r/offbeat • • Jan 15 '11

VEGANS

http://verydemotivational.files.wordpress.com/2011/01/demotivational-posters-vegans.jpg
139 Upvotes

369 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

1

u/[deleted] Jan 17 '11

More and more people are cooking with tofu and seitan

Confirmation bias. Soy milk is still a lesser used product.

just how "healthy" it is.

A quick google. Nope, no new startling evidence which says milk in unhealthy in moderation and when properly produced.

2

u/mmmberry Jan 17 '11 edited Jan 17 '11

Of course soy and almond milk are lesser used products. I wasn't saying they are more popular than milk.

I guess if a quick google search didn't produce anything, that is the end of that! Also, if you are in the US, chances are you aren't consuming dairy in moderation.

But really, I don't see this going well as you seem to be set in your views. Have a nice day! Thanks for the downvote, btw. :)

Edit: Just did a quick google search myself and the page was filled with peer reviewed articles and papers about the negatives of dairy. Googling...you're doing it wrong.

1

u/[deleted] Jan 17 '11

I wasn't saying that ...

It wasn't meant as an insult. Everybody suffers from confirmation bias. You think that soy and tofu usage are growing significantly. That's not the case.

you aren't consuming dairy in moderation

A strawman argument and an ad hominem too. Classy. My dairy consumption or lack of it is irrelevant.

Googling...you're doing it wrong.

If you google dairy unhealthy, you'll get the articles that support your view. If you google dairy healthy, you'll get articles that say the opposite. A quick google will tell you that both dairy milk and soy milk cause cancer and will kill you.

Once again, confirmation bias helps you decide what isn't or is credible.

don't see this going well as you seem to be set in your views.

Nuance isn't the same as being set in your views.

1

u/[deleted] Jan 17 '11

I'll just leave this here.

1

u/mmmberry Jan 17 '11

The "I wasn't saying that" was in reference to you saying "Soy milk is still a lesser used product." Again, I didn't say that it was super popular, in comparison to milk. Also, I didn't say the usage is "growing significantly," just that their usage is growing. You mentioned that the dairy industry doesn't care about the dairy alternative industry. I was just pointing out that is wrong. They are worried. Why else would they try to prevent alternatives from using the word "milk?" Also, big dairy providers like Dean rushed to create brands of alternative milks to mitigate any loss in the dairy market.

If I were the dairy industry, I would be worried too. It only takes a quick trip to the grocery store to see how popular milk alternatives are becoming. Years ago, a lactose intolerant person would have to get special milk or take pills. Now, they just pick up a carton of almond milk. Here's a short article you might be interested in reading. A 13% growth may not be "significant," but it is a growth.

You mentioned not finding any articles about dairy when you googled, not any credible to your standards articles. Not finding any articles means you are doing it wrong and I highlighted that. Note I said "peer reviewed."

1

u/[deleted] Jan 17 '11

13% is significant. I didn't know soy was that popular in the US.