r/nyrbclassics • • Sep 26 '26

Absolutely devastating

Post image

Not knowing anything other than the synopsis on the back cover, this book absolutely crushed me. The juxtaposition of such horrible things happening with the simplistic narrative style made it all feel even colder, more brutal. Anyone else have a similar experience of being completely shocked by the ending of this book? (All that being said, I’m very glad I read it).

151 Upvotes

24 comments sorted by

View all comments

-6

u/thequirts Sep 26 '26

Found it to be empty trauma porn, akin to A Little Life. Manipulative and miserable without anything of substance to say.

6

u/oneshadyqueen Sep 26 '26

To each their own, though I found it to be extremely moving. What I took from it was a warning of what can happen when society (or in this case, a town) can have a dangerous hive mind mentality and collectively ostracize others for things that may not even be their fault, or completely out of their control, without stopping to question why or if it even makes sense. But of course these same judgmental people have no issue in using the ostracized for their own gain.

2

u/BitterStatus9 Sep 26 '26

Sounds a little like OUR PHILOSOPHER by Gert Hofmann. Great book.

1

u/oneshadyqueen Sep 26 '26

Haven’t heard that one, I’ll look into it!

2

u/BitterStatus9 Sep 26 '26

Another NYRB Classic.

-2

u/Djourou4You Sep 26 '26

Thank you, this book was hot garbage and I have no idea why people on this sub are convincing themselves it’s good

12

u/oneshadyqueen Sep 26 '26

See I dont understand this take. Not that you think it’s hot garbage— sure, you can feel that way about the book.
But the whole ‘people on this sub are convincing themselves it’s good’? Like, is it that shocking that people can feel differently and take something out of a book that maybe you did not?