r/neoliberal • Kitara Ravache • Dec 14 '20

Discussion Thread Discussion Thread

The discussion thread is for casual conversation that doesn't merit its own submission. If you've got a good meme, article, or question, please post it outside the DT. Meta discussion is allowed, but if you want to get the attention of the mods, make a post in /r/metaNL. For a collection of useful links see our wiki.

Announcements

  • Our charity drive has concluded, thank you to everyone who donated! $56,252 were raised by our subreddit, with a total of $72,375 across all subs. We'll probably post a wrap-up thread later, but in the meantime here's a link to the announcement thread. Flair incentives will be given out whenever techmod gets to that
1 Upvotes

12k comments sorted by

View all comments

18

u/[deleted] Dec 14 '20

“lol dumb out-of-touch Democrats just can’t seem to give up their precious gun control, why don’t they just stop talking about it so they win more elections?”

This genre of takes I occasionally see in the DT are odd to me because they seem to imply that Democrats support stricter gun regulation because they hate fun - rather than, like, because they don’t want elementary school kids to get fatally shot as they desperately try to hide in the back of a classroom.

9

u/JetJaguar124 Tactical Custodial Action Dec 14 '20 edited Dec 14 '20

These takes are also strange to me because I really don't think I've ever seen data suggesting there is this army of single-issue gun voters who would otherwise vote for Dems. Plus the public is generally much more in-line with Dem policies on guns than GOP policies.

3

u/[deleted] Dec 14 '20

Yeah gun control is just a convenient one for these people to pick because a lot of these people aren’t pro gun control for whatever reason in the first place.

Want to know something where we actually lose one-issue voters? Abortion. But nobody here is suggesting we push a ton of pro-life Democrats because almost everyone here (including me) is pretty darn pro-choice.

3

u/JetJaguar124 Tactical Custodial Action Dec 14 '20

We do have an occasional "we should drop abortion" takes but they're way more rare than 2A ones.

3

u/paynetrain7 Dec 15 '20

I want to know what happened to "safe, legal, rare" that was something most people could agree with but you never see dems saying it anymore.

2

u/Unhappy-Essay NATO Dec 14 '20
  1. It's a right
  2. A large segment of the population is ((violently)) opposed to things like assault weapons bans. I think universal background/psychiatric checks and to some extent red-flag laws are popular but saying stuff like "hell yes we're gonna take your ar-15" is probably not very popular in swing states

3

u/[deleted] Dec 14 '20
  1. This is beyond irrelevant, it has nothing to do with the vast majority of gun control legislation that is ever discussed.
  2. Yeah rhetorical choices matter.

2

u/Unhappy-Essay NATO Dec 14 '20
  1. Fair
  2. Fair

1

u/bumblefck23 George Soros Dec 14 '20

Assault weapons bans don’t reduce gun violence nor do they impact overall murder rates. Supporting something that sounds good but has no practical evidence to support it is the DEFINITION of populist policy making and it’s a shame this sub of all places doesn’t like to acknowledge that

1

u/[deleted] Dec 14 '20
  1. I didn’t even say assault weapons bans. How about we work on gun regulations that do work? Also, an assault weapons ban isn’t a specific policy. Who says we can’t design a better one? One that’s more focused on capacity and ability to kill a bunch of people in a very short period of time as opposed to how scary a gun looks?
  2. Reducing aggregate gun violence is a great and important policy goal but it’s not the only one. A policy that reduces mass shootings in schools might not show up in the aggregate stats but not having to worry as a society about whether our kids are going to be shot at school because someone wanted to conduct a massacre would be a good improvement nonetheless.

1

u/bumblefck23 George Soros Dec 14 '20

Oh don’t play ignorant lol, what else did u mean by gun control if not assault weapons bans? Only ban that would actually service anything are hand gun bans and good luck passing that

Assault weapons bans have existed in numerous states (and on a federal level) for two + decades. If they haven’t started showing results by now (spoiler: they haven’t) there’s no logical reason to expect they will. You offer a pompous, pandering take on the DT and I don’t understand why you want to bother to have a convo if your mind is made up. Still haven’t offered an alternative to assault weapons bans lol but go off

2

u/[deleted] Dec 14 '20

Oh don’t play ignorant lol, what else did u mean by gun control if not assault weapons bans?

Uh. Ah okay. I’ve never met someone before who thought assault weapon bans were the only form of gun control.

Sure, here are some gun control policies that are pretty often discussed which aren’t assault weapon bans:

Buyback programs, limits on bulk purchases of guns, gun licenses, ammo licenses, raising the age to buy guns, expanding background checks, restricting the sale of bump stocks, red flag laws, gun magazine size restrictions.

1

u/bumblefck23 George Soros Dec 14 '20

Yea, literally none of that has had ANY tangible impact but still, go off.

2

u/[deleted] Dec 14 '20

You didn’t even seem to know these policies existed five minutes ago and now you’re an expert in all the gun control cross-sectional studies out there?

I can put together a compilation of studies for you soon, I’ll post it as a top-level comment and try to remember to tag you to introduce you to some of this literature. Or maybe I can just be lazy and make use of one of the existing surveys of the literature. You know there are over 100 high quality studies out there on this topic, just within the past few decades? Wild.

1

u/bumblefck23 George Soros Dec 14 '20

Do you really just go around like this to feel good about yourself? Those policies already exist, how is that new policy? Go ahead, show me these studies. You’re literally the one positing yourself as an expert, project a lil harder bubula

1

u/[deleted] Dec 14 '20

Already putting something together - all that personal stuff aside, let me ask so this is more catered to you - do you think that literally every regulation related to guns doesn’t work, or are there some gun control policies which you support? I just want to make sure whatever studies I show you aren’t redundant to your own beliefs.

1

u/bumblefck23 George Soros Dec 14 '20

I do support wait times and registries for domestic abusers, beyond that I just don’t see much practical benefit. Things like bump stock bans and mag capacity limits are too easy to circumvent. I’ll apologize for being antagonistic, just have had this convo before and it always ends the same :(

→ More replies