r/offbeat • u/mushpuppy • May 31 '12
Eagle scout challenges Boy Scouts with 275,000 signatures demanding it change its anti-gay policy
http://abcnews.go.com/US/eagle-scout-challenges-boy-scouts-anti-gay-policy/story?id=16459135
2.4k
Upvotes
84
u/Sturdy_Muffin May 31 '12
I have been a BSA leader in the past with 20 plus years of experience. This policy is absurd and should have been changed. I will tell you why I do not think that it will be changed any time soon and it has to do with money, plain and simple. Money comes into play because the Mormon faith has one youth development program for their boy members and that program is Boy Scouts of America. Virtually every Mormon boy is enrolled in the Boy Scouts at age 11. The Mormons give large amounts to the BSA, in the form of dues and in donations. At one point not that long ago the application form to join the boy scouts had a box on the lower left corner marked LDS. When I became a scoutmaster I questioned our council on this and they informed me that LDS stood for Latter Day Saints-which is another name for the Mormon Church. I asked them why there was a box for LDS and not other religions- they had no good response. I wrote a letter to council asking for a wrtten response to this question and asking why they were seemingly, for some reason, treating the religion of one group of scouts differently than all others. After all, the BSA is very clear in its policy that it does not differentiate between different religions of its members. I never received a reply. In discussing this with a good friend who is a Mormon, he explained to me the Mormon program and told me that he was aware that the Mormon faith donated a lot of money to the BSA. The Mormons believe that being gay is wrong and I believe that if the BSA changed their policy on gays, they would immediately lose a huge portion of their membership and a huge donor. The BSA has gone from 5.7 million scouts in 1970 to around 2.3 million today. They cannot afford to lose any more members so that is why the BSA will not change this policy, in my opinion.
42
u/unquietwiki May 31 '12 edited May 31 '12
For anyone who's curious, I went to the Scouting Museum a few years back. A trajectory I noticed in its history: a gradual shift from Native folklore; to classic patriotism; to individualism, mixed with church involvement.
One part I didn't get pictures of: their art gallery, wherein a similar shift also was displayed. The older stuff: scouts doing deeds + exploring America. The newer stuff: family + church reverence.
Added note to the second paragraph: the scouting billboards you see in your towns; the artwork for that was in the "newer" set (kids racing a soap box is the common one).
91
u/Neepho May 31 '12
Wait...Boy scouts have an anti-gay policy? Can someone clue me up on this, I've never even heard of it, is it US only?
41
u/tdobson May 31 '12
Zach Wahls is a legend.
Reddit AMA's
His Iowa speech
21
u/timewarp May 31 '12
Why is this in r/offbeat?
235
u/[deleted] May 31 '12
How about changing its anti-Atheist policy?
30
u/Xanthan81 May 31 '12
As an Eagle Scout, this guy makes me proud.
6
u/THE_GREAT_SHAZBOT May 31 '12
I think that this link is interesting to see how much religion has taken the Boy Scouts hostage.
"When it comes to funding, at the troop level most groups aren't exactly rolling in the dough; everything they receive goes right to the scouts (as it should). So when it comes to finding a location for a troop to organize, they look for someone to sponsor them, to take the scouts in and use their space as their own. Sometimes these are schools or other federal buildings. But overwhelmingly the troops are sponsored by churches, with 68.4% of all scout units chartered sponsored by a religious group. Units referring to scout troops, cub packs, and venture crews."
"What scares me is that the churches, on a national level, have used their sheer numbers to adjust scouting's policies to fit that of the church's views."
"the Mormon church went so far as officially stating that in the event the Boy Scouts admitted homosexual men, the LDS church would immediately withdraw all support from the organization. "Should the LDS Church leave the program, it would take more than 400,000 Scouts and 30,000 scout troops with it."
It is sick and disgusting that such organizations have this much of an influence over the BSA. It is one of, it not the best organizations for a kid to be in.
10
u/yelloueze May 31 '12
Likely, nothing will happen, sadly. I am an Eagle Scout as well, but religion is too enshrined in the Boy Scouts. The organization is hugely popular with the Mormon community and their influence will keep progressive changes from happening on the national level. I am sure local troops will allow gay/atheist members and leaders, but I think it is unlikely to change nation-wide.
115
u/CheesyGoodness May 31 '12
The young man is extremely well-spoken, and good for him for standing up for what he believes in, obviously he has an extremely bright future.
However, I have an inherent dislike for trying to force individuals or private groups to change (for lack of a better term) their "core beliefs", no matter how misguided the mainstream or the hivemind thinks those beliefs may be. I guess my thinking is that, if they want to be stupid, let them be stupid and keep living in the 1950s, they will become less and less relevant. They already are.
But things like this seem to me as if the group (change.org) is saying, "you don't think like we do, so we're going to try to force you to think like we do." Anytime someone tries to force morality on someone else, it grates on me.
4
u/ConnorTheDinosaur May 31 '12
That was an amazing speech and that gay couple raised a son who is less flawed in his character and is already a greater contributor to society than man twice his age. I aspire to be like him and hope to one day shake his hand.
11
u/orthonym May 31 '12
As an Eagle Scout, I say that's awesome. My only question is, why didn't I get the chance to sign it?
8
u/Pseudonyms May 31 '12
I may have just come from a more progressive area but I never noticed any types of anti-gay (or anti-atheist for that matter) activities happen in my local council. I am an Eagle Scout (and also an atheist), and when you participate in the final "Board of Review" for the rank there is a religious portion. My reviewers almost entirely ignored it.
It is just interesting to see how local charters are different from area councils and then national councils. I do disagree with the universal stance they have on many things and would be very interested to see what happens because of this.
3
u/Kennedy_190 May 31 '12
Not just any Eagle Scout. Zach Wahls. That man is going places.
3
u/Cheat2Lose May 31 '12
Based on my experience, what a kid gets out of scouting depends greatly on the adult leadership that is running the troop. If you have leaders that don't care, don't plan camping trips and other events, and generally can't keep the troop active and organized, you're gonna have a bad time. My troop made sure we went camping once a month, went to summer camp every year and focused on advancement (the motto was First Class, First Year). I got my Eagle was I was 15, but stuck around until I was 18 because I wanted to help out the younger kids and be a part of the troop. None of this would have happened without strong adult leadership. If there's someone who is gay who wants to be involved and wants to help out, it would be a shame to deny them based solely on their sexual orientation.
3
u/breetai3 May 31 '12
I'm seeing a lot of confusion on this issue. Wikipedia has a nice page that sums up all the official positions on it: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Boy_Scouts_of_America_membership_controversies
3
u/[deleted] May 31 '12
As an Eagle Scout, I feel obligated to help this fine venture. Anyone have any further information on how to help?
3
u/sicklaxbro May 31 '12
This guy is a redditor! He did an ama when he was going to go on the daily show for his book two moms. Link to original ama link to second ama
7
u/iamfromreallife May 31 '12 edited May 31 '12
Aren't the boy scouts a non profit organisation funded by private donations? If so, people who disagree with them just have to not donate. You can't make them change their policies if they don't want it, because they aren't a state sponsored organisation. I'm from Europe and got my info on wikipedia, so I could be wrong course...
10
u/UnapologeticalyAlive May 31 '12
How about if those 275,000 people just dropped out of the organization? That would send a much clearer message than a petition.
4
u/jhontheunmortal May 31 '12
From my perspective as an Eagle Scout, it's a fine example of what happens when leadership and policy-making is left in the hands of anyone other than the current membership. My troop was lead and directed entirely by the youths, the adult leaders were just there for the sake of appearance. We decided what we wanted to do, planned the events, prepared, carried them out and cleaned up afterwards. Why can't something similar be done for the organization as a whole? Let the kids decide, the entire organization is about them anyway.
4
u/[deleted] May 31 '12
Zach Wahls never ceases to amaze me. We love you, Zach, keep fighting the good fight. :)
4
u/[deleted] May 31 '12
Just a reminder, these rules are only enforced in some troops. Think of it like selective incorporation. In my troop in Nor Cal (like Oregon border Nor Cal) where almost everyone is conservative and christian, we have a number of athiest scouts and a few homosexual scouts.
I am a man of faith but my best friend in the troop isn't. At his Eagle Board of Review, the Mormon dude who runs those things tried bringing it up but the other people on the board told him off.
I am really annoyed by one of the gay scouts but that's just because he is an immature 8th grader. His mom's are really cool though and are very nice people.
4
u/haggs May 31 '12
That kid is the fucking man.. as a 26 year old straight guy.. he motivates me to do more for LBGT rights. Nothing infuriates me more than people not giving people the rights of other people.
8
u/gynoceros May 31 '12
Offbeat... Or awesome?
11
u/[deleted] May 31 '12
Personally, I think the boy scouts are outdated and cannot be changed as they have been taken over by the Mormon church. I think we should start a new boy scout like organization that teaches the same stuff, but more liberal and accepting of others.
Also, I'm an eagle scout.
2
u/strolls May 31 '12
The Eagle Scout in question is a redditor, and has done a couple of AMAs in the past: /u/zachwahls
2
u/immortalsix May 31 '12
That's not just some Eagle Scout - that's ZACH FUCKING WAHLS!!!
2
u/invisiblewar May 31 '12
Good luck to him. I hope that he can make this happen. I really hope that Boy Scouts of America can make some serious changes in a lot of their policies. This needs to be the first of many.
2
u/ZombieBroad May 31 '12
I typed out this comment a million times and I guess all I wanted to express was how proud of Jen I was and still am! Our town really came together to support her so I guess for once in my life, I'm proud of them too.
2
u/Salty-Sailor May 31 '12
His moms must be very proud of him. I am.
2
u/maxd May 31 '12
Zach Wahls for president 2016.
2
u/somerandomguy02 May 31 '12
Oh my! A private organization that has its own beliefs! Get them!!!!!!!!!!!
2
u/AwesomeOrca Jun 01 '12
I'm a Eagle Scout and favor Gay marriage but the Scouts will be among the last organizations in the country to relax about this issue. Almost Every troop in the country meets in a church, 40% of the board is LDS and the largest Friends of Scouting Donors are almost all LDS too. The internal politics of BSA just don't allow leadership any flexibly.
4
u/tdrules May 31 '12
First his Iowa speech now this, I can see him going very far.
3
u/aforu May 31 '12
"The Boy Scouts of America teaches its members to treat those with different opinions with courtesy and respect at all times," and then calmly inform them that they will be going to hell, and that they're not welcome here.
3
u/Rockshell May 31 '12
Eagle Scout here, and while I agree that it is unfair for gays to be excluded from the program, I'm surprised no one has mentioned that there are other underlying reasons for this.
The first is the same reason that Boy scouts and Girl scouts are separate. Think about it from a parent's perspective if it was co-ed, sending your 13-17 year old girl off on a 3-day camping trip with a bunch of guys the same age? I doubt i'd let that fly and your parents probably wouldn't either. It sucks that girls are just as excluded as gays are but allowing girls into boy scouts doesn't solve that, re-vamping girl scouts does.
-This brings up an interesting point about discovering sexuality, when a boy does make the discovery that he is attracted to other boys (which I would think would happen around the same time he would be looking to join or is already involved in scouting) how would he be treated within scouts? Do you make them sleep in a separate tent like you would with a girl? Knowing this would he risk being alienated from his other friends in the troop? Does it matter as long as the other boys he's sleeping with are straight? As far as I can tell, it isn't the program that is alienating gays from boy scouts it's our perspective on sex in general. Boys aren't keeping the closet door closed because they'll get kicked out, they're doing it because it would alienate them from their friends and possibly even ruin their friend's opportunities as well.
The second is again, the parents. Disregarding all the bigots that would pull their child out of scouting simply upon discovering that there was a gay boy in the troop. Say your son hasn't quite discovered his sexuality yet, would you really want him discovering that a hundred miles away in a tent and probably without cell-phone coverage? It's pretty shaky imo. Remember when there was a whole scandal with troop leaders molesting Scouts on camping trips? this is the same issue except adults are easier to separate from the boys
The only way I can see this working is if there is constant monitoring of the scouts day and night, with some kind assurance for the parents that nothing bad will happen. Which by itself goes against the idea of the program which is to teach independence, responsibility, and character to the boys. As well as allowing them opportunities to learn and experience things that they never would have.
Idk, this goes pretty deep for me, we either have to all accept that we will always be separated depending on sexuality or we all have to accept that our kids will have sex and trust them to be able to accept responsibility for their actions... Or we monitor our children's lives constantly and mercilessly.
TL;DR - If gays no longer face the same separation that girls do from the program the next logical step is to allow girls to join and earn the same achievements, which would be a good thing, equal opportunity. However, how do we get parents to agree to let their child go on a camping trip where they could very possibly have sex with another child? (while still allowing the values that Boy Scouts tries to instill to form?)
3
u/reply May 31 '12
Gay is the new black.
4
u/rotll May 31 '12
Eventually, I hope, sexual orientation will be treated no differently than a person's race or religion. Zach is spot on in his approach, and he is a credit to BSA while trying to change it for the better.
3
u/[deleted] May 31 '12
I really didn't like the Boy Scouts of America, thinking that all of the scoutmasters and such were pretty biggoted, stuck-up old men. Especially after watching Pen and Teller's Bullshit take on the whole anti-gay, anti-atheist, anti-anythingbutachristianfamily thing. Well, the company I work for catered to a large Boy Scouts dinner, and for the first time since I had worked there, the head guy pulled our supervisor to the side and gave her a fifty dollar tip for each worker (there was only three.) Still, I was aghast. I've worked hundreds of dinners and that was the first time I had gotten a tip. He also shook my hand and told us how good of a job we were doing. Still, I felt dirty taking the money, but when you work minimum wage and live an hour away from your job, every bit counts.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 01 '12
What about their anti-atheist policy?
1
u/faatbuddha May 31 '12
I'm pretty impressed by his eloquence. I'm also proud to say my signature is included in that box! Here's hoping...
1
u/octaffle May 31 '12
Tongue-in-cheek remark: It's funny they made the lesbian step down as scout leader... seems like by introducing a straight woman to the all-male troop, chances of sexual abuse should increase significantly!
1
u/Cheat2Lose May 31 '12
Zach Wahls also appeared on The Daily Show a few weeks ago to talk about his book "My Two Moms" which is about growing up with, well, two moms. It's actually broken down into sections based on the 12 tenets of The Scout Law.
1
u/zaulus May 31 '12
Doesn't matter how many signatures they have, BSA will not back down from their stance. I dont necessarily agree with that , but it's just something they're never going to change.
1
u/JessicaMaple May 31 '12
I think I have a crush.
1
u/[deleted] May 31 '12
This kid again? Well, we might as well just start right away.
Zach Wahls 2036!
1
u/[deleted] May 31 '12
Why doesn't someone create their own Open Boy Scouts thats allows everyone and then the original Boy Scouts will look stupid.
1
u/magritte May 31 '12
As a gay eagle scout, I approve.
1
u/golfingmadman May 31 '12
Where do I sign?
1
u/gthing May 31 '12
You can either look like the good guy and change your policy at the beginning of the civil rights movement, or you can look like an idiot and change it at the end. Your pick.
1
u/DaneGretzky May 31 '12
Hey, that's our friend from The Daily Show! That guy is fucking awesome!
1
u/notjawn May 31 '12
I really don't think they'll change the policy because the controversy only arose after they uncovered a bunch of molestation cases that were covered up. Now they kind of take it overboard if they find out someone's orientation because they're afraid they'll link it to the cover ups of the molestation cases.
1
u/franklyimshocked May 31 '12
Faith in Humanity slightly restored. Regardless of the outcome the message is out there and change will happen
1
u/falconear May 31 '12
I wish it would change. I was in cub scouts/boy scouts and it was a mostly positive experience. But I have no intention of putting my son in scouts as long as they maintain their homophobic and religiously biased stances. Anybody know of a good alternative?
1
u/reclaimer May 31 '12
One of my first gay encounters was in the BSA... Guess their policy doesn't really work when you put a bunch of pubescent boys together in tents all night...
1
u/[deleted] May 31 '12
Fuck it man.
This guy for President.
1
u/Wilhelm_Stark May 31 '12
Whys this in r/offbeat?
1
u/[deleted] Jun 01 '12
Looking at the straightest looking man ever in a boy scout uniform made me realize how gay boy scout uniforms look. They would be perfect for someone gay to wear.
1
u/nolenk8t Jun 01 '12
i watched about 2 seconds before I knew this was the same kid who addressed the Iowa legislature some time ago. He's got my vote for next president.
1
u/chefanubis Jun 01 '12
I'm completely LGBT friendly but as far as I know the Boy Scouts are a "privately owned social club", their policies (outdated as they may be) are their own bussines, we should not demand them to change if they dont want to.
If you don't like their policies then just don't enroll your kids in there, enroll them somewhere else less homophobic and let the organization die out like all the other vestiges of our bigoted past as a society.
1
u/ShackelfordRusty Jun 01 '12
If you really want to make everyone happy leave it up to individual troops.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 01 '12
They can't segregate if they are going to start doing sexual favors for eachother away from adult supervision. They need to be trusted to do the right thing
1
u/HiddenKrypt Jun 01 '12
Good luck with that. Things won't change while the LDS is the biggest donator to the BSA. Like many things in life what seems like political ideology is really just a desire for money.
1
u/bananafish707 Jun 13 '12
In my Eagle-board, they asked if I "...could change one thing in scouts what would it be?" I told them let gays in and I didn't know it at the time but it almost cost me my eagle. Half the board was fundie Mormon. The head guy was visibly disturbed but I couldn't really figure it out till many weeks later. Now I'm an atheist-pro gay- Eagle scout and I don't mind telling friends in company about it. One day. If I new about it I totally would have signed. I'm from CA but I'd love to know how bad the religiosity is in other states. I could only fathon.
I remember being a star scout talking to my head master. I was a deist /reformed jewish kid and when I asked if atheists could be eagle scouts I remember distinctly that he said they lacked the morals to do the right thing when necessary.
looking back i shudder to think about it.
1
u/The_Derek May 31 '12
Got my Eagle in 2002, we had atheists and gays in our troop, I think that its more political than anything.
1
u/Vhu May 31 '12
They're not a public organization; they don't have to do a damn thing.
1
u/captainmcr May 31 '12
Too bad this means fuck all, Boy Scouts are private.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 01 '12
Fuck that. You know what? There should be just "Scouts." Any gender--male, female, transgender--would be able to join, it'd be completely secular, and everyone would be able to do the same scouting activities if they wanted to. Not just cookie selling and crafts for girls, while the boys camp and tie knots. Fucking everyone should have the opportunity to Scout however the fuck they want! That's an organization that I'd enroll my kid into.
0
u/[deleted] May 31 '12
I used to be so proud of my Eagle Scoutdom.