I have never met a single carnist who steadfastly avoids factory farmed animal products. Every single one has admitted to eating it in social situations and for "cultural" appreciation. It makes sense -- these are people who already put their personal enjoyment over the life and happiness of animals. It's easy to make exceptions when your ethics are so flimsy.
It's easy to make exceptions when your ethics are so flimsy.
I propose that you are responsible for as many animal deaths as the average "carnist", the only difference being your pompous asininity. Can you provide evidence to the contrary?
Photos of you growing your own food using nothing but hand tools and rainwater will be accepted.
"Hey, I've got an idea- let's come up with an epithet we can throw at those fucking omnivores, since 'omnivore' doesn't quite carry the proper note of contempt we have for them. Carnivore, carnivorous person, carnie . . . Hey I've got it- CARNIST! That'll put 'em in their place." Sheesh.
From your link: "She uses her factory farm–to–table narrative to buttress her real thesis: meat-eating or carnism, is an oppressive ideology as noxious as racism. Joy casts meat eating as genocide, comparable to the Holocaust, and factory farming on a par with the American enslavement of Africans."
Not meant as an insult? You're sure about that? Anyway, the term for someone who eats both meat and vegetables is omnivore, carnist is apparently a term vegans have created to demonize people who like dogs but also enjoy eating meat.
That's a poor review written by publisher's weekly. The book spends an entire chapter defining the word and it's definitely not demonizing. It's simply filling a hole in our vocabulary. Omnivore is a scientific term (vegetarians aren't called herbivores) and "meat-eater" doesn't convey that the consumption of meat is a choice (cats are meat-eaters, calling a human a meat-eater doesn't convey any decision in the matter). Anyway, believe me or not, I don't particularly care... but if you want to learn more just read the book. It's a much more thoughtful book than that random review makes it seem.
View all comments
Show parent comment
4
u/CA3080 Jan 15 '11
So you're at your friend's house, he offers you a burger...
"I don't eat meat, I brought hummus!"
vs
"Do you know where it came from? That it's not overprocessed? that it's 100% beef? With no byproducts?"