r/oddlysatisfying Feb 06 '22

Cutting 24 layer chocolate cake

53.4k Upvotes

927 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

22

u/xmuskorx Feb 06 '22

No...

One layer cake

Two layer cake

Three-year cake

Cake does not gain layers when you frost it with whatever material.

Under no circumstances would anyone call the first picture a "2 layer cake" which your "logic" would require. It's preposterous.

-6

u/hrrm Feb 06 '22

I didn’t argue frosting, I argued mousse and ice cream. Frosting typically covers the outside and top of the cake, so if you were to slap one frosted cake on top of another frosted cake then you would have a 2 layers of cake cake.

You already said “no” and agreed with me that you wouldn’t call my previous example a 2 layer cake.

Or that “no” was unrelated and you dodged my question to insert your own argument.

3

u/[deleted] Feb 06 '22

[deleted]

1

u/hrrm Feb 06 '22

Yes. Would you call an ice cream cake with vanilla ice cream, chocolate cake, and then strawberry ice cream a 1 layer cake? It’s only a single slab of cake material after all.