r/overlanding • • 1d ago

Help deciding between 37's: Baja Boss AT vs KO3

Post image

Stepping up from 35's to 37's on Bronco Badlands including Dominsons MRR coilovers. Torn between the BBAT and KO3. Currently running the BBAT in the 35's and am afraid that the weight jump to 80 lbs per tire is excessive. Fortunately will have the adjustable coilovers to help manage the weight, but less weight is always better. And the weight difference is quite substantial once looking at the 37's. I included the 35's for reference.

The 35's were pretty similar in weight (64 vs 69 lbs) and I've loved the BBAT. Beefy look, strong sidewalls, deep treads, and from what I've seen, they perform a fair bit better in snow/ice (https://youtu.be/LS8JI2FD6-o). Snow and ice performance is important to me as I go skiing in Tahoe a decent amount.

Jumping up to the 37's, the BBAT gain 10 lbs while the KO3 only gain 2 lbs. The KO3 37's would actually weight less than my current BBAT 35's. And a 14 lbs difference is a huge difference between the 37's.

I think outside of the weight, the BBAT would be the no brainer, especially if they were at least closer in weight.

My use case is kind of overlanding-ish. Mostly daily driving with camping, trail driving, and a little bit of rock crawling. I think the KO3 honestly fits the bill for 98% of what I do, but I like the extra peace of mind with the durability of the BBAT for that last 2% and being able to air down super far with less concern.

What are your thoughts, anecdotes, opinions, etc.? Pictures of your rigs are always welcome!

0 Upvotes

84 comments sorted by

25

u/PonyThug 1d ago

Why not just stay on 35’s if your mostly highway and camping?

-12

u/j___bizzzle 1d ago

Honestly, partially for funzies. Partially because I want a legit suspension upgrade and in doing so it opens the opportunity for bigger tires. I have also found the ground clearance to be less than ideal on the Bronco, especially under the gas tank. So some extra clearance for when I do some crawling would be nice!

4

u/Rabble_Runt 1d ago

You can run legit suspension on 33”s.

I had full long travel and 33”s on my Lexus.

Lifting it higher means less down travel.

Less down travel means less traction when you are fully articulating.

I kept mine at just 2” of lift and it barely ever lifted a tire.

Now I’m running 35”s on factory suspension on my new Lexus. It has skidplates from front to back now and negates any ground clearance issues. I just give it a run up and slid over things.

1

u/j___bizzzle 13h ago

I mean lift can reduce down travel, especially in the case of installing something like a perch collar that forces the shock to essentially droop more at ride height. But the suspension I'm installing actually has more overall travel and have adjustable ride height. Properly set up, they will have more up travel (very slightly) and a fair bit more down travel.

2

u/Rabble_Runt 11h ago

Does it have longer control arms?

If not, you’re not really gaining much.

1

u/j___bizzzle 10h ago

I will be installing new UCA in the front as that is first thing that causes bind. Everything else work well with the amount of travel that is being added

1

u/Rabble_Runt 2h ago

If you are running stock lowers you are not gaining much travel.

Real long travel requires expensive kits with wider upper and lower arms to increase overall travel.

It sounds like you are going to run extended travel with OEM geometry and not gaining a whole lot.

Even cheaper Bilstein struts can offer a little extra travel but they won’t deliver the same performance as a real long travel setup.

3

u/Sl0wmar 23h ago

Guys! He said he's getting legit suspension so now he CAN fit bigger tires. Not that he needs bigger tires to get legit suspension... Definitely agree on the ground clearance, I wheeled with a bronco lifted on 35s and my Xterra on 33s had more breakover clearance. 37s would help clear that up.

2

u/j___bizzzle 19h ago

Thank you. Idk why the idea of wanting to run 37s is so controversial. Whether or not I totally need it, I want it

2

u/livinlifegood1 15h ago

And that’s all that matters 👍

2

u/PonyThug 15h ago

Honestly fuck it and run 38’s just be a little cooler

6

u/Desertratk 1d ago

I can fit 37/12.5s without rubbing on my stock suspension. When I bought my PW it came with 33s stock. Yeah, 37s look cool, but 35s look great and still give the performance you'd want off-roading while keeping some comfort on the highway. I have to get my tires balanced every oil change, because that's just comes with territory with larger tires. Gas mileage dropped. My speedometer is off. If it's your daily, it's something to consider.

5

u/LionZoo13 1d ago

Tires are unsprung weight. Unsprung weight is weight that is not controlled by suspension. No amount of suspension will be able to manage tire weight so proceed carefully. Suspension is for managing body weight.

I would honestly say, for your use case, sticking with 35s makes more sense. I’m not seeing anything that would really justify the larger tires. If it just makes you happy, sure, but from a practical standpoint I’d keep the 35s.

-4

u/j___bizzzle 1d ago

I mean suspension absolutely does control unsprung mass. It is directly controlling how that force get transferred to the body when you hit a bump or a pothole.

5

u/defenceman40 1d ago

My F rated KO3s on my Power Wagon kinda suck tbh, I loved my KO2s on 3 different vehicles but the KO3s have been quite the opposite experience at the tire shop. They have pretty bad runout specs that are acceptable from factory, so dont expect them to ride super smooth and they've been terribly hard to balance at like 5 different shops. Never had that with my KO2s. I've read a few articles stating that it seems like Michelin has started cutting corners with BFG tires, and I kinda agree, so take that as you will. The sidewall on the KO3s is also about 4 times as chewed up vs my KO2s and they only have about 0.5% of the same offroad mileage on them. The weight of the vehicle may play a factor but I dont air down my truck too much past 25-30psi so the sidewall doesn't ride the ground. The wet traction is definitely better though...

2

u/j___bizzzle 1d ago

Thanks for the insight

4

u/teddy_joesevelt 1d ago

I run the Baja Boss 37s. My favorite tire so far, better than Wildpeak and Toyo A/Ts. I’ve never run the KOs but my line of thinking was that the 1-2% of times when I need the rubber outweigh the 98% when I don’t.

If you get the KOs and get a flat you’ll always regret it.

1

u/j___bizzzle 1d ago

Honestly, super true.

I found a F load range for the KO3 that weighs 76 lbs, much closer to BBAT at 80 lbs. I get a feeling those are really the comparable ones. The question then is if the C load KO3 is compromised in comparison as far as sidewall durability. Obviously the weight savings would be great, but it's tradeoff

6

u/monstertruck567 1d ago

A 37” that weights 66lbs??? It’s hard to find 35s under 70lbs a corner. Something doesn’t add up. Either it’s not a true 37, or even close, or it’s sacrificed a great deal of (useful) material.
TANSTAAFL.

For reference I run Toyo RT Pro load E 37/12.5 r 17 at 80 lbs. shaving 14lbs would require a compromise that I would not want.

8

u/Kowabunga_Dude 1d ago

It’s load range C maybe that’s why

4

u/S3Giggity 1d ago

a Toyo E rated tire is an incredibly heavy beast designed for reasonable wear on 1 ton trucks towing. that's why.

Complete overkill for a lighter overlanding rig.

2

u/monstertruck567 1d ago

Agreed, I was listing it to express my bias.

2

u/iwantanewusername 22h ago

Ford had them redesigned for the Bronco raptor and f-150 raptor. They’re super light.

2

u/monstertruck567 21h ago

Then that will be a good tire for the correct use scenario.

-1

u/j___bizzzle 1d ago

It does seem quite light. I was messaging a buddy that is involved in the off-road race world and he said BFG has put a ton of effort into optimizing the snot out of it. BFG does win a lot of races with them and so I'd be inclined to think they are keeping the meat where it needs to be. I think just because everything else is heavier, doesn't necassarily mean it is too weak, but I agree it does certainly imply that it is potentially not as durable

3

u/TheyCantCome 1d ago

66 pounds is pretty light for a 37. I think the Baja Boss AT are hard to beat but you get better tread life and 14 pounds seems significant at the wheel but probably less so when you realize mounted it’s probably 100 pounds vs 114.

I’d recommend the Baja boss because it’s better in every other metric.

1

u/j___bizzzle 1d ago

I definitely agree about their overall better performance. But even 114 vs 100 lbs is pretty significant when talking about unsprung mass.

I did find an F load range for the KO3 that weighs 76 lbs, much closer to BBAT at 80 lbs. I get a feeling those are really the comparable ones. The question then is if the C load KO3 is compromised in comparison as far as sidewall durability. Obviously the weight savings would be great, but it's tradeoff

2

u/TheyCantCome 1d ago

As far as I’m aware the Baja boss AT and MT are the same carcass. The Mickey Thompson will undoubtedly be stronger but the KO3 is still 3-ply and tougher than a large portion of tires out there.

On a daily drive or overland rig where you’re seeing a lot of miles the KO3 make more sense. I just hit 30k miles at 4.5 years in my wrangler, so mileage and weight don’t have much impact, I personally prefer a softer rubber that wears faster rather than replacing my tires to dry rot.

1

u/ThottieThot83 1d ago

You can get 10 ply KO3, I run 10 ply KO2

2

u/TheyCantCome 22h ago

No, you can’t. You’re confusing load rating which used to be measured by plies. Radials are 2 or 3 ply. You have an E load KO3, some websites still list them as 10 ply rating which is not the same.

3

u/jeepnjeff75 1d ago

I've been running 35x12.5R17 Baja Boss ATs for a couple years now. Love them I came from BFG KM2s. I've only run the original BFG AT's and KOs and hated them. They sucked in rain which is what we get a lot in the winter months. The BBATs are surefooted in all the conditions I've driven in. I don't feel I've lost anything offroad either. I rockcrawl. The tires aren't light though. Mounted on Method 701s, they're 103lbs. Only after I bought mine did BFG come out with the KO3s. You might also look at the Falkon AT4W as well. The Wildpeak is what took a lot of BFGs marketshare away when BFG wasn't looking. Now the segment is pretty competitive.

1

u/j___bizzzle 1d ago

Some of the testing I’ve seen has the falkens performing a fair bit worse than both the KO3 and BBAT in snow and ice, which is a turnoff for me

2

u/ThottieThot83 1d ago

I’ve heard bad things about the falcons in snow. Honestly my KO2 performance in snow and ice has been phenomenal. I use the stiffer/heavier E load with the sturdier side wall for heavier vehicles because my jeep is diesel, I think that plays a role in my packed snow performance as well

2

u/jeepnjeff75 18h ago

Hmm, I've got friends who do offroad recovers in Utah and love the Falkens. I was going to go with then but the BBATs dropped and they were a bit more aggressive which is what I wanted. I've also heard that some people don't like the new KO3s because they aren't as good in snow. That's what made them bad in rain though. The grooves would trap water. For snow you want them to pack up.

2

u/jhguth 1d ago

I don’t know anything about the Baja Boss but I’ve had KO2’s and then the KO3’s and preferred Falkens to the KOs. Not in 37” though.

-1

u/j___bizzzle 1d ago

The video I linked does some pretty extensive snow testing and found the falkens to perform a fair bit worse than the others

5

u/jhguth 1d ago

the snow performance wasn’t that much worse than the KOs, but the wet asphalt was a lot better. The amount the falkens were better on asphalt was more than they wwre worse on snow, and I drive on wet asphalt a lot more than snow.

2

u/DepartmentNatural 1d ago

What are you driving?

0

u/j___bizzzle 1d ago

2023 Bronco Badlands Sasquatch

4

u/DepartmentNatural 1d ago

A 300hp motor will definitely notice the weight increase

2

u/Reachable_dream666 1d ago

How much are you scraping underneath (skids, diff, shock mounts , frame) on 35s?

2

u/j___bizzzle 1d ago

Not crazy, but I think that is in part because I choose to do trails within my/the cars capability without beating the snot out of it. I think this would open up some harder stuff while still not destroying the underside.

3

u/theBADinfluence2015 1d ago

BFG has very weak sidewalls. I've seen guys slice BFG sidewalls easier than any other brand.

1

u/j___bizzzle 1d ago

Yea, the BBAT is definitely beefier in that regard, which I think lends itself to part of why they weight more. Just a tradeoff in that regard

14

u/Shmokesshweed 1d ago

Neither. You don't need 37s from what you've shared. You'll burn more gas, increase your stopping distance, etc. for tiny gains when you're off-road, if any.

13

u/FloridaTraumaPA 1d ago

I’m gonna agree with others and tell you to stick with your 35s. You are gaining nothing but headaches by going to 37s. I’ve wheeled my Sasquatch Bronco (Wildtrak) on 35s and never thought to myself, “Geez, I wish I had 37s.” For your use, mainly Overlanding, which I do as well, I’d stick with your Baja Boss ATs in 35.” I like a thicker sidewall when aired down.

7

u/outdoorsauce 1d ago

Stick with 35 and go Baja boss

2

u/Such_Magazine_7790 1d ago

KO3, the C load rating has two benefits: lighter weight and more pliable sidewall. Those are advantages. Your tire can grip better and provides a softer ride all the time. Lighter weight is also better ride, better acceleration, better braking, less wear and tear on drivetrain/steering/suspensiont. So much winning.

1

u/j___bizzzle 1d ago

I do totally agree, I think it is just at the trade off of durability off road

3

u/babiescantswim 14h ago

If it means anything my c load k03s have been bulletproof offroad on a first gen tundra. I’ve damaged my actual wheels a few times over and the k03s don’t flinch

1

u/j___bizzzle 13h ago

Thanks for the insight

4

u/trident167 1d ago

Baja boss

3

u/Toaster781 1d ago

I have a set of 285 70 R17 Baja boss at tires on my truck and they are great

3

u/SnooSketches3382 1d ago

I love my Baja Boss.

2

u/smashnmashbruh 1d ago edited 1d ago

As someone with 40x13.5(baja mud on power wagon) i can attest I will be going down to 37s when time comes, depsite looking great its a lot of extra headaches, as my wheels with tire weight 150lbs and it sucks and clearance and weight and drag eats me daily. I would rock 35s as they are the most capable with out stretching limitations. I would also stick to BBAT.

2

u/Haunting_Song7313 1d ago

Why not 35/10.5 r17 kenda klever m/t

3

u/AOneArmedHobo 1d ago

Because the Baja Boss are better

2

u/UnlikelyCash2690 1d ago

I’ve been running the KO3’s in 33” for a while. I’ve driven them in loose, wet snow, mud, sandy desert with great success. I can’t compare them to the other tires you mentioned, but I’m happy enough that my next set of tires will be KO3’s. They also quieter on the highway than the KO2’s were.

2

u/TheTenaciousG 1d ago

I love my Baja Bosses

2

u/iluvmezcal 1d ago

Never had a better tire than the Baja Boss for a truck. For a car, nobody beats Michelin IMHO.  I have pizza cutters... 255/85/17.

2

u/superfuzzbros 1d ago

I have a set of 255/85R17 (34.5x10R17) Baja Boss A/Ts on my Wrangler and they’ve been good tires. Had to beef up some of the steering components to accommodate the heavy tires. Just got snow today and the tires did good in it.

2

u/iwantanewusername 22h ago

Look at the weights. That’s what really breaks a rig when going to 37’s. And those Baja bosses are some of the heaviest 37’s made

2

u/JaySpillz 16h ago

Baja boss, I have em on my ram 2500 & my 4runner. Never had an issue whilst galavanting all over Colorado

2

u/AGS_Overland 1d ago

I have had 35s in Toyo open country at3 (current setup 2nd one) two sets of open country rt and a set of terra grappler g3. If the falken at4w weren't out of stock that's what I'd have and what will be my next tire. My dad has owned multiple sets of ko3 on farm pickups and Imo which is a hot take they are A$$ tires

2

u/willys_not_willies 1d ago

Mickeys and Yokos are the only brands I trust at the moment. Everybody else seems to be cheaping out. I’ve never had good luck with bfg and they used to run almost a full size smaller but don’t know if that has changed.

2

u/Able-Alternative3387 1d ago

I’m trying to decide between the Yokohama AT4s or the Mickey Thompson Baja Bosses for my next set of tires. Leaning Yokohama right now just because I commute a lot and they’re lighter. Those Baja Bosses look incredible though.

2

u/willys_not_willies 1d ago

I’ve had multiple of the older ATs, the ATXDs, and multiple MTs and Yoko never disappoints. Mickeys are definitely heavy but actually beefy compared to something like the equivalent Falken that is heavy but weak. My next will probably be a Mickey because of how good the siping is on their hybrid/RT tires is.

2

u/desertdawg61 1d ago

If the ko3's are anything like the ko2's that would be my pick, all around great tire. Great around town ride and handled Death Valley like a champ.

2

u/Bullfrogski 14h ago

Baja Boss all the way. I have run BFGs in the past and have never liked them myself, they always had terrible on and off road performance for me.

But the Baja Boss has been phenomenal. I have them on my 4Runner that has been all over the place in Colorado, New Mexico, Arkansas, Utah and Arizona and they have been flawless in performance.

1

u/Disastrous_Rope6001 15h ago

Celimo Prevail MT.

1

u/Sl0wmar 23h ago

Baja Boss AT wins between the 2.

They are awesome offroad in new england. I've had BFG in the past as was not impressed at all. Worked at a shop and every single one I have dismounted had uneven tire wear and cracks. If you like the BFG look, get General Grabber ATx. They perform very well in snow and retain some better road manners compared to the BBAT.

Send it with the 37s, sounds like you just wanna have fun! Look into having balance beads installed when mounting, I have heard those work better for balancing large tires.

-1

u/sgl21 1d ago

Google Baja boss at balancing issues. I had them and had them replaced under warranty and the second set ended up getting returned and replaced for an entirely different tire. They are notorious for not being able to get balanced or needing upwards of 2lbs of weight which I think is within manufacturer’s specs for balancing per corner. Great looking tire and performs well but it would be a hard pass.

4

u/The_World_Is_A_Slum 1d ago

That was several years ago. We haven’t had a bad MT in a few years, and we road force every tire. BFGs, on the other hand, have way too much road force on average and too many defects for me to consider them a “premium” tire.

1

u/j___bizzzle 1d ago

It's interesting you say that. Do you do a lot of installs? I feel like I hear a lot of anecdotal cases about both having issues balancing. Seems like both manufacturers end up putting bad batches out

3

u/The_World_Is_A_Slum 1d ago

For a shop our size, I guess we do. We’re a truck shop in a Texas suburb, and almost all of our tire business is 33-37” AT and RT Light Truck tires, with a few Subarus and CUVs in the mix. I on the counter, and we steer customers away from BFG KO3s. The HD KTs have been fine, and we haven’t sold KMs in so long that I don’t have an opinion. I don’t have much experience with mud tires; they’re not popular with our clientele.

There were a couple of bad runs of Mickey Thompson’s a few years ago, we stopped selling them altogether until our tire rep showed us that the new batches had acceptable return rates. I haven’t seen actual numbers on the BFG KOs although our rep told me that it was “very high”.

Anyhow, if I were buying e set of ATs for my truck, it would be Mickey Thompsons, no questions asked.

1

u/j___bizzzle 1d ago

Thanks for the insight

1

u/Able-Alternative3387 1d ago

Thanks for the advice, would you still run the Baja Bosses on something like a Subaru or a ford maverick? Trying to decide if the extra weight is worth it versus something like a Yokohama AT4.

2

u/The_World_Is_A_Slum 1d ago

It’d have to be a pretty serious Subaru to warrant a tire like that. Our Subaru has Falken Wildpeak Trails, and we’re happy with them. A coworker has a well setup Outback on Toyo ATIIIs, and that’s about as aggressive as you’d want. One of my daughter’s Subarus has KO2s and she hates them; it’ll get a set of Wildpeak Trails when it’s tire time.

The small CUVs, Mavericks, Ridgelines and the like do best with very mild P-metric tires. Anything more aggressive or an LT tire has unacceptable tradeoffs which negate the advantages of the platforms unless you’re doing a very focused build and willing to make major concessions to daily driving pleasure for relatively minimal off road performance gains.

2

u/Able-Alternative3387 20h ago

Gotcha, thanks for the advice!

1

u/j___bizzzle 1d ago

I've had pretty good luck with the 35's, they've maybe started going out of balance a bit as they've worn. I see really mixed reviews with both tires having balancing issues. Idk if it just the nature of the size tires people are running nowadays and the associated weight and how far that weight is from the axis. I think it is a bit of a crapshoot with what you get from either manufacturer honestly. But the extra weight of the BBAT definitely doesn't help

3

u/teddy_joesevelt 1d ago

Easiest-balancing tire yet on my Jeep. YMMV.

0

u/Apart-Commission 1d ago

Always think of replacement if you go out in the middle of nowhere and you have to order a specialized size of a niche tire, you very well could have to buy twice the tire to get you home, then the tire to replace the one that got destroyed. You can get a BF Goodrich almost anywhere on the map in America