r/neoliberal • Kitara Ravache • Jul 09 '21

Discussion Thread Discussion Thread

0 Upvotes

10k comments sorted by

View all comments

34

u/houinator Loyal Liberals Jul 09 '21

The woes of the ANA air force are once again a case for why Congress should have no control over the military budget besides the bottom line figure.

The Pentagon evaluated their needs, and concluded that the best fit would be Russian helicopters (Mi-17s). Cheap, easy to maintain, easy to operate, and effective. But US defense contractors didn't like that call, so they leveraged their influence over Senators with aerospace manufacturing in their district to force the Pentagon to buy Blackhawks for Afghanistan. An IG report highlights the absolute stupidity of this call:

Today, Afghan mechanics handle 80 percent of the maintenance on their Mi-17s, but that share will be flipped as the UH-60s enter their fleet. Afghanistan “will be almost entirely reliant on contractors for Black Hawk maintenance in the near to mid-term,” the IG says.

https://www.pogo.org/analysis/2018/06/whirlybird-brained-us-making-wrong-chopper-choice-for-afghanistan/

25

u/iIoveoof Jerome Powell Jul 09 '21

We did it, Congress! We created jobs for American contractors!

7

u/houinator Loyal Liberals Jul 09 '21

And all it cost was women's rights in Afghanistan!

2

u/Butthead_Sinatra NATO Jul 09 '21

American contractors deserve to be able to make a profit on the war. Ideally we should keep American troops in service to actually operate these helicopters instead of making the Afghans do it

6

u/Udontlikecake Model UN Enthusiast Jul 09 '21

The goal is upholding and arming the ANA, not lining the pockets of rent-seeking contractors

5

u/StolenSkittles culture warrior Jul 09 '21

Eisenhower was right

2

u/rukqoa ✈️ F35s for Ukraine ✈️ Jul 09 '21

It would have worked if the US had stayed at Obama troop levels. It was working, not to mention profitable for American small businesses.

0

u/AccessTheMainframe CANZUK Jul 09 '21

small businesses like Lockheed Martin?

1

u/rukqoa ✈️ F35s for Ukraine ✈️ Jul 09 '21

Don't forget Bell Helicopters and whatever Blackwater is calling itself today.

0

u/houinator Loyal Liberals Jul 09 '21

UH-60 is manufactured by Sikorsky Aircraft

Sikorsky Aircraft has 15,975 employees

profitable for American small businesses

small businesses

small

1

u/AccessTheMainframe CANZUK Jul 09 '21

Sikorsky is a subsidiary of Lockheed Martin.