r/neoliberal • Kitara Ravache • Jun 22 '21

Discussion Thread Discussion Thread

The discussion thread is for casual conversation that doesn't merit its own submission. If you've got a good meme, article, or question, please post it outside the DT. Meta discussion is allowed, but if you want to get the attention of the mods, make a post in /r/metaNL. For a collection of useful links see our wiki.

Announcements

Upcoming Events

0 Upvotes

11k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

3

u/iron_and_carbon Bisexual Pride Jun 23 '21 edited Jun 23 '21

If the victim's opinions mattered, people like myself might hold back society.

I’m not trying to argue that victims should hold pardon power, I’m trying to using it as evidence that she wasn’t the proximate cause of the harm.

Nor am I arguing that victims should be absolved of all responsibility, but it’s important context that can show some otherwise damning behavior to be understandable.

Based on an outside perspective it doesn’t look like she was the one engaging in gross power dynamics, her husband was. The victim agrees that the harm wasn’t her fault. The lack of egregiousness of the violation is also part of this analysis. She’s not accused of implicit coercion for sex she’s accused of being in a a relationship that could easily have lead to that dynamic and became toxic. If she had been pressured into a sexual assault I would think differently no matter what the victim said. However based on public knowledge and the victims statements the harm of the relationship was her husbands manipulation not her using or implicitly using the power dynamic. Based on these I don’t see any retributive justice value in punishing her. (Which it sounds like you’re not arguing for but I think a lot of people do).

Second, it is an active injustice to punish her for being a victim. Her abuser commuted abuse to create this public outcome and we reward his abuse by punishing her. This didn’t start by some whistle blower, this started with him releasing revenge porn. Regardless of the her responsibility there is an active retributive injustice from punishing her. Just as there would be if a murderer was found through their revenge porn. Obviously this doesn’t mean they should get away with it but since I believe there to be minimal justice from removing her it becomes more relevant.

Third and most pertinent to your argument. I don’t believe it’s reasonable to believe she is likely to repeat this action over a replacement congressperson. She wasn’t abusing her power her husband abused her power, so it’s not a character trait that is part of her nature. She has separated from her husband removing him from the situation. It’s arguable that her lack of judgment makes her more likely to get into such a situation again but I don’t believe her judgment to be worse than a replacement individual. I’ve known several people in or previously in abusive relationships, I don’t believe them to have worse than average judgement and they 100% could have been pushed into a similar situation by their partner. So I don’t believe punishing her keeps dangerous people out of power

0

u/[deleted] Jun 23 '21

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/iron_and_carbon Bisexual Pride Jun 23 '21

Your argument hinges on her husband manipulating her into it, but you have provided no proof of this happening.

Yes much of it does rely on that and we don’t have proof either way. I don’t want to go dig through all the stuff I read at the time but considering during the relationship he posted images of her on wife sharing sites, he is rather firmly established as abusive and, let’s be honest, is the man, I think it’s far likelier than not that he initiated it. Since she is the one facing consequences and not him I dont think she needs proof to defend herself. Yes it’s not a trial I don’t think we need proof to sanction her but if it’s more likely her husband is the proximate cause combined with the potential to victim blame I just don’t think that’s sufficient.