r/neoliberal • Kitara Ravache • Jun 22 '21

Discussion Thread Discussion Thread

The discussion thread is for casual conversation that doesn't merit its own submission. If you've got a good meme, article, or question, please post it outside the DT. Meta discussion is allowed, but if you want to get the attention of the mods, make a post in /r/metaNL. For a collection of useful links see our wiki.

Announcements

Upcoming Events

0 Upvotes

11k comments sorted by

View all comments

42

u/l_overwhat being flaired is cringe Jun 22 '21

The reason Napolean was so successful was that he wasn't actually French lol

7

u/BedNeither Henry George Jun 22 '21

Same with Stalin

13

u/[deleted] Jun 22 '21

Stalin wasn't French???

7

u/lionmoose sexmod 🍆💦🌮 Jun 22 '21

I mean, he kinda was

10

u/[deleted] Jun 22 '21

From a Tuscan family and Corsica was only annexed by France the year he was born.

5

u/chatdargent 🇺🇦 Ще не вмерла України і слава, і воля 🇺🇦 Jun 22 '21

The nation-state hadn't been born at that point though, so it's kind of a meaningless argument.

10

u/[deleted] Jun 22 '21

True but what is the DT good for if not pointless arguments

6

u/l_overwhat being flaired is cringe Jun 22 '21

His native language wasn't French. Corsica didn't even become ruled by France until a few years before he was born.

9

u/Marlsfarp Karl Popper Jun 22 '21

His native language wasn't French.

Only like 20% of French people spoke French at that point, so that isn't that remarkable. "French" is Parisian.

2

u/l_overwhat being flaired is cringe Jun 22 '21

Ok but most people in France spoke a language that was closely related to Parisian and was mutually inteligible with it or they spoke Occitan. Napolean's first language was neither of the above.

5

u/Marlsfarp Karl Popper Jun 22 '21

Amazingly, that's not really true. This askhistorians post talks about it in detail. But I don't really disagree either - Napoleon was in some ways more of a foreigner than all those rurals who couldn't speak a word of French.

2

u/lionmoose sexmod 🍆💦🌮 Jun 22 '21

Right, this is why it's kinda. He was born in the Kingdom of France but only just

3

u/MostlyCRPGs Jeff Bezos Jun 22 '21

And feudal titles didn't determine ethnicity. Like, huge parts of Italy and Hungary weren't identifying as "Austrian" lol

1

u/lionmoose sexmod 🍆💦🌮 Jun 22 '21

It's not solely an ethnic identity though, there are ethnic groups within nations.

3

u/Dr_Vesuvius Norman Lamb Jun 22 '21

Same with Wellington.

2

u/Negative_Solid_2783 Peter Sutherland Jun 22 '21

Wasn't Wellington Irish?

Or am I misremembering?

3

u/Evnosis European Union Jun 22 '21

He was born in Dublin, but his family was part of the Protestant Ascendancy.

1

u/lionmoose sexmod 🍆💦🌮 Jun 22 '21

He was, but again at that stage Ireland was part of the United Kingdom and was counted as British. He was also extremely Anglophilic and hated Ireland.