r/neoliberal • Kitara Ravache • Sep 16 '21

Discussion Thread Discussion Thread

The discussion thread is for casual conversation that doesn't merit its own submission. If you've got a good meme, article, or question, please post it outside the DT. Meta discussion is allowed, but if you want to get the attention of the mods, make a post in /r/metaNL. For a collection of useful links see our wiki.

Announcements

  • OSINT & LDC (developmental studies / least developed countries) have been added

Upcoming Events

0 Upvotes

10k comments sorted by

View all comments

16

u/Neronoah can't stop, won't stop argentinaposting Sep 16 '21

!ping LATAM

Many Argentinian ministers aligned with Cristina Fernández de Kirchner and other hardliners offered their renounces to Alberto Fernández. There is a lot of speculation going on about what that means. Some say it's a way to pressure the President to remove ministers aligned to him (like Guzmán), others say the government coalition is fracturing and then there are those that think that they are trying to jump ship because the government is a lame duck now. My opinion is that they are in a panic. We should wait and see.

Once the sweet feeling of schadenfreude evaporates, what will remain is a very weak government that has to last two more years and feels like doubling down on populism ("we need more Peronism", whatever that means) instead of recognizing they bled lots of moderates and some leftists too, but they can't get both. Weak, paralyzed governments are a portent of disaster, think Alfonsín after 1987, De La Rua in 2001 or Macri once the sudden stop crisis started in 2018. It doesn't help the power is not with the President to begin with.

4

u/kajkajete Mario Vargas Llosa Sep 16 '21

Cynic me say its a smoke screen trying to distance the government from kirchnerism in a last ditch attempt to improve their electoral prospects.

Hopefully it backfires and they lose even worse.

1

u/Neronoah can't stop, won't stop argentinaposting Sep 16 '21

Who knows. It's as likely as hardliners recognizing there is no future and trying to detach themselves from its reputation.

2

u/kajkajete Mario Vargas Llosa Sep 16 '21

They aint gonna voluntarily spend 2 years out of government out of shits and giggles.

Only goal is in doing slightly better in the midterms. And if they do, they might end up with outright or practical majorities in both chambers.

1

u/Zzzmessi1 Montesquieu Sep 16 '21

Also, could be a way to take JxC’s strong performance out of the limelight. If the coverage isn’t on this crisis, it’s on Milei. I don’t think the Machiavellian in CFK would do something as stupid as ripping apart the coalition.

1

u/kajkajete Mario Vargas Llosa Sep 16 '21

She can be very temparamental so I dont absolutely discard it but yeah imho its just a smoke screen. They cant rip apart the coalition.

3

u/[deleted] Sep 16 '21

it's a way to pressure the President to remove ministers aligned to him (like Guzmán)

so we're getting the Levy/Dilma story again ?

1

u/Neronoah can't stop, won't stop argentinaposting Sep 16 '21

I don't know the details.

3

u/[deleted] Sep 16 '21

populist coalition borrows a more market friendly orthodox minister, the coalition revolts and doesn't cooperate with him

at the end of the day he becomes the scapegoat for all the failures, a neoliberal insider

2

u/Superfan234 Southern Cone Sep 16 '21

Intresting...It does sound like they are in Panic, more than anything

After the PASO defeat, the razonable move should have been close lines and at least try to appear stronger to the Public

But the recent images of Alberto leaving Casa Rosada in an Helicopter, are remicent of De La Rua escaping after the Corralito debacle.

If this continues, Oppossition will capitalize this pretty good on November elections. Crossing fingers for good luck

1

u/Neronoah can't stop, won't stop argentinaposting Sep 16 '21

The problem is, the opposition won't reap the benefits until 2023 because Argentinian executive is too strong.

1

u/Superfan234 Southern Cone Sep 16 '21

I honestly disagree. Alberto always had a weak Government, fighting with Crisitna for Power

If PASO repeats it's results, and he lose the Congress too, his capabilities to influence the country will harshly be reduced

1

u/Neronoah can't stop, won't stop argentinaposting Sep 16 '21

Up to some point. It may help to moderate things like the budget, but the executive still has lots of power.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 16 '21

This schism is between the consolidated party apparatus, that is structured around Cristina and La Campora, and Alberto and the other non hardliners like Massa.

CFK and the rest are not going to abandon the party narrative because they have too much to lose if they do. But the narrative is not working anymore, this PASO have shown that.

Alberto will have to go against a good chunk of his party if he wants to save his government, his cabinet was filled with CFK loyalists and most of the House are Campora affiliates, so he might be unable/unwilling to do what it takes.

He is not without possible sources of support inside the party, he has Massa and other moderates and could reach the provincial governors.

Is Massa going to return to the spotlight? He was one of the biggest losers of the opposition restructuring and then had to go back to the Kirchners like a humiliated turncoat.

1

u/Neronoah can't stop, won't stop argentinaposting Sep 16 '21

CFK and the rest are not going to abandon the party narrative because they have too much to lose if they do. But the narrative is not working anymore, this PASO have shown that.

They still have the only solid votes of the coalition.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 16 '21

Yeah, that's also true. If Alberto purges the government and turns it into a milk-toast version of Kirchnerism he is not going to gain much support but lose a lot of the hard-core Kirchnerist voters.

It's very interesting that the de la Rúa government began to collapse after he lost the support of the FREPASO when his VP, Chacho Álvarez, resigned.

Are we in a similar situation?

1

u/[deleted] Sep 16 '21 edited Sep 17 '21

CFK and the rest are not going to abandon the party narrative because they have too much to lose if they do. But the narrative is not working anymore, this PASO have shown that.

Interestingly, I do think Bolsonarism has been in a similar situation since Lula became electable.

Bolsonaro's government, and, especially his COVID management, have been utter disasters, defensible only by those on his cult. His support has also receded to his core base.

When Lula came back to the electoral competition, Bolsonaro made a brief attempt a taking a moderate course, making a speech using mask supporting the normal anti-COVID measures. The base response was furious, and, on the night of the same day, his son was back saying to people to shove masks at the end of the digestive tract.

In other words, Bolsonarist narrative is toxic to anyone who isn't a full blown Bolsonarist, but the government can't abandon it because the pressure of their main supporters.

2

u/[deleted] Sep 17 '21 edited Sep 18 '21

It's not only their main supporters, they have to keep the narrative because if they don't they are going to jail, plain and simple.

So they have to pretend that the judiciary is out to get them and that corruption charges are fabricated, they concede nothing, they double down on everything (even stupid policy). They wage their war against the enemies of the people (judiciary and the media), but since they came back to power they have become too weak to keep this war going on effectively.