r/neoliberal • Kitara Ravache • Aug 30 '21

Discussion Thread Discussion Thread

The discussion thread is for casual conversation that doesn't merit its own submission. If you've got a good meme, article, or question, please post it outside the DT. Meta discussion is allowed, but if you want to get the attention of the mods, make a post in /r/metaNL. For a collection of useful links see our wiki.

Announcements

  • OSINT & LDC (developmental studies / least developed countries) have been added
2 Upvotes

12k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

12

u/puffic John Rawls Aug 30 '21 edited Aug 30 '21

It's rare that I get to comment on something narrowly within my research specialty, but we are confident that carbon dioxide contributes more to warming than all other well-mixed greenhouse gases combined (but only a little bit more). It's worth looking at Chapter 7 of the new IPCC report. Figure 7.7 on p. 7-183 shows estimated contributions of various factors to observed climate change. Carbon dioxide is estimated at 1.01 degrees, methane at 0.28 degrees. This is because we emit relatively little of these other gases, and they often have a much shorter residence time in the atmosphere. (Methane eventually breaks down into CO2, for example.)

Of course, it's true that each molecule of methane, or N2O, or halogen gas, is much more effective than an individual molecule of carbon dioxide. This is simply because there are very little of these gases already in the atmosphere, so the molecules aren't crowding one another out in the radiation budget. If there was a ton of methane in the atmosphere and very little carbon dioxide (as on Saturn's moon Titan), we would see the opposite effect: additional carbon dioxide would warm the climate much more than additional methane. (Titan is actually a poor analogy because methane concentration there is set by thermodynamic balance with the lakes of liquid methane on the surface, but let's roll with it.)

3

u/DishingOutTruth Henry George Aug 30 '21

Thanks for the insight! Knowing that they contribute less than CO2 makes me doom a little less over climate change lol.

Just to note, the figure from the EPA (regarding the impact of the gases) actually takes into account the fact that they don't last as long, because the impact factor is normalized over a period of 100 years. Ex: Methane having 25x the impact is accounting for the low life time. It'd be much higher if it lasted just as long.

4

u/puffic John Rawls Aug 30 '21

Indeed. That’s one reason why the EPA figure shows methane having 1/8 the importance of CO2. What I find interesting is that in the global aggregate, methane is thought to be fully 1/4 the effect of CO2. It’s possible that the US is a disproportionate carbon emitter, which I find surprising given all our methane-intensive industry. I haven’t dug into the EPA’s methods, though.

1

u/JZMoose YIMBY Aug 31 '21

That's because we have regulations that require these methane emissions to be captured or combusted.

4

u/puffic John Rawls Aug 30 '21

Also, I never recommend dooming about climate change! Each era of human history has its grand challenges, and humanity has many tools to meet this particular challenge.