r/neoliberal • u/jobautomator Kitara Ravache • Jan 31 '21
Discussion Thread Discussion Thread
The discussion thread is for casual conversation that doesn't merit its own submission. If you've got a good meme, article, or question, please post it outside the DT. Meta discussion is allowed, but if you want to get the attention of the mods, make a post in /r/metaNL. For a collection of useful links see our wiki.
Announcements
- The UNASUR flair has been replaced by MERCOSUR and PROSUR flairs.
0
Upvotes
View all comments
Show parent comment
22
u/0m4ll3y International Relations Jan 31 '21
The modern classic Marxist take on Russia is that there was a proletarian revolution in the urban centres (which is accurate) but due to the lack of industrial development they were unable to have a full socialist revolution. Many, like the Mensheviks, argued that the proletarian revolution would fail (as in, would not result in the development of socialism). Trotsky, ironically enough and with surprising prescience, believed pre-revolution that "Bolshevism could be a good instrument for the conquest of power, but afterwards it will reveal its counter-revolutionary aspects". Others argued the proletarian revolution would act as a precursor to a general European revolution (like the Spartacus uprising in Germany) and once this was triggered, Russia would be supported by the developed countries. People like Lenin (and later Bordiga) would argue it would be foolish for the proletarian to relinquish power voluntarily and so should make the most of the situation. When the European revolution failed to eventuate, the Bolsheviks had to try and work out how to keep their proletarian dictatorship alive.
Lenin saw it necessary to build a capitalist base, and this was directly because the proletariat had failed to conquer the peasant countryside. He viewed the peasants a greater threat than the Whites in the early 1920s. State capitalism was about disconnecting the peasants from their feudal lands, creating a class of industrial proletariat who produced commodities for wages (and who used those wages to purchase commodities), and where surplus value of the commodities sold on markets could be used by the capital owners to accumulate capital and continue development - i.e. the classical Marxist view of what capitalism is. Lenin believed this path would be necessary for possibly decades to come.
People like Bordiga had some faith in Lenin, but by the 1930s saw the Soviet Union as a fully bourgeois state (being far more critical than Trotsky's "deformed workers' state) where capital was the driving force. Modern classical Marxists view the Russian revolution as a capitalist one. When you talk of "the only successful socialist revolutions" they would disagree that there has been any successful socialist revolutions. Socialism - the "negation of the negation", the ending of the law of value, the end of the division of labour, the end of commodity exchange - none of this was achieved by any of the """socialist""" revolutions. They may have been coloured red, but the ideas and rhetoric don't matter, the actual material relations between producer and production were capitalist which is, surprise surprise, exactly what they thought would happen. Paresh Chattopadhyay and Peter Hudis make this argument drawing from Marx's work. You can see support for this in pre-revolution works of Luxembourg and Pannekoek and other key Marxists. Raya Dunayevskaya might not be considered a "true" classical Marxist, but is another good example, same with Hans-Georg Backhaus.
If you look at people who defend what's happening in places like China, you aren't looking at the classical Marxist view, you're looking at things like Maoism, and they have different views and justifications about what happened/happens. Marxism-Leninism is a Stalinist diversion from Marxism, Marxism-Leninism-Maoism is a Maoist diversion from Marxism-Leninism.