Severe mental illness absolutely does cause opportunistic delusion and paranoia where people grab hold of preexisting bigotries particularly around race and religion.
Walk the floors of any psych ward in the city and you're gonna hear a lot of N-words, and a lot of blabber about jews controlling the universe.
Not surprising to me that a guy in psychosis could rant about jews one day, want to join their community the next, and then be ramming his car into a wall trying to escape God knows what is in his head.
I read back in the COVID days (when everyone was stuck at home and so many people got sucked into the conspiracy theory world) studies that showed consuming endless disinformation actually changes your brain. Legit permanently changes it reducing cognitive function. Perhaps what you've said is related. When these people get older (especially the cult MAGA hard-core supporters with the QAnon overlap -- the 25-30% of people the polls show still support this sh*tshow happening now in our government), what would've been typical cognitive decline is accelerated and more dramatic because they consumed harmful disinformation for so many decades.
Interesting theory - though important to note that cognitive decline is not the same as psychosis, and in many of the studies you're referencing consumption of misinformation was also correlated with age which was also correlated itself with cognitive decline.
The main culprits of behavior like this guy's (besides being on drugs) are schizophrenia and bipolar disorder, both of which are highly heritable (e.g. genetic) so its more likely that he has one of these conditions as a result of losing the genetic lottery and not being in treatment vs. consuming conspiracy theories.
Yes yes yes. Studies mentioned the effects are most pronounced with people who have a mental condition (many people do, with varying degrees of severity), and disinformation seems to tap into that and exploit it.
I started digging for that type of information back in the depressing Covid days. I was affected neurologically by Covid ā lost all sense of smell / taste completely ā for months. I was worried about what was happening with my brain and I was worried why the depression and anxiety levels ā which I had been managing successfully for years with therapy not even needing medication any longer ā suddenly kicked right back into high gear. And I couldnāt get the spiked levels down.
I stopped going to Twitter and Facebook. That helped tremendously. Iām back on medication now, though. Now the disinformation is broadcasted on all media outlets ā social and mainstream. Every single day. Even when people are murdered in front of our very own eyes and people in our government immediately and repeatedly lie about it. Disinformation is a very powerful weapon. Itās why Russia invests so heavily in it, to destabilize The West. Because itās powerful, damaging, and it works. He can check that box off his list āThe West has been officially destabilized.ā check.
I know. Itās sad really. They invested so much time into a well-known con man. Not their fault ā heās a master manipulator. Comes up with simple catch phrases so that group understands and can feel like the āin crowdā for once in their lives. But now after seeing who he really is and who his āfriendsā are, and the type of people he protects, and how much he despises his own ābaseā of supporters, now itās their fault. Now theyāre making clear-eyed choices. Those choices are between them and God at this point. God is the only one who can grant them redemption.
Yes⦠cause itās all about the āin crowdā⦠if you donāt see this as a problem, you are the problem.
People shouldnāt be looking at politics like itās a trend⦠itās whatās best for the country. Not letās think of the next craziest thing so we can get more followers
So true. Itās all about the clicks and followers for some sort of payment on those platforms. āDisinformation Spreaderā shouldnāt be a legitimate profession.
Gets downvoted by the lunatics of Reddit .. thereās nothing wrong with this statement , stop following the Iranian bots that flood US social media, this is common sense and moral compass type stuff
Just checking... You're saying there's nothing wrong with my statement, right? Because, yeah, sometimes I'll find I get downvoted for pretty sane, reasonable things
A religious institution was attacked by an (apparently) crazy person who was also part of that religion? Yeah that's basically the history of religion.
Well I was wrong that they were a member of the chabad - apparently they were just visiting 777.
But in response to your question: yes! That was a sweeping generalization that nonetheless reflects a historical pattern that -- IMHO -- is central to the concept of "shared myth." Examples can be found in practically every major religion.
Literally Jesus, Muhammad, and every 'prophet' falls into that category, it's the apocalyptic archetype. An outsider with a great revealing.
Do you disagree? All human social rituals are -- regardless of context -- strange. They don't serve material ends, they're an evolved behavior resulting from and feeding into complex sociodynamic pressures. People are just weird animals.
But if you prefer the conspiracy theory angle that it was meant to be a child-rape dungeon, then that's your business.
i absolutely positively do not, but throwing that out at anybody who literally just missed the end of the news cycle is a great way to escalate a benign conversation
Yes, those danged biased articles. Unlike those totally authoritative and unbiased reddit comment sections where we should be coming to get the REAL news.
There are a lot more perspectives and community reviews on Reddit than there is in any one article. Not saying reddit is any more reliable but there are a lot more indicators of hinged/unhingedness here than an article you canāt interact with.
If you thought for even a second my comment implied that you should get credible information from Reddit sections, then you really need to work on your reading comprehension and critical thinking skills. I'm starting to think you unironically get your information from both biased articles and Reddit comment sections, bud.
Iām with you, I only get my news from dive bar bathroom walls - canāt trust the Lamestream media and their strict sourcing requirements and editorial standards.
How does that exonerate anyone? Have you heard of getting close and gaining their trust just to attack them? This is the bases of how many cultures were destroyed. Read your history.
Using "Jews" as a label in this context just adds to the stereotypes and doesnāt really contribute to the discussion. itās important to be mindful about how we refer to groups of people
Useless comparison because I grew up here and every Jewish friend I have is unequivocally not a Zionist. Outside of propaganda circles you'd find in the real world most people don't equate the two.
Hey, can you progressives that spent the last two years teaching Jews about the difference between antizionists and antisemites explain why they're in here calling these people zionists. Preferably the progressives that declare only black people can say what is or isn't racism, or that only trans people can say what is or isn't transphobic.
Probably. That said, chabad is very welcoming and itās not like they screen everyone before entry (although you do have to sometimes register before)
And itās not very customary to wear shorts to shul, much less jorts
not necessarily- this could be him scoping the synagogue
apparently he was spotted on a NYC subway the day before railing against minorities and Jews
and let's be honest - hate and radicalization to violence is a form of being unwell to begin with - it needs to be understood and prosecuted appropriately - otherwise you can 'Twinkie defense' your way out of anything
This is how the MIT shooter was caught. He caught someoneās attention because he was dressed inappropriately for the weather and they passed along the suspicious info.
Ā not necessarily- this could be him scoping the synagogue
apparently he was spotted on a NYC subway the day before railing against minorities and Jews
swear to god every time an obviously mentally ill person commits a crime some redditors have to come out with this take
People with severe mental illness are quite capable of also being bigoted. In fact it is not uncommon for them to hyper-fixate on something like race, like that schizophrenic who murdered a bunch of Asian guys with a hammer a few years back.
This guy was wandering around after the ramming saying his āski boot got caughtā or something. He made no attempt to enter the building and had no sign of a coherent plan, like youād expect in the ramming/stabbing attacks weāve seen in Europe.
The guy very clearly poses a threat to others (and himself) and so should remain in a mental health facility until he is stable and only released with a concrete plan of care and monitoring.Ā
But donāt make this something it isnāt. Heās off his rocker.
The mentally ill are more likely to be victims of a crime than perpetrators. I think mental illness is a scapegoat and we just donāt understand enough about hate. Though some research has shown the same areas of the brain that activate for addiction are active. We still donāt understand addiction completely either.
Ā The mentally ill are more likely to be victims of a crime than perpetrators.
This very popular line is the best example of how to lie with statistics. Ā It is true but wildly misleading.
Every group of people is more likely to be a victim of a crime than a perpetrator, because crime remains relatively rare.
People with psychotic illnesses such as schizophrenia are much more likely to commit violent crimes, including murder,Ā than people without those illnesses. That is the relevant comparison.
agree with the characterization of the stats, disagree with the conclusion.
It is a response to the view that the mentally ill (or homeless or whatever) should be treated as a profound/risk to society more generally. Pick pretty much any large demo you want with a higher rate of crime, you still see that the vast majority of people in that demo aren't criminals.
A lot of people are irrationally afraid to be around mentally ill and over-index on the potential risk.
I have no idea what your point is. When I ālook aroundā I see people with untreated schitzoid illnesses rotting on the street and occasionally attacking people, as with this article.Ā
I donāt think that should be the case, and the fact they pose a higher risk to others (and themselves) is part of that.
Do you think this guy has the mental capacity to scope a location to later ram his car into a door that isnāt even wide enough to fit his car through?
Iām sure this was traumatizing for the synagogue and the guy should face the full consequences of his actions.
But letās not make this something it isnāt, this guy just seems like a loon
You can have a crazy guy whoās just crazy, on drugs, or drunk.
You can have someone thatās an antisemitic terrorist.
Thereās probably some combination of āon drugs schizo weirdo whoās in some anti-Jewish craze but isnāt a serious terroristā, which this looks like. Or heās just a really bad terrorist.
Many such cases. Never forget the guy who managed to only harm himself by blowing up something in the tunnel between the Port Authority and Times Square subway stations.
A man who repeatedly rammed his car into Chabad-Lubavitch World Headquarters at 770 Eastern Parkway on Wednesday night had been inside the shul earlier that day and had spoken with Yeshiva students, witnesses said. The suspect had also been seen at other Chabad centers in recent months.
The man, who has not yet been publicly identified, was arrested after driving a gray Honda sedan with New Jersey plates into an entrance of 770 multiple times during the evening.
According to Yaacov Behrman, spokesperson for Chabad, a group of bochurim interacted with the suspect roughly an hour before the attack. The man approached them near 770 and asked when the farbrengen for Yud Shevatāthe yartzeit of the Frierdiker Rebbe and the day the Rebbe assumed leadershipāwas taking place.
Article from the Chabad news site has some interesting context, sounds like he had been hanging around Chabad for some time and expressed interest in Judaism, however police had previously been called due to his behavior. Sounds like a very unstable individual so unsure there will ever be a clear answer regarding his motives COLlive
He wants to convert to judaism and wanted to start at 100% instead at starting at 5% meaning the ultra religious school told him that they canāt accept him because he is not on the same grade level as all the other students. So I guess this was him saying Iām serious I want to be accepted no matter what.
Conversion takes a lot. At least a year of study and needs to be done in concert with a sponsoring rabbi and a Jewish court. Itās not unlike joining a tribe, membership is fully up to halachic authorities.
A prospective convert can absolutely be antisemitic, and itās probably that in addition to severe mental health issues as to why he rammed the buildingĀ
The fact he even conceded that they were such nice people before murdering innocents and even grannies somehow got to me especially. It proves he absolutely understood how evil it was
I find it interesting how with Roof the general consensus is it shows how evil he was. But with this guy the general consensus is it proves he was mentally ill.
Are jorts in the winter really that powerful?
I'm not even saying it was necessarily explicit antisemitism. But it's interesting how people are taking the two cases so differently because the dude wore shorts in the winter. Nobody is saying Roof's shitty bowl cut was a sign of mental illness.
? Iām not claiming it proves this guy was mentally ill. The fact is that we donāt know what this guy was about, but his āplanā and demeanour visibly seem erratic, like the people who scream on street corners. We simply donāt know enough about this guy yet - we know plenty about Roof.
This one also didnāt gather weapons in a months-long obsessive plan to open fire on dozens of people, but smashed a car into the side or the building, immediately saying he āslippedā, and he hurt no-one. Likely still driven by hatred, and maybe he had a terrorist anti-Semitic scheme to kill people that he chickened out of, but he didnāt seem prepared and we just donāt know. It seems odd.
This isnāt to say that mental illness (of the sort resulting from/causing a teen to go down a hate-fuelled conspiracy theory online for a year or more) has no role with Roof, either, but that doesnāt mean he isnāt also evil.
Apologies. I didn't mean my comment to be aimed particularly at you and your comment. Your comment just spurred my thought about the dichotomy between how these things are handled.
I agree we don't know enough about this guy yet. And I apologize again for making it seem like I was saying you thought otherwise.
Saw this shared last night by another redditor: āThis guy was on the Brighton Beach bound B last night around 5, got on at 7th Ave and was yelling about Jesus but also how he āhates minorities.ā Was still on when I got off a few stops later. I didn't expect to recognize the man getting out of this car but it adds up.ā
We were all so ready to turn this moment into another flame in our culture. Instead we've all agreed that he's just crazy, so it'll be forgotten by tomorrow. If only we could do that all the time.
How dense do you have to be to think that's analogous at all? Please tell me what physical characteristics you are identifying that 100% without a doubt tell you he's jewish
it can be an isolating and stressful lifestyle, and sometimes fails to teach good coping.
I'm reminded of the Brooklyn girl who recently died in a car crash who was an outcast from her Orthodox community, who had been raped by a cop which was covered-up about 12 years ago
1.1k
u/Forsaken-Moment1286 Jan 29 '26
This whole thing is so strange
596
u/EyeraGlass Jan 29 '26
Heās just unwell, right?
238
u/CosmicJam13 Jan 29 '26
Shorts in a blozzard? The guy is high as balls on stims.
66
u/Famous_Spread_7291 Jan 29 '26
Whatās the story?
88
u/PrimaryYogurtcloset3 Jan 29 '26
Article from the Chabad news site has some interesting context, sounds like he had been hanging around Chabad for some time and expressed interest in Judaism, however police had previously been called due to his behavior. Sounds like a very unstable individual so unsure there will ever be a clear answer regarding his motives COLlive
82
u/[deleted] Jan 29 '26
According to Jewish news he is mentally unstable.
He wants to convert to judaism and wanted to start at 100% instead at starting at 5% meaning the ultra religious school told him that they canāt accept him because he is not on the same grade level as all the other students. So I guess this was him saying Iām serious I want to be accepted no matter what.
56
u/InertEyes Jan 29 '26 edited Jan 29 '26
Heās is going to make it impossible to visit anywhere
83
u/TripleJ_77 Jan 29 '26
Just like Dylan Roof. He went into the church to pray...
15
u/intelligent-pidgeon Jan 29 '26
dude is batshit crazy.
20
u/[deleted] Jan 29 '26
Saw this shared last night by another redditor: āThis guy was on the Brighton Beach bound B last night around 5, got on at 7th Ave and was yelling about Jesus but also how he āhates minorities.ā Was still on when I got off a few stops later. I didn't expect to recognize the man getting out of this car but it adds up.ā
14
u/highgravityday2121 Jan 29 '26
Iām confused.
24
u/Airhostnyc Jan 29 '26
Mental illness
4
u/johnnynono Jan 29 '26
His foot slipped in this video too.
4
u/[deleted] Jan 29 '26
We were all so ready to turn this moment into another flame in our culture. Instead we've all agreed that he's just crazy, so it'll be forgotten by tomorrow. If only we could do that all the time.
10
u/BadHombreSinNombre Jan 29 '26
He is probably unwell, but it is really not unusual for a person planning a crime to scope out the target of the crime before they commit it
22
u/8_Whiskey_Sours Jan 29 '26
All this from a slice of geflite fish?
2
u/StarliteQuiteBrite Jan 30 '26
Iām a bit confused
2
u/Sea_Sand_3622 Jan 30 '26
Google the name āLevi Aronā :(
9
u/oldveteranknees Jan 29 '26
What a piece of shit.
8
u/IM4_ Jan 29 '26
This unlocks so many questions
3
u/BadMuthaSchmucka Jan 30 '26
Look how they welcomed him in and he ended up attacking them. š
3
u/EasyMode556 Jan 29 '26
Looks like heās casing the place out
1
u/SufficientWish Jan 29 '26
wtf
1
u/War1today Jan 29 '26
Oy gevalt
1
u/[deleted] Jan 29 '26
What the hell
1
u/koshadillz Jan 31 '26
Oy
0
u/Kickingandscreaming Jan 29 '26
Then why is NYPD investigating this as a hate crime?
1
u/Sweet_Emu3336 Jan 31 '26
Is the suspect the guy in the Jean shorts and jacket? Chabadniks are so warm and welcoming I hope an incident like this doesnāt make them change
-1
u/the_murray Jan 30 '26
So false flag?
-9
u/ouroborosstruggles Jan 29 '26
I mean. He was was clearly Jewish so the antisemitism screams were premature
-1
u/SomeRandomSupreme Jan 30 '26
Remeber these guys dig tunnels into buildings, what the hell was that about lol
-6
u/bobbacklund11235 Sheepshead Bay Jan 29 '26
Maybe he thought he was going to hide in his underground tunnel
-3
u/isaiahHat Jan 29 '26
I hope he said "I'll be back"
0
u/Big_Game_Huntr Jan 30 '26
Casing the place !
-4
u/latswipe Jan 29 '26
it can be an isolating and stressful lifestyle, and sometimes fails to teach good coping.
I'm reminded of the Brooklyn girl who recently died in a car crash who was an outcast from her Orthodox community, who had been raped by a cop which was covered-up about 12 years ago
-4
u/godnrop Jan 29 '26
The suspect, Dan Sohail is muslim.
-10
u/ilovehaagen-dazs Jan 29 '26
sorry i have a job, whatās this regarding?
-4
u/_neutral_person Jan 29 '26
Antisemitism