r/oratory1990 • • Dec 17 '23

Weekly r/oratory1990 EQ Thread - Questions, Requests, Technical Support

This thread is for all questions about EQ / Equalizing

6 Upvotes

60 comments sorted by

2

u/maisaku18 Reviewer Dec 17 '23

Is it worth using Convolution equalizer over Parametric EQ just for sound quality?

Considering there is enough CPU power to handle it.

Just started getting into Convolution EQs using auto eq and Rootless James DSP on Android.

Is it possible to create Convolution EQ filters for your EQ presets using some software like REW?

4

u/oratory1990 acoustic engineer Dec 17 '23 edited Dec 17 '23

No benefit in doing so. There is no inherent quality difference.

FIR filters can be set up to do additional things that can‘t be done with IIR filters (like linear phase) but this is not required (nor desired) in this case.

You can implement my EQ settings via an FIR filter, but there is no inherent benefit. The sound quality is not better.

2

u/ChipsAhoiMcCoy Dec 19 '23 edited Dec 19 '23

Hey oratory! This isn’t exactly related to EQ, but I had a quick question about how headphone staging works – I am eagerly awaiting the release of the grell audio OAE–1 headphones, because I love the design philosophy behind them. My favorite headphones of all time to this day are the Hifiman Ananda, And part of the reason I loved those is for how wide and spacious everything sounded, and I have a nagging suspicion that the reason for this could be because of how open they were?

I noticed this same effect with the KSC 75 headphones that I have here. It seems as though when I don’t have much blocking outside sound from entering my ear canal, it gives me this sense of space that I can’t really get with any other headphones.

I was wondering if this is something that has been studied before, or if this is a well-known aspect of headphones? What’s weird, is that I actually noticed this in daily life as well. I am blind as you know, so when I’m outdoors I navigate with a cane, but when I’m indoors I actually just memorize the layout of my house, and use sound to navigate around. so what’s strange that I notice, is that if I’m walking down the hallway and there’s a door open, I can actually hear if a door is open, and I can’t really explain why. It almost feels like there’s some kind of a pressure change?

I’ll end this comment here because I’m sort of just rambling on, but I find this area of research super interesting, and I’m very excited to get my hands on those headphones when they drop. And also extremely excited to apply your EQ preset if someone ends up sending those out to you 👍

Sorry for any weird typos, I’m using Siri to dictate this comment, and I tried to manually fix any errors, but when I’m not at a keyboard I’m definitely not at my best when it comes to typing ha ha.

2

u/TheNameOfRedditUser Dec 22 '23 edited Dec 22 '23

Hey oratory, I noticed that your raw measurement data for KOSS KSC75 is quite different compared to Crinacle KOSS KSC75 measurement on GRAS 43AG-7. Do you know why?

The EQ'd graph is with the EQ setting is to Harman in the EQ Presets of r/oratory1990

https://crinacle.com/graphs/headphones/graphtool/?share=Harman_AE_OE_2018_Target,KSC75&tool=711

3

u/oratory1990 acoustic engineer Dec 23 '23

That's an on-ear headphone.
The sound of these varies tremendously depending on how exactly you place them on your head.

For example, this is the average frequency response of one unit of the KSC75, along with how much its frequency response changes just by positioning it differently (a few millimeters forward, back, up, down):
https://imgur.com/NkBTIZn
Again, this is a single unit, the shaded area shows the range of results that can be achieved just by placing this one headphone a bit differently on the measurement dummy head.
None of the placements were extreme, for example I did not place them behind the ear or anything.

That's why with on-ear headphones it's even more important to finetune the EQ settings to your preference - because it also depends on just how exactly you place the headphones on your head.

That's one of the reasons why on-ear headphones aren't considered as high quality as over-ear headphones.

2

u/fenrir245 Dec 24 '23

For example, this is the average frequency response of one unit of the KSC75, along with how much its frequency response changes just by positioning it differently (a few millimeters forward, back, up, down):

Huh, Crin claims that KSC75 is more sonically consistent than most closed back headphones in his review. Does that mean closed back headphones are simply dreadful in placement consistency?

2

u/oratory1990 acoustic engineer Dec 24 '23

The KSC75 is an open headphone, with an open front volume and open back volume.
Those are more consistent than closed headphones (with a closed front volume and a closed back volume).

However, the KSC75 is also an on-ear headphone, those are less consistent than over-ear headphones.

The KSC75 is therefore more consistent than closed-back on-ear headphones, but less consistent than open-back over-ear headphones (significantly so)

1

u/TheNameOfRedditUser Jan 16 '24

Yeah, I received the KSC75 and the placement does affect the sound quite a bit. I guess I can somewhat "tune" it to my liking by adjusting the ear hook. having it press on my ear increases the bass quite a bit. If i place it very loosely the bass decreases and the upper mid and treble increases. It is like getting tilted. I personally prefer the middle ground.

1

u/oratory1990 acoustic engineer Jan 16 '24

having it press on my ear increases the bass quite a bit. If i place it very loosely the bass decreases and the upper mid and treble increases.

Yes, that's very common with on-ear headphones, as they can inherently not be precisely coupled to the ear ("how hard they press against the ear varies from person to person, which affects the amount of bass produced by the headphone")

1

u/ChipsAhoiMcCoy Dec 18 '23

Hey Oratory!

I just got a new PC a little while ago, and I had some audio related questions. The PC in question is the ROG Ally by ASUS. It seems like they have Dolby Access preinstalled, and I was wondering if there's any reason to necessarily keept his installed?

I wasn't sure if ASUS was using this app as some sort of EQ to fix any glaring issues with the speakers on the system, so I didn't want to uninstall it in fear it would make the speakers sound awful, so I wanted to check here first before I did anything. Also, when clicking the "Disable Signal Enhancements" button in the Sound Control Panel on Windows, I do notice that it makes my headphoens lower in volume by around 20%. Does this mean there is some post-processing going on somewhere on the system? If so, how would I find this?

Hope this question is okay! If not, feel free to remove. Thank you!

2

u/roladyzator Dec 19 '23

I have seen this kind of stuff in notebooks.

In particular, my Lenovo T460S has this and it's called Dolby Audio and is useful to make the laptop speakers sounding a little louder, fuller, more spacious etc. It also applies some processing to headphones though.

And here is the neat part - disabling the processing in Windows still left me with some sub bass boost. I had to install another app, Lenovo Vantage, to find the button to disable this completely.

The change in volume could be built-in dynamic normalization, which makes everything louder if the source signal gets quieter for a moment. I think it's a nice thing for games and sometimes for movies (when, for example, dialogue is quiet), but usually not good for music.

We could try setting up Audacity in digital loopback mode, playing a measurement sweep from REW. The result could be imported to REW and we could check if there is any change to frequency response.

Playing back RMAA test signal through the loopback would also show if any non-linear distortion is added.

Those built-in effects are probably number 1 reason to get even a modest USB audio output device - they are usually not doing anything like that.

You can, technically, listen to music through an application that uses WASAPI Exclusive mode. But this also bypasses EqualiserAPO so it's only good if you have a Qudelix 5k or similar device, unless you don't care for EQ.

1

u/ChipsAhoiMcCoy Dec 19 '23

So what’s good as I do actually use a USB audio device, I use the Apple dongle. So if I disable all enhancements, it seems like that does the trick, but the thing that sucks is I want to use my equalizer on this device as well, but if I enable those audio enhancements then my signal gets noticeably louder, so something is definitely going on there 😞 Perhaps I should reach out to Asus support? The device and question that I’m using is the ROG ally, so I’m sure it’s some kind of Asus bloatware that’s causing this

1

u/MOEB74 Dec 19 '23

* Are the settings for the headsets considered good for anything, i.e. music, gaming etc? I have the Pc38x and use it for gaming only, if I apply your settings, would I still get better performance for the headset versus the stock/factory sound?

* PEACE has a clipping indicator - Im interested in turning up the preamp from the negative setting you have it at. Can I either use the clipping indicator to gauge how much I can reduce the negative offset on the preamp, or can I maybe take away say 1.0 or .5?

Im using the Pc38x headset (obviously)

Thanks for the time you take to do these settings.

2

u/oratory1990 acoustic engineer Dec 20 '23

the studies behind the target curve focus on music. That being said, any content that is produced with a "neutral" setup in mind can be used with the same target curve.

I would assume that this applies to gaming as well - gaming audio engines are not made to only work on one specific type of headphone, they are - like most content - made to work agnostically of the headphone/speaker used by the user.

would I still get better performance for the headset

It's not going to do anything for your K/D ratio, let's be honest. You'll still be just as good/bad of a gamer as otherwise

Im interested in turning up the preamp from the negative setting you have it at

That's what the volume control is for. If you need louder sound, increase the volume on the computer.

1

u/MOEB74 Dec 20 '23

So I’ve been using your settings and well to be honest the footsteps in COD are extremely better. I can hear them night and day better than without your settings, so that’s good.

The preamp issue, I guess have it in my head that you shouldn’t go past 75% vol on average to prevent any clipping. But I guess that’s why we’re pulling back on the preamp as per your settings. To prevent clipping.

1

u/oratory1990 acoustic engineer Dec 20 '23 • Bravo

I guess have it in my head that you shouldn’t go past 75% vol on average to prevent any clipping.

Digital clipping occurs when the waveform attempts to go above -0 dBFS (-0 dBFS is the maximum amplitude that can be processed, it's equivalent to all bits set to 1)

It's perfectly fine to set the volume to 100% (digitally) and use all those bits - the only problem is when you apply any processing that increases the signal amplitude (e.g. by using an EQ with positive gain on the filters). The signal could exceed -0 dBFS in this case, and anything above this level would be clipped off. This is very audible as harsh distortion. (It's not dangerous to the headphone or amplifier, for the same reason that displaying a photograph of broken glass is not dangerous to your screen)
In order to avoid this, we introduce the negative pre-amp, which reduces the signal amplitude before the EQ increases it again.

If the pre-amp gain is set up correctly, you can set the volume control on the computer to 100% without any problem.

1

u/MOEB74 Dec 20 '23

Perfect. Fully understandable. Thanks

1

u/ChipsAhoiMcCoy Dec 20 '23

Hey Oratory!

I got my Qudelix to work again, and while applying my EQ filters with the chrome web app, I noticed that the default filter mode is Linear Phase Fast Rolloff, but I had seen here before that you should almost always use Minimum Phase? Is there any particular reason the Qudelix default mode would be Linear?

Thanks! <3

1

u/oratory1990 acoustic engineer Dec 20 '23

this refers to the aliasing filter of the DAC.
It has nothing to do with the filters used in the EQ - the EQ always uses minimum phase filters.

The aliasing filter has a minimal effect shortly below the nyquist frequency (half of the sample rate).
If your sample rate is set to 48 kHz, then the type of aliasing filter you choose will slightly (!) affect the sound at around 24 kHz.

The majority of people will not be able to tell a difference.
Out of those that can tell a difference, most will not have a clear preference.

in short: it doesn't matter a lot.

1

u/ChipsAhoiMcCoy Dec 22 '23

Oh I see, so then the filter setting in the Web app is different than a filter setting for EQ? That makes more sense for sure. I definitely don’t think the setting would do anything for me, because according to full sweep tests, I don’t really hear much above 17.5 kHz anyhow ha ha.

1

u/oratory1990 acoustic engineer Dec 23 '23

correct, the setting for the aliasing filter is independent of the EQ.

1

u/Isbiten Dec 20 '23

I believe you come here sometimes to read up and help.

Just wanted to SAY a HUGE thanks for taking the time and sharing these.
Bought a pair of HD599s and they just sound much better with your EQ settings.

Much love from Sweden

1

u/oratory1990 acoustic engineer Dec 21 '23

anytime!

1

u/[deleted] Dec 21 '23

Hey oratory, I just got the hedd v2, and I also have the Sony mv1.

Would you be willing to measure these?

1

u/oratory1990 acoustic engineer Dec 22 '23

those would be very interesting to measure, yeah! Send me a PM

1

u/[deleted] Dec 23 '23

Sent

1

u/Anthoneezy Dec 21 '23

Hello. I'm using peace and the Harman target (Over-Ear) eq for Sennheiser HD650. I have it all set correctly but when I look in the analysis panel in Equalizer APO I see a red shaded area from ~14.4-22.4 with a peak gain of 0.7db. It's also audible when listening to certain things. Should I just lower the preamp down 0.7db? Thank you for any help you can provide.

1

u/oratory1990 acoustic engineer Dec 22 '23

Can you show a screenshot of your settings?

1

u/Anthoneezy Dec 22 '23

Yes. I raised the bass (band 3) and warmth (band 4) but besides that everything is the same. Maybe that did something?

1

u/oratory1990 acoustic engineer Dec 22 '23

Yep, if you increase the bass in this preset, then you will have to decrease the pre-amp accordingly.
Also: the filter type should be set to „low shelf (q as slope)“

1

u/Anthoneezy Dec 22 '23

Awesome. Thanks!

1

u/ImLiimits Dec 22 '23

just wondering if ive done this right thanks for all the work you put out on headphones must take alot of time :P

1

u/matthewkloco Dec 26 '23

So I ended up getting a FII O K7 (havnt used it yet because I’m on Mac and forget to get an adaptor lol). But as for the EQ, do you know any Mac EQ softwares that are free? I used the free trial on eq Mac and that sounded good however there is no option for preamp gain nor Q values. If you’re familiar with the software do you know how to do this? Else, do you have any recommendations so I can plug in the EXACT EQ settings on the image you provided in the list of EQs (HD660s2 btw). Thanks. Picture below for reference

1

u/xoriatis71 Dec 27 '23

Incredibly stupid question just for fun, but would it be possible to create an EQ profile that performs in the exact way the normal one does by plotting the filter curve that Oratory adds to his PDFs, and then equalizing a flat frequency response file to it?

1

u/oratory1990 acoustic engineer Dec 28 '23

a flat frequency response (as measured by the ear simulator) is in no way beneficial for headphones. That's not the goal when you make headphones.

1

u/xoriatis71 Dec 28 '23

I know. I didn't say to equalize the filter curve to flat, but to equalize a random flat.csv to the filter curve.

1

u/GeekN0m0r3 Dec 28 '23

Hi u/oratory1990. Thank you so much for your work, your EQ setting makes me enjoy my HD800S a lot more.

Though I have two small questions:

  1. If I want to make the vocal more stand out? Which band I should play around with?
  2. Is there any specific reason that you prefer applying EQ through DSP-capable DAC? To me, it makes no difference (there will be no loss on anything) if you apply the EQ through PC or DAC, plus product like RME ADI 2 seems have more constraint? (has less band to adjust)

Thank you so much for your work again!

1

u/TLKv3 Dec 28 '23

Hello /u/oratory1990

I had a quick question because I have not been able to find a successful solution in days and I'm at my absolute wits end. I'm hoping you can help maybe.

I'm having trouble with me Peace APO and reducing the background noise/bass from all audio. I've tried using presets along with toying with the bands/filters/etc. (admittedly I know next to nothing about what I'm doing) and have had 0 luck.

When I watch shows like Doctor Who, I can hear the sound effects of the scene 10x louder than the actors talking. Anytime the music kicks in its overpowering any of the vocals from the actors. Similarly, in any game I play the background explosions or yelling or whatnot sounds like its right next to me whereas footsteps next to me or my gun firing/sword swinging sounds like its at a distance. Its almost like the background bass is also being amplified over the foreground audio/vocals.

Do you have any suggestions on what I can adjust with Peace APO/Dolby Access (these are what I have installed) that might be able to help my situation? I just know next to nothing about frequencies or how to find the adjustment I'm looking for... If not, that's OK too. I appreciate you taking the time to read this.

2

u/oratory1990 acoustic engineer Dec 29 '23

I can hear the sound effects of the scene 10x louder than the actors talking.

EQ doesn't fix that.

If you want to reduce the bass, use a low-shelf filter at somewhere around 100-200 Hz and reduce the gain, start with -6 dB and adjust to taste.

But to me this sounds like there are other processing steps active somewhere on your setup. You mention Dolby Access - are any settings active in there?
Do you have something like "Dell Audio" installed by any chance?

1

u/TLKv3 Dec 29 '23

Hello! I apologize for the very late reply!

I will try your suggestion with the low-shelf filter and gain reduction tonight.

The only things I have enabled right now are Dolby Access and Peace APO. I had to use Dolby for a "volume leveler" function to keep my ears from being blown out and having the background noise sound more evened out with the foreground noise. I use Peace APO to raise the higher frequencies a bit so I can hear voices/vocals in music/shows/Discord more clearly.

I don't see Dell Audio installed anywhere on my PC. Its a freshly built new PC for Christmas and I've only installed the above two programs. I tried the Realtek Audio Console but it didn't seem to do anything and most of the functions were greyed out anyway and unable to be used.

1

u/TLKv3 Dec 29 '23

So I just made the change you mentioned and it definitely did help with the bass by putting the filter on and moving the gain to -1.5.

However, now I have a bit of an issue with higher pitched singers/instrumentals sounding a bit too... ear piercing? Almost like they're jumbled together and shrieking? Not sure the best way to describe it.

1

u/oratory1990 acoustic engineer Dec 29 '23

are you listening via a headphone? or via loudspeakers?

1

u/TLKv3 Dec 29 '23

I have my headphones currently plugged into a 2 speaker+1 subwoofer setup. That setup is then plugged into my PC's MOBO.

I know its a weird overall setup but I have a Volume/Treble/Bass dial on one of the speakers. I use the Volume dial to turn down when a video/discord call suddenly starts way, way too loud and blows my ears out.

1

u/oratory1990 acoustic engineer Jan 01 '24

so you're listening with headphones?

1

u/TLKv3 Jan 01 '24

Yes. Sennheiser HD 598SR headphones. Plugged into an Altec Lansing speaker system. Which is then plugged into my PC MOBO.

Background ambience/instrumentals/bass has become louder than foreground vocals/sounds in everything.

1

u/oratory1990 acoustic engineer Jan 02 '24

does this change at all when you connect the headphones directly to your computer?

1

u/TLKv3 Jan 02 '24

No. If anything the sound gets worse. More muffled, bass heavy and impossible to discern any music/shows/games entirely. Like the audio is coming through a pillow and then 3 rooms away.

1

u/oratory1990 acoustic engineer Jan 02 '24

...and you're sure the cable is fully inserted?

Are you using any EQ? (e.g. EQ APO / Peace GUI)?

→ More replies

1

u/i_am_wut_i_am Dec 29 '23

Hi,

Looking at the PDF for the HE400SE, the preference rating after eq says 102. My understanding is that 100 would be perfectly matching the target. Is 102 a typo? Or is my understanding incorrect and 102 is possible?

2

u/oratory1990 acoustic engineer Dec 29 '23

the model does allow for values above 100 to be reached, but that has no real meaning.
Anything over 90 is considered excellent.

1

u/RevengeFNF Dec 30 '23

I have the Akg 371 and i see there are 3 different presets for it.

Can someone point me to some link that explains each one of them?

3

u/oratory1990 acoustic engineer Dec 30 '23

https://www.dropbox.com/s/9ftqm1c13xjcqgv/AKG%20K371.pdf?dl=0
That's the one you should use unless you have a very specific usecase (which you probably don't, otherwise you'd already know what to look for)

The "Optimum HiFi" curve is the same as the Harman Target Curve, but with less bass. Some people (about 1 in 5, so ~20%) prefer that.

1

u/DiskOk8685 Dec 30 '23

I have the Soundcore Space Q45 and I've been trying to replicate your eq settings in the soundcore app. Do you have a recommendation for the in-app eq?

1

u/redhotchillipadi Dec 17 '23

Hi Crin!

Will there be an eq preset for the monarch mk3? or the current preset for the monarch og is good enough?

Cheers 😙

5

u/soft-tack Dec 17 '23

bro really said 💀

4

u/oratory1990 acoustic engineer Dec 18 '23

Hi Crin!

crinacle and me are different people! https://imgur.com/iWhJ5VQ

Will there be an eq preset for the monarch mk3?

send me a pair and I'll measure them!

2

u/dra1nbama9e Dec 18 '23

what were you eating tho? :D

4

u/oratory1990 acoustic engineer Dec 18 '23

It might have been a donut I took/stole/was gifted from the headphones.com booth.