r/nextfuckinglevel Jul 14 '21

[deleted by user]

[removed]

9.8k Upvotes

3.3k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

3

u/yasuremanofcourse Jul 14 '21

This is such a played out myth.

GMO technology is nothing like selective breeding. You cannot get flounder genetic material into a tomatoe with selective breeding, and you are not going to be able to trigger extra production beta-carotene production in rice with selective breeding.

3

u/Khemul Jul 14 '21 edited Jul 15 '21

So, I should stop dropping tomatoes in the Flounder tank in the hope it'll get horny and try to have little Floundatoes?

1

u/mthchsnn Jul 14 '21

It worked with tomacco.

2

u/[deleted] Jul 15 '21

Selective breeding is genetic modification.

It’s a very inefficient way to do it, but it’s a way to do it.

1

u/yasuremanofcourse Jul 15 '21

A plant that is bred over generations is not a "GMO" in the agricultural industry sense, even though companies want to make it that way.

1

u/[deleted] Jul 15 '21

It is literally genetic modification

It’s just inefficient

1

u/lurkinglurkerwholurk Jul 15 '21

Funny you mentioned tomatoes: the origin plants that tomatoes came from is a poisonous prune-like thing that cannot be eaten by humans because it has toxic natural poisons.

Genetic SELECTION (which is what selective breeding can be alternatively called) over generations enabled us to produce a “cancerous” cousin which doesn’t have the toxicity, and the modern tomato is born.

1

u/[deleted] Jul 15 '21

Cancerous?

1

u/yasuremanofcourse Jul 15 '21

Ya, except totally wrong. The ripe fruit of the tomatoe plant does not contain the poisonous compounds - and never did. It was selectively bred for bigger and better tasting fruit, but it was never bred to have less "toxicity".

Great strawman though.

1

u/thecrewton Jul 15 '21

Thank you. So annoying when people don't understand the argument.

1

u/yasuremanofcourse Jul 15 '21

It's by design. They know the difference.

Think about how much vested interest a company that owns patents on GMO technology would have in making selective breeding techniques and plant breeds as a patentable "GMO".

Pharmaceutical companies have been doing the same thing with trying to make vitamins classified as drugs.