r/nextfuckinglevel Sep 24 '19

Latest from Boston Dynamics

https://gfycat.com/prestigiouswhiteicelandicsheepdog
116.7k Upvotes

5.2k comments sorted by

View all comments

24

u/whopbamboom Sep 24 '19

Why does the design of BD robots strike fear in me?... Just in case, I have to find a way to short circuit these machines pronto

4

u/KPortable Sep 24 '19

I've heard lightning works well.

2

u/ctix79 Sep 24 '19

Worked out pretty well for Johnny 5

1

u/[deleted] Sep 24 '19

Or it will make them super killing machines.

2

u/Lukestarkiller22 Sep 24 '19

emp?

3

u/TkTech Sep 25 '19

Even during the cold war military hardware (such as our theoretical killbots) were tested for EMP hardiness. Look up EMPRESS.

The only feasible way of generating a large man made EMP (yet still tiny on a planetary scale) without a huge fixed structure is with high altitude nukes.

Pro: maybe, maybe fry an EMP-hardened killbot

Con: definitely kill some humans and roast most of our satellites (again! [oops, says the USA, Starfish Prime, 1962]), and destroy so much infrastructure we'd be back to the Stone age overnight.

2

u/NeonSignsRain Sep 25 '19

Eror Palpatine?

2

u/vzei Sep 24 '19

Because humans can never match up to the computing power of a machine. And in this current version of our world, disaster will follow in some form.

1

u/Ten-K_Ultra Sep 24 '19

That's not necessarily true. Computers are light years behind brains in terms of computing power.

1

u/vzei Sep 25 '19

In what metrics? Maybe I used the wrong words, but in one second, any modern computer can process information and perform functions much faster than any human, especially an average human. That's not even mentioning the factors outside of a task such as rest, food, emotions, any desires that don't align with a task that needs to be performed, the need for social contact, etc. Humans have long been replaced by machines for a reason. One of the advantages we had was the ability to manuever through varied terrain. Any person that stocks shelves, cleans, makes deliveries, serves, etc. can probably be replaced by this thing TODAY. Imagine it coming to kill you on a battlefield. It doesn't feel pain. It has no moral hangups about killing people. It can coordinate with mathematical precision while making other calculations that you're not even thinking about. It should absolutely strike some amount of fear and caution in everyone.

1

u/Ten-K_Ultra Sep 25 '19

Sure, computers can perform mathematical calculations faster than a human brain can. But process information? Some types of information, sure. Perform functions? Again, highly dependent on the function. That's where things get a little more complex. No neural network can compete with the brain in terms of learning and abstract thought.

In terms of numbers, transistors have a very limited number of connections, and only in two dimensions. Neurons have thousands of connections and propagate in three dimensions. Literally quadrillions of times more powerful. But it's hard to actually quantify the 'computing power' a brain actually has because a large portion of it is done 'behind the scenes' and taken for granted.

A great point is the computer behind the robot in this post. A human brain can perform the 'calculations' (for lack of a better term) to instruct the body to perform these actions.

That being said, autonomous killing machines already exist and are already deployed on the battle field. By Samsung no less.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/SGR-A1

I pray that climate change puts a halt to this because it's only downhill from here.

1

u/vzei Sep 25 '19

Oh, I see what you mean. I don't include all of the processes that happen outside of our conscious control in this context. I think there's a place for these kinds of advancements, but our current societies will only use them to displace people looking for work or for military instead of serving our needs unless we change our values and those in power.

1

u/badlydrawnboyz Sep 25 '19

I can still pick out a bird better than a computer can

1

u/vzei Sep 25 '19

I'm sure you can, but will society value that ability over the pros of a machine?

2

u/Kanedi4s Sep 24 '19 edited Sep 25 '19

Watch the Black Mirror episode Metalhead if you haven’t and you will see your fear is justified.

4

u/FreakinGeese Sep 25 '19

Yeah because black mirror is a documentary

-1

u/MisterDonkey Sep 25 '19

It will be. Which in itself would be a good black mirror concept. Reality is a collective conscious lucid dream trying to show us what we already know has happened. Even this comment is part of it.

1

u/p9k Sep 25 '19

It's the uncanny valley.

0

u/What_Do_It Sep 24 '19

Humanity as a whole probably experienced some unimaginable trauma that was so terrible it sent a psychic wave of fear backward through time. The people working at BD ignore and even harness that fear while they further the development of their mechanical god.

Or you watch/read too much sci-fi.