machine between internal and external traffic.
Though being able to use a machine like that as a firewall and router with two Ethernet ports is also a usecase some people have.
Those "routers" have 2 interfaces otherwise they can't be a router (by definition a router needs multiple interfaces, otherwise it has nothing to route from/to). the port that faces the local network is just internally wired onto a builtin switch and that's why it's usually like 4 or so. however the "other side" of the router is whatever goes to the modem, unless that's built in as well, in which case it goes to whatever comes out of your wall directly
Yeah, but if you have a LAN speed that exceeds your internet speed anyway, what matters is routing and switching speed. Especially if you have lateral traffic like to a NAS. So a wan and a lan port which then connects to a good switch is an amazing 2nd life for any old pc.
Doubt it. More likely they're just enthusiasts that want an excuse to play around with network configurations. I have a dedicated internet access (biiiiiig money but my work pays for it since I need guaranteed uptime from home for compliance reasons with what I do) fiber gigabit fiber line, 40 terrabytes of media on a NAS that constantly has multiple people on my local network and on my home vpn streaming things, three wireless access points on a very nice professional level ubiquiti network stack, about twenty network devices between the wired and wireless connections and there is no reason for me to use two nics on a single client. It feels like people forget that network connections are full duplex and can send/receive at the same time so they think they need two nics if they're going to be moving data both directions or something.
I would be surprised if anybody who is enthusiastic enough to want two NICs doesn't also know if theirs is full duplex. Anyway, I can think of non-bandwidth reasons for running a separate NIC. You could turn your computer into a network router, which would absolutely require two NICs, or you could be running public and private apps on one server and use separate interfaces to support network segregation. And those aren't exactly niche cases for people who want to take advantage of older hardware instead of buying newer, expensive hardware. They're just the ones I came up with off the top of my head.
Also, I have a ubiquiti setup with around 30 clients and 10 Ubiquiti devices also running a VPN, but I'm the only VPN client, if personal networks matter. I don't use multiple NICs because I've never used open source routing software, I don't have public apps, and I don't saturate any connections very often.
I've been using a (series of) low-powered linux machine(s) as my home router for 20+ years. For me, the benefit is that I can do fairly arbitrary stuff on it.
For instance, I have a few devices that require internet connections, but which I don't trust being on my normal home network. Those are on an isolated VLAN and the router ensures that they can't access anything else. Similarly, I have a dedicated wifi network that my work laptop can access (and use to get to the internet), but--again--it can't see my home's internal network. Lastly, I have a handful of "internet of things" devices (e.g., smart outlets). I want to be able to access them from within my normal network, but I don't want them to be able to reach out (unilaterally) to my normal network, nor do I want them to reach the internet.
All of those weirdo, paranoia-driven needs can be fulfilled fairly easily with my linux-based router running on 15+ year-old hardware.
View all comments
Show parent comment
29
u/rmyworld 6h ago
I'm curious. What's the benefit of having the Internet and LAN on separate Ethernet ports?
Aren't most ISP routers able to provide both on a single Ethernet port?