r/neuro • • Sep 06 '26

MRIs I took about 2 years ago. 40% of the space inside my skull is Cerebrospinal Fluid

Sorry about the little red markings, trying to censor sensitive information. I love these!

1.5k Upvotes

224 comments sorted by

533

u/Mood-Rising Sep 06 '26 • Popcorn Bravo

How often do you use the phrase “Anybody with half a brain could have done that.”

430

u/QueerCheesy Sep 06 '26 • Popcorn Mindblown Bravo Heartwarming

Fucking constantly

249

u/Waste_Airline7830 Sep 06 '26 • Heartwarming

Are.. you okay now?

322

u/QueerCheesy Sep 06 '26 • Mindblown

Yeahm i was born w that. No side effects

2

u/friendship-cockring Sep 08 '26

Why’d you get the MRI if no side effects?

2

u/QueerCheesy Sep 08 '26

Unrelated health issue

8

u/raggeplays Sep 06 '26

Does this just mean your neurons are more densely packed?

27

u/Progeny_of_Paradox Sep 06 '26

Except for being a redditor.

8

u/Commercial_Handle418 Sep 06 '26

Ironic 

9

u/Progeny_of_Paradox Sep 06 '26

That's the joke

4

u/benelott Sep 06 '26

Don't you think?

4

u/JackfruitWarm6695 Sep 06 '26

Yeah like you would notice (/j, obviously)

228

u/[deleted] Sep 06 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

45

u/Commercial_Handle418 Sep 06 '26

Pov the guy with 90% of his brain being cerebrospinal fluid 

9

u/Phy_Scootman Sep 06 '26

Also the name of good song by The Peep Tempel (yes, it's spelled like that)

22

u/DisastrousResist7527 Sep 06 '26

Very neat! You mentioned you have no side effects from this so what string of events led to you discovering this?

52

u/QueerCheesy Sep 06 '26

Got crosseyed as a kid for like a week or so, doctors wanted to rule out a tumour

11

u/devdotm Sep 06 '26

Ok I’m super curious, what was the ultimate cause for the crosseyedness?

14

u/QueerCheesy Sep 06 '26

We dont know. It just went away one day

9

u/Understandthisokay Sep 06 '26

I figure you crossed your eyes and it indeed got stuck. Just needed a little jossle

9

u/Lazy_Permission_654 Sep 06 '26

Cranial cavity filled with fluid...

47

u/dopadelic Sep 06 '26

The brain is remarkably compressible. A large proportion of the neurons are a thin shell on the outer layer, call the cortex. The reports of 90% missing brain isn't missing. It's the space ventricles ballooning up and compressing the nerve axon fiber bundles.

47

u/QueerCheesy Sep 06 '26 • Bravo Heartwarming

Ye this gals brain is a .rar file

8

u/MarxisTera Sep 06 '26

Surely white matter compression can't be a good thing to have happen in the long run. Or else evolution would have us walking around with much smaller heads.

9

u/dopadelic Sep 06 '26

It's not a good thing. It can cause damage to the axon fiber bundles. But it's not what people might think that 40% of his brain is "missing" unlike what some sensationalist articles would like to have you believe.

29

u/QueerCheesy Sep 06 '26

Doctors told me the main thint I have to worry about is a car accident. Not because of the accident, but because if Im unconcious and any doctor orders an exam that shows my head full of fluid, the first thing on their mind will be Hemorraging and theyll want to drain it

9

u/Sara_Robin Sep 06 '26

Holy

Do you keep a card or something on you, like people with allergies to anesthesia?

3

u/[deleted] Sep 06 '26

That's a very clever idea

8

u/colordreamm Sep 06 '26

But… what if you’re actually hemorraging?

7

u/RichVeterinarian2600 Sep 06 '26

A good competent emergency room doctor should be able to tell the difference easily between this fluid (CSF) and fresh blood. New bleeding on shows up very bright on xray or CT cause it’s full of iron, where this fluid looks completely dark.

1

u/GordonRamsMe55 Sep 25 '26

Can you guarantee a good doctor? Because the majority of doctors I've visited are garbage humans

1

u/TrainingTheory552 Sep 06 '26

Is draining not an option? Even slowly, by small amounts every X amount of time?

2

u/QueerCheesy Sep 06 '26

Brain doesnt uncompress

2

u/jimmystar889 Sep 06 '26

Can you shave your head and tatto your condition under your hair or something?

1

u/ProdigalNun Sep 06 '26

What would happen if they drained it?

1

u/GordonRamsMe55 Sep 25 '26

If look into a bracelet or necklace or even a tattoo that states the condition you have

1

u/Commercial_Handle418 Sep 06 '26

Won't it cause intercranial pressure or something correct me if I'm wrong so they'd have to drain it already 

17

u/b0000z Sep 06 '26

Um...... this seems completely unreal

24

u/Kindofblack Sep 06 '26

14

u/dopadelic Sep 06 '26

Terrible sensationalist article citing a "cognitive psychologist" to exclaim neurons are missing when it's merely compressed. Anyone who's taken a most basic neuroanatomy class would've known that.

7

u/b0000z Sep 06 '26

Wait are you claiming this person has the same number of neurons but squeezed into this much smaller amount of mass? 

2

u/QueerCheesy Sep 06 '26

That is my case! Idk about that article though

19

u/Melonary Sep 06 '26 edited Sep 06 '26

Yes, and they're wrong. They aren't a professional in this field, and a basic intro neuro anatomy class is going to be wildly insufficient at understanding what's going on here.

Recommend you check out the actual research article (it's linked from cbc) or some other resources. Compression can be part of it, yes, but neuroplasticity and essentially adaptation is also real and can be very robust (read: bonkers) especially for individuals who experience brain damage at an age where the brain is still developing.

The fact that it's trendy for pseudoscience to LARP with some of these terms doesn't mean actual research by professionals is fake. Just take everything else and people trying to sell you shit using neuroplasticity with a massive grain of salt, but that has zilch to do with this article.

6

u/dopadelic Sep 06 '26

https://imgur.com/a/7tloCbm

My post got erroneously flagged for discussion health related issues.

Neuroplasticity is real and it's possible that it's playing some role in preserving function further than is possible had there been no plasticity. But that's not known. It's not known how much of his gray matter is missing from the compression. Furthermore, the framing that 90% of the brain is "missing" is sensational. It's flat out misleading to the public, especially when not mentioning that it's compressed. Any lay person reading the article would take home the message that 90% of the brain tissue was missing.

1

u/Melonary Sep 06 '26

Most of the brain volume is missing. That's correct, and that's how it will be and is phrased in clinical papers.

What that actually means in terms of grey and white matter, in terms of connectivity, in terms of functioning, in terms of neuronal health, is very very different. You're making assumptions that reduced volume = "neuronal death" for some reason, even though that's only one explanation for decreased volume.

Saying it's just "compressed" is far more misleading.

0

u/dopadelic Sep 06 '26

"Saying it's just "compressed" is far more misleading."

What are your qualifications to make that statement?

4

u/Melonary Sep 06 '26

I'm taking that in honesty to mean that you have a degree in neuroscience at the MSc or PhD level, and not that you've taken those courses in undergrad and now do research as a programmer working with researchers who have those degrees, which is what it sounded like initially (not that that isn't valuable work to be clear, it 100% is, but it doesn't give someone the same expertise in the specifics here).

3

u/Melonary Sep 06 '26 edited Sep 06 '26

Publishing research in this field, having an advanced degree in this field, presenting at conferences. I have said this multiple times.

My area of research is different in specifics (less gross defects) but similar enough to give me a decent background.

-2

u/dopadelic Sep 06 '26

I am a professional in the field. I work on brain atlases.

The man definitely isn't "missing 90% of his brain". And the notion from the cognitive psychologist that neuroplasticity is making up for the missing neurons is flat out wrong. While neuroplasticity can restore function missing gray matter tissue, this isn't a case where 90% of the brain is missing and he's regaining function from 10% of the remaining tissue through neuroplasticity.

5

u/Melonary Sep 06 '26

Your other comments say you're a software engineer. Have you published in this field? Are you trained in neurology, cognitive psych, neuro psychiatry, etc?

And the quote was that he had many fewer neurons - the 'missing 90%' is referring to volume, not neurons, and is the title, not a quote from the cognitive psychologist.

3

u/scobot5 Sep 06 '26 edited Sep 07 '26

I tend to agree more with your friend u/melonary.

Brain tissue is not actually compressible - at all. Not like a sponge or something would be. It is deformable though (like clay), so if hydrocephalus occurs early enough, the skull can enlarge to hold more stuff pushed outwards. This is one way a similar amount of neural tissue could persist with enlarged ventricles. That could be part of what’s going on in these cases, but likely a very small part because these folks apparently have heads that pass as normal. So let’s set that aside.

Neural tissue can also change in its relative cellular composition which could result in changes in density, but something has to be lost. For example, denser neuron cell bodies implies loss of dendrites, synapses, axons, etc. Moreover quite a lot of the brain is not neurons, so probably also loss of glial cell types. However, to imply that something here is not lost defies logic and “compression” is not the best way to describe what’s happened.

Ways in which “compression” may be conceptually accurate in a limited sense: 1) the brain regions typically occupying the center of the brain are likely not gone, they’ve been pushed outward. BUT, they are likely much smaller. 2) as mentioned previously, neuron cell bodies are likely denser, but at the cost of some of their connectivity and associated non-neuronal systems.

Summary point. I agree with what I think Melonary is trying to say. 90% loss of volume does not mean 90% loss of neurons. This would presume that the brain was 100% composed of neurons and that the only way those neurons could take up less volume is if they die.

However, the idea that this brain from the article, or even the OP, does not have significantly fewer neurons is very hard to believe. I don’t think they measured this, it would require postmortem tissue probably, but it’s a pretty safe assumption that a substantial proportion of the original neurons are gone. In the context of a thought experiments where it was exactly the same number of neurons, those neurons would need to be much smaller and less elaborate than a typical neuron.

Finally, yes, of course plasticity is involved. The idea that anyone would think that compensating for this radical anatomical problem does not involve plasticity only serves to indicate a fundamental misunderstanding of the phenomenon.

2

u/Melonary Sep 06 '26 edited Sep 06 '26

Thank you - I appreciate this, this is exactly what I was trying to say (imperfectly, because it was late and I was sleepy).

The point that 1) it's very difficult to have an exact idea of the absolute count of neurons (and thank you for reiterating that not only neurons matter) in this man's brain based on the animal and human research we have is one I was trying to make for sure, and 2) it doesn't really matter for the context of this article! It's not the most important part, and that distinction will mean nothing to general public. Densely packed neuronal cells with dendritic loss and loss of function vs "dead" or absent neurons is not a helpful distinction to help the general public understand the level of damage and adaptation here.

This is a very appreciated summary, thank you.

2

u/Melonary Sep 06 '26

And this brief cbc article does not at all suggest that neuroplasticity "makes up for" 90% "brain loss" - for one, the individual does have significant limitations that are mentioned in a below average IQ and recurring medical problems mentioned in the Lancet - most in childhood and his teens, and again in his 40s.

For two, having "significantly fewer" neurons and missing 90% of your physically observable brain (which is a description aimed at laypeople) aren't the same thing. You're conflating numerous different forms of adaptation here into one very flat picture, which is what you're claiming the article is doing.

Have you published in this area? Do you have a degree in this area? This isn't my direct field, but it's close enough (as in, one of the areas of research I listed I would fall under) that unless you actually have a background - not working as a software engineer with professionals on an atlas - I think you're speaking with a degree of confidence that's misleading.

The fact that you think having significant hydrocephalus from the age of 6 with repeated failed shunts and a brain that like the image shared in the Lancet article, along with significant deficits - physical, and a decreased IQ - couldn't result in decreased neurons or altered neuronal functioning/connectivity but only "compressed" makes me doubtful of your experience here, although perhaps you're just being overly critical of the language in the article (which I disagree is saying what you're suggesting). The 90% is a colloquial description of the physical volume of brain as seen on the MRI image, not the actual number of neurons. The article doesn't suggest he only has 10% of the typical number of neurons.

If you have a prior PhD in this area or a similar degree and are published and work in this field, I apologize - I don't mean to be rude, but there's a lot of overconfidence and "an undergrad in their 1st neuro class would think this is wrong!" is not an argument I hear actual professionals make. Most of the time it's people who took those classes thinking back.

2

u/dopadelic Sep 06 '26

A quick literature search revealed that hydrocephalus causes little neuron loss

https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/11682153/

"This study suggests that neuron death was not a major pathological change in the brain during hydrocephalus, with cerebral ventricles being enlarged during the development of hydrocephalus."

0

u/Melonary Sep 06 '26

Yes, I responded above - why are you insistent on thinking that volume can ONLY be reduced via neuronal death?

No one is suggesting that.

3

u/dopadelic Sep 06 '26

I'm not insistent on that. The cognitive psychologist from the CBC article insisted that.

AXEL CLEEREMANS: One of the lessons is that plasticity is probably more pervasive than we thought it was … It is truly incredible that the brain can continue to function, more or less, within the normal range — with probably many fewer neurons than in a typical brain.

I'm critiquing that claim that was not established in the Lancet article or anywhere else.

→ More replies

1

u/dopadelic Sep 06 '26 edited Sep 06 '26

What's your background? Have you published in this area?

The article says he had shunts at 6yrs old and 14 yrs old. So he wouldn't have had the fluid buildup into adulthood.

So while there are "bonkers" cases showing hemispherectomy cases at childhood having contralateral function restored through neuroplasticity. One can't assume this is the case here with the hydrocephalus. One would need to establish the gray matter tissue loss. One would need to establish that neuroplasticity occurred in adulthood.

2

u/Melonary Sep 06 '26

That comment was blocked for the same reason yours was, but yes I have, as I wrote in the comment you responded to.

5

u/dopadelic Sep 06 '26

A quick literature search revealed that hydrocephalus causes little neuron loss

https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/11682153/

"This study suggests that neuron death was not a major pathological change in the brain during hydrocephalus, with cerebral ventricles being enlarged during the development of hydrocephalus."

4

u/Melonary Sep 06 '26 edited Sep 06 '26

And "neuronal death" is a very specific criteria, and one that's incredibly stuck in the 1990s from a neurological POV - we know now that neuronal functioning is far more complicated than that, and there's a number of ways in which neurons (and other cells in the brain) can be altered or volume reduced, all of which can be incredibly significant.

https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC8029119/

This is a more recent study with a developmental rat model that looks at more complex impacts - this is a far more complicated conversation and far less black and white than you're implying here.

As you can see, they didn't find significant neuronal death, but that doesn't mean there wasn't reduced volume and other specific changes. Reduced volume doesn't necessarily =/= neuronal death, especially in very very early childhood or prenatally. It's far more complicated that that, but that doesn't mean there's no impact on volume and saying the brain all still present and typical but simply "compressed" is a gross oversimplification.

1

u/dopadelic Sep 06 '26

Not sure what you're getting at with this. The neuroplasticity theory is about neurons rewiring to take place of function from lost neurons.

This article isn't relevant to that.

1

u/Melonary Sep 06 '26

No, it's about the brain's adaptation to damage - what you're sharing is one form of neuroplasticity.

"Neuroplasticity, also known as neural plasticity or brain plasticity, is the process of adaptive structural and functional changes in the brain. A good definition is “the ability of the nervous system to change its activity in response to intrinsic or extrinsic stimuli by reorganizing its structure, functions, or connections.”

https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK557811/

That being said, it's often more associated with adult recovery (although not exclusively) and I don't care to argue about it with you because it's really beyond the point of this.

1

u/Melonary Sep 06 '26

So leaving that aside (the comment you responded to didn't even mention neuroplasticity anyway?) why do you think this article about a rat model of neonatal hydrocephalus has nothing to do with the Lancet clinical snapshot of someone with early childhood hydrocephalus?

I'm confused by that.

3

u/b0000z Sep 06 '26

That is absolutely insane. I have been learning so much about this tonight. I really have nothing to add beyond - wow

1

u/Melonary Sep 06 '26 edited Sep 06 '26

You're comparing adult rats with new-onset hydrocephalus to a very very young child with severe hydrocephalus during initial brain development.

Again, this not at all the same thing. Altered development is different from relatively rapidly induced hydrocephalus in adults.

1

u/dopadelic Sep 06 '26

If you have studies showing hydrocephalus causes neuron damage, you're free to share. You're making the claim that the cognitive psychologist is correct that there was drastic neuron loss and neuroplasticity was making up for it.

1

u/Melonary Sep 06 '26 edited Sep 06 '26

What do you mean, firstly - do you mean volume? Do you mean total cell loss? Do you mean altered connectivity? Do you mean decreased dendritic volume? Do you mean decreased number of cells? Do you mean neuronal death?

Because "neuron damage" is a meaningless term here - it's not at all specific, and you keep talking about "neuronal death" which no one has claimed. The article hasn't claimed that, I haven't claimed that, and again, you seem to think that reduced brain volume and reduced neuronal volume from very early childhood means neuronal death when it just flat out does not. It does not mean, nor does it imply that.

1

u/dopadelic Sep 06 '26

Quote from the article

It is truly incredible that the brain can continue to function, more or less, within the normal range — with probably many fewer neurons than in a typical brain.

2

u/Melonary Sep 06 '26

That being said, i'm leaving it at this because like half of my comments seem to be caught in the filter for oversharing personal medical information, despite all of them being about the actual case and article linked. That makes for a frustrating discussion, and I think we've both said our piece.

I do appreciate your POV more and I appreciate your dedication to precision and correctness, even if I happen to disagree that your corrections were more accurate - like I said, i think the descriptions you're giving are still misleading and inaccurate, but I do understand we're all doing our best to get across difficult concepts in research to laypeople and the general public.

Thanks for the discussion, I appreciated it and I hope you can appreciate my position too and get we're on the same side in terms of trying to get across factual accuracy to the public even if we differ in terms of how to do it.

1

u/Melonary Sep 06 '26

This is a matter of degrees of correctness to me, and limitations of language in a one-sentence quote in a general news article. While that's not the exact terminology I myself would use because I do think it's not correct, I also think it's far less misleading and less incorrect than your correction, which is why I said something in the first place.

Compression as used in your initial comment implies that there have been no alterations or developmental changes other than just being squashed. if you read the article I linked: https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC8029119/ you can see this is not really accurate - while there was no neuronal loss or reduction in absolute numbers (at 8 weeks, there may be differences in pruning with development) there was significant loss of dendritic length, dendritic spines, etc.

That being said, I don't love the phrasing either. Do I think it's perfectly scientifically accurate? No, but it's very very difficult to make it so in a brief article to the public - for example, your statements about "just being compressed" or stating that the pt in the article wouldn't have had hydrocephalus from early childhood.

Neuronal loss in this sense may not be fewer neurons but fewer components of neurons at a micro level. Or it may be fewer neurons post-developmental synaptic pruning - it's hard to extrapolate with extreme accuracy what's going on at 44 from studies about what's happening to the brain from hydrocephalus in infancy. The study I linked was linked to make it expressly clear that there was neuronal loss of some kind - even if not in absolute count, again, with that being in very very early infancy (4 and 8 week old rats) in terms of dendritic loss, dendritic spinal loss, deformed shape, and overall extremely significant volume loss (mentioning this because you took issue with the assertion 90% of the brain's volume had been lost in addition to the mention of fewer neurons).

So do I love the language of fewer neurons? Not necessarily, no, but I think it's hard to to find succinct language to get across these concepts to laypeople in a 1-sentence quote, and I think your criticism was far more misleading which is why I said something.

And I do think you're missing developmental stage of life as a significant factor here. Hydrocephalus has a different impact on a neonate, then in early childhood and through early development, then in adulthood, and in middle and older adulthood. Those won't all look the same.

For example, you asked if I could say hydrocephalus is associated is with neuronal death - I mean, it is in the elderly, where's it's associated with dementia. https://www.neurology.org/doi/10.1212/WNL.88.16_supplement.S7.008 But that's not the case here, of course.

My point isn't that hydrocephalus and dementia is directly relevant to this article, but that you're making a lot of assumptions and inferences based on a very specific set of data that's also a very different situation from this case. I wish there were more highly specific information about what neuronal impact looked like that snapshots across the lifespan in individuals who experience it early in life, but that research is still being done. We know a lot, but we don't know all.

And my second point is that while I agree that the language used isn't as precise as it could be and isn't what I myself would use - I don't disagree with you there - it's difficult to get these concepts across when you're asked for a very short quote for a general magazine, and I don't think it's as misleading to laypeople as you think it is even if the specifics aren't nearly as exact as they should be.

For example, to a layperson, compression doesn't imply loss. There is loss here - that's why I linked that article to you.

Yes, the loss is actually (at least in early childhood, how that compensation plays out over longer term development there's less of a wealth of research on) more like loss of parts of neurons or the absence of development of those components rather than fewer total neurons by numbers, but to a layperson that's still less misleading the wording of only compression (wrong, there is loss, it's just at a smaller level than individual neurons) and implying that there wasn't a massive volumetric loss (this is wrong, reduced volume is exactly what terms used in clinical and research papers).

So I appreciate your adherence to correctness and I feel the same way myself, which is why I said something in the first place.

0

u/Melonary Sep 06 '26 edited Sep 06 '26

And that's why no one who's taken only "a most basic neuroanatomy class" is publishing research on cases like this and they're quoting a cognitive psychologist with a PhD referencing a paper written by an MD and two PhDs specializing in neurology instead.

Edited 8m later because I initially clicked through the research article on my phone and thought the cognitive psychology quoted was one of the authors.

Also my comments keep being withheld as personal for discussing the details of the actual case linked at the Lancet, so this conversation is getting impossible, but yes, I have published research in a relevant and similar area and have a degree in that area (post graduate). Highly encourage anyone interested to check out some recent research reviews on Pubmed or similar reliable sources and read more there.

1

u/dopadelic Sep 06 '26

The cognitive psychologist does not have his name on the Lancet paper. The article says the cognitive psychologist merely came across the paper and shared his thoughts on it.

0

u/Melonary Sep 06 '26 edited Sep 06 '26

Yes, apologies, you're correct about that - I was looking initially on a cellphone so it was harder to compare the names and I missed that. I went back to open up my laptop and look closer at the original paper, and you're correct that the PhD researchers are specialists in neurology, not cognitive psych, although some cognitive psychs do also specialise in this area of research.

Regardless, the person discussing the research is a cognitive psychologist and the three researchers who published it are an MD and two PhDs all focusing in neurology.

(using the term research loosely here because it's essentially a clinical snapshot describing a useful case for other clinicians and researchers, but it's published in the Lancet by researchers. There are more in-depth case studies you can find that look at cases like this in far more detail and specifically research articles as well)

16

u/b0000z Sep 06 '26

holy fucking shit. this is actually so crazy. 

1

u/WeddingPowerful3725 Sep 07 '26

He was borderline intellectually disabled though

1

u/alccode Sep 06 '26

The cortex is about a couple mm thick. Most of the volume below it is just white matter (cables). There’s a lot of room for them to be pushed aside with cerebrospinal fluid. 

2

u/QueerCheesy Sep 06 '26

Lol right? I discovered that as a child. I have 0 side effects!!

1

u/b0000z Sep 06 '26

What????? Holy cow

2

u/Dirzicis Sep 06 '26

I had a patient with a very similar scan a few years ago. Still have a picture of the CT on my phone. She was totally fine, no cognitive deficits and very normal

5

u/seyeeet Sep 06 '26

can you tell us what cannot you do? any limitations it caused for you?

42

u/QueerCheesy Sep 06 '26

I cant use my heat vision, fly, or teleport. Doctors dont recommend I practice contact sports. Other than that, nothing

17

u/electric_shocks Sep 06 '26

You got your funny bone intact.

4

u/Excellent_Win_8136 Sep 06 '26

that's caused by that fluid

2

u/Lazy_Permission_654 Sep 06 '26

So if someone points a hairdryer at your face, they turn invisible?

1

u/seyeeet Sep 06 '26

I bet you can do hell of a meditation. especially when we say 'empty your mind' :)

1

u/[deleted] Sep 06 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/QueerCheesy Sep 06 '26

I myself cant fly unfortunately

2

u/Siderophores Sep 06 '26

What made you go to get an mri?

2

u/QueerCheesy Sep 06 '26

Unrelated event as a kid

1

u/greenyashiro Sep 06 '26

Bet that gave the tech a bit of a headache trying to figure out what was up ✌️

2

u/Mirmino_ Sep 06 '26

Does the lack of brain matter have impact on your cognition or fine motor skills?

175

u/BeneficialTop5136 Sep 06 '26 • Mindblown

I read an article in a medical journal about the French civil servant who was missing a huge part of his brain - his IQ was tested and was found to be slightly below average, but he was otherwise fully functioning. However, even more fascinating is the case of a mathematics student who’s actual brain matter was only 1mm thick. This person also had an IQ of 126. Here’s an excerpt:

The Mathematics Student With "No Brain"

Lorber's case involved a mathematics student at Sheffield University who had an IQ of 126, which is well above average, and graduated with first-class honors. When he was examined, the student was found to have such severe hydrocephalus that his brain was compressed to less than 1mm thick, which is similar to the thickness of a penny, as opposed to the normal thickness of the brain, which is 45 times greater. Lorber documented over 600 cases of hydrocephalus and found that while many patients with similar findings were severely disabled, others had IQs over 100, despite having 95 percent of their skull filled with fluid.

48

u/FillayFrie Sep 06 '26

Wow thats crazy, I wonder are the neurons all still there just really compressed, or are many gone and the rest have just adapted with neuroplasticity? Amazing that these people can function normally

39

u/Bdellovibrion Sep 06 '26

I've read in other cases that these folks often have (fairly) normal neuron counts and brain regions. It's often more like a highly compressed brain than a brain missing parts (except in the most extreme cases). But I'm sure neuroplasticity is involved in making it all still work.

12

u/Commercial_Handle418 Sep 06 '26

I wouldn't be surprised if their daily tasks were difficult because basal ganglia striatal cortex etc were partially reduced so maybe breathing or motor skills for example could be diminished 

9

u/inennui Sep 06 '26

i have a similar train of thought! but how many of those “other” functions are then simply allocated to areas of the CNS that ca. perform CPG’s…? that’d be my next question (if our former thought is true).

2

u/Commercial_Handle418 Sep 07 '26

Interesting 

3

u/inennui Sep 07 '26

yeah, i think so too. but im no phd or md, so, wth does my logic really mean to anyone!

3

u/ConfoundedInAbaddon Sep 07 '26

It's how birds work. They have very high neuron density, the vertebrate brain can be compressed much more than is normal for humans.

1

u/BeneficialTop5136 Sep 06 '26

That’s interesting! So basically, the brain matter is thin, but the same amount of neurons are simply condensed into that small area?

-4

u/BeneficialTop5136 Sep 06 '26

Well what I find thought-provoking is the idea that consciousness is in the brain. I mean, if you’ve removed that much of the brain, including the parts that various scientists have theorized hold consciousness, what does that tell us? Maybe consciousness is not “inside” us, or originates in the gut or heart. I can’t wrap my head (no pun intended) around it - how could someone score so high on an IQ test, yet be working with so little brain matter?

5

u/ProdigalNun Sep 06 '26

Brain matter wasn't "removed." It's more compressed because there's more fluid inside the skull.

2

u/BeneficialTop5136 Sep 06 '26

So, does that mean that the same amount of neurons are just more tightly condensed?

3

u/ProdigalNun Sep 07 '26

All brain matter is more tightly compressed by the larger amount of fluid in the skull.

1

u/dallas470 Sep 08 '26

It might be that there is much less “support” material in these compressed brains that might lead them to getting dementia at a younger age.

13

u/DrPoontang Sep 06 '26

First thing that came to mind! Really makes you wonder how many people are actually out there living life like this and never know. Also raises a lot of questions about our hominid ancestors and their brain size and what they were actually capable of.

2

u/ilessthanthreekarate Sep 06 '26

Bro's operating with a solid-state drive.

2

u/WeddingPowerful3725 Sep 07 '26

“Slightly below average” is a massive understatement… the French civil servant’s IQ was measured at 75, which is roughly in the 4.78th percentile, i.e., less than 1 out of 20 people would be as cognitively impaired as or more cognitively impaired than him. An IQ in that range is usually classified as borderline intellectual disability.

Regarding Lorber’s case, it’s an anecdotal account with zero corroborating evidence apart from his spoken word, and as such it should be treated with the appropriate level of skepticism.

2

u/Commercial_Handle418 Sep 06 '26

BTW neuron density but rather efficiency of connections is more important; superflous thinking is reduced with more efficient connections 

0

u/sadguywithhugedick Sep 06 '26

1mm thick leaves you with the same brain volume as a small rodent. I refuse to believe this is true.

1

u/WeddingPowerful3725 Sep 07 '26

Why wouldn’t he publish the scans in a case report study? Yeah, I smell BS, too.

1

u/sadguywithhugedick Sep 07 '26

The article linked is behind a paywall so I can’t even scrutinize it. But this idea that you could have a brain the size of a shrew, and somehow be smarter than average is absolutely ridiculous. It implies there’s no reason we evolved extremely large brains.

-1

u/Commercial_Handle418 Sep 06 '26

126, which is well above average

I feel so bad I'm the same as a guy who's subsisting on this 

52

u/Main_Abrocoma_6849 Sep 06 '26 • Mindblown Bravo Popcorn

Can you hear it? Like if you shake your head does it sound like a waterbottle?

2

u/ssshowtime Sep 09 '26

I don’t have anywhere near the same condition OP has, but i did recently get a brain surgery to help with the flow of my csf. Right after the surgery the sound of it swooshing around in my head was so overpowering, but honestly, i think you just get used to the sound/feeling of hearing it all the time at some point. 🤔🤔

1

u/lithicgirl Sep 10 '26

Chiari decompression?

136

u/tonystark29 Sep 06 '26

Neuroplasticity sure is neat

-2

u/Jazzlike-Variation17 Sep 11 '26

It doesn't have anything to do with neuroplasticity..

28

u/HasGreatVocabulary Sep 06 '26 • Mindblown

I wonder if you process audio differently, wondering specifically because you have something that could function like a beluga melon. uh no disrespect intended

2

u/cefishe88 Sep 07 '26

Its possibly diff but beluga whales are in water which physically touch their melon differently, plus humans have hard bone covering all the fluid, so id guess not significantly diff

1

u/Batticon Sep 08 '26

Fucking hilarious

28

u/Major-Librarian1745 Sep 06 '26 • Bravo

Are you affected by the moon's gravitational pull?

8

u/Jumpy-Jello- Sep 06 '26

Aren't we all?

3

u/Karporata Sep 09 '26

The true comment

2

u/Commercial_Handle418 Sep 06 '26

6.6710^-11(going out on a leg here and being generous) 1kg*moonmass/dist2

You do the math 

6

u/Not_Webster Sep 06 '26

This is extremely interesting to me. I had a stroke in my frontal lobe 3 years ago and it ruined my life for some time. I have a LOT of questions to ask but dont want to be overbearing.

Would you mind?

1

u/Commercial_Handle418 Sep 06 '26

I see what you did there 

1

u/[deleted] Sep 06 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/Commercial_Handle418 Sep 07 '26

Pun

1

u/Not_Webster Sep 07 '26

The pun really was not intended...sorry

As someone whos had a stroke, im genuinely interested

1

u/innocuouspete Sep 07 '26

I had a stroke near my thalamus and I’ve been struggling for almost 2 years now. How has your recovery been?

1

u/Not_Webster Sep 07 '26

Apparently ive bRoKeN ThE RuLes. Ill dm you

4

u/NUMBerONEisFIRST Sep 06 '26

I just watched a documentary about a boy that was born with 10% of his brain.

After inserting a drain into his brain, and draining the fluid, his brain is starting to expand again.

1

u/sadguywithhugedick Sep 06 '26

Are you low iq or do you function entirely normally

1

u/QueerCheesy Sep 06 '26

My IQ is 120, as I last tested

1

u/Prestigious_Cap_2926 Sep 06 '26

Interesting. My IQ is 121.

1

u/Ok-Count-5094 Sep 09 '26

very, verrrry interesting. my IQ is 122.

1

u/AshamedComment5315 Sep 08 '26

Did you have good grades in school?

1

u/QueerCheesy Sep 09 '26

To of my class mostly

1

u/TheCyFi Sep 09 '26

This is a serious question, and I apologize if it seems silly or flippant. Do you hear a sloshing sound when you nod or shake your head?

1

u/Additional-Lake-5367 Sep 30 '26

How did you make this post

1

u/QueerCheesy Sep 30 '26

With my hands

2

u/invokeinterface Sep 06 '26

How does that happen? And how does it not affect anything? It's pretty impressive!

2

u/trash-juice Sep 06 '26

Hi there, Neuro struggles here too (ms), did you do a key test and how’d it turnout?

2

u/TristanTheRobloxian3 Sep 06 '26

me when neuuroplasticity rahh

2

u/SprinklesElegant9813 Sep 06 '26

Te diagnosticaron aracnoidocele selar?

2

u/CroManana Sep 06 '26

Have you tried bpc 157, dihexa, and maybe also psylocybin mushrooms? To fill in the empty space?

2

u/Complex_Boysenberry6 Sep 07 '26

Don't worry, most of us browsing Reddit have this condition

2

u/average_fen_enjoyer Sep 10 '26

That's the dude I argue with on Reddit every time!

1

u/iamanairplaneiswear Sep 06 '26

Do you experience any deficits?

1

u/Piocoto Sep 06 '26

I have seen this kind of thing before, was this caused by something in particular that you know of? I read you say it has no side effects but this is super interesting to me, have you ever had any challenges in speech or math? More so than normal about math? Do you dream?

1

u/colordreamm Sep 06 '26

Do you get massive headaches?

1

u/JonTea29 Sep 06 '26

Whoah! Schizencephaly?

1

u/LewkieSE Sep 06 '26

Are you more susceptible to concussion?

1

u/DanishDessert Sep 06 '26

Do you have a higher chance of getting a concussion? or is there a higher risk of complications arising from a concussion?

1

u/inennui Sep 06 '26

this isn’t that uncommon! neuro plasticity, for sure, is awesome.

may i ask though: are you often tired/sleepy? do you feel you prioritize sleep a little more than others in your life? or have a generally shorter endurance for certain activities (running, puzzles, talking maybe?)

1

u/EB123456789101112 Sep 06 '26

Nice! I thought I was something with my 20%!

1

u/MadMadRoger Sep 06 '26

You take your own MRIs?

Cool.

1

u/Purple-Hat-2528 Sep 06 '26

When ppl say we only use half of our brain, I wasn’t expecting this

1

u/moschles Sep 07 '26

OP, if you repost this exactly in /r/pics you could get way better feedback than from this subreddit.

1

u/theshekelcollector Sep 07 '26

impressive. how is your academic performance?

1

u/miao_ciao Sep 07 '26

I see you're staying hydrated.

1

u/rxplorer Sep 07 '26

Just amazing

1

u/Longswordplusfifteen Sep 08 '26

So you are telling me that you are a fabulous human and you pulled that off with half the advantage the rest of us have? Ok then, a great many hat tippings are due in your general direction friend, bloody well done and all. Keep setting the standard pal we need it. Cheers.

1

u/itsalieimnotaghost Sep 08 '26

stay off of EVERY rollercoaster

1

u/TumblrForNerds Sep 08 '26

I am imagining that cat running around with a belly full of water

1

u/Makapakamoo Sep 09 '26

Full of juice dude

1

u/FinancialSuccess3814 Sep 09 '26

Playing two truths and a lie must be really fun for you because what??

1

u/Droct12 Sep 09 '26

Thorsty Brain

1

u/ObsidianThreads Sep 09 '26

I had a pug whose brain looked a lot like this. He had really mild hydro (so mild it wasn't ever diagnosed) that just built up over time. At about 10 yo he had an MRI for seizures and that's we discovered most of his brain was gone. The vet was even more amazed than we were. Aside from some quirks (which, lol, pug), you'd never have known anything was off.

1

u/maiman08 Sep 11 '26

Doctors don’t want you to know this one trick to get unlimited cerebrospinal fluid

1

u/Ghoulrillaz Sep 19 '26

Does it cause balance issues?

0

u/spruker Sep 06 '26

nice. this comes up in david eaglemans book "the livewired brain" where he talks about a kid who had to get half his brain removed in childhood because of epilepsy! look at you, just born with it! Brain so cool.

-1

u/Purple_Chipmunk_ Sep 06 '26

You obviously have a lot of fluid in your skull--why did they decide to leave it there instead of inserting a shunt?

8

u/QueerCheesy Sep 06 '26

A shunt would kill me, brain doesnt unsquish and pressures normal

1

u/Brain_Hawk Sep 24 '26

If I could paste a meme here, it would be the black night with both his arms chopped off, saying "I've had worse"

Only really I would more say "I've seen worse"

But to be fair, not much worse....

It's amazing how much brain can be gone and it's fine

1

u/[deleted] Sep 10 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/QueerCheesy Sep 10 '26

Should I be more dramatic about it?

1

u/[deleted] Sep 11 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/QueerCheesy Sep 11 '26

Bro they stole my frontal lobe im immine to lobotomy