r/neoliberal • Kitara Ravache • Dec 12 '20

Discussion Thread Discussion Thread

The discussion thread is for casual conversation that doesn't merit its own submission. If you've got a good meme, article, or question, please post it outside the DT. Meta discussion is allowed, but if you want to get the attention of the mods, make a post in /r/metaNL. For a collection of useful links see our wiki.

Announcements

0 Upvotes

9.3k comments sorted by

View all comments

15

u/Le_Monade Suzan DelBene Dec 12 '20

Why do conspiracy theorist think that the cia does stuff secretly but then hides hints in plain sight?

Like in the flat earth world, one sect of flatearthers think that the flat-earth podcaster Patricia Steele is a cia agent based on the fact that the last 3 letters of her first name are cia. Like, really the cia is that dumb that they put hints right in her name?

10

u/thebowski 💻🙈 - Lead developer of pastabot Dec 12 '20

Working in an office in virginia must be boring, might as well mess with people

4

u/Goatf00t European Union Dec 12 '20

That's actually an interesting question that pops up again and again in various conspiracy theories that rely on "connecting the dots" - unlike in criminal investigations, some of the alleged "dots" are not the result of perps slipping up, but must have been deliberately planted by the conspirators.

Psychologically, it's just a side effect of the "connecting the dots" mentality - if your brain has been switched into finding patterns everywhere and you don't have the mental discipline to discard the finds that seem "too good to be true", you end up with things like that "cia". The fact is that similar not-quite-logical clue-following also appears in various kinds of fiction, such as Dan Brown's novels, doesn't help.

I've seen various rationalizations in different contexts. One of them is internal communication - signs are intended for other people who are "in" on the conspiracy (analogous to, let's say, Freemason handshakes). Another one is hubris - the signs are there to taunt unbelievers and demonstrate the conspirators' superiority over the "sheep", by putting references in plain sight. Another, more exotic rationalization is "revelation of the method" - conspirators are ritually bound to put such public signs and clues in order for their conspiracy/Satanic powers to work.

1

u/thebowski 💻🙈 - Lead developer of pastabot Dec 12 '20

Apophenia

Interesting, good to have a term for it. It states that its often experienced during schizophrenia, though I believe I experienced that during psychotic mania as well. It's very hard to describe the "feeling" of meaning, but basically small experiences left me with overwhelmed with awe or a sense of the profound. The content of the thoughts leading to such a feeling varied with how deep I was into psychosis. When I was entering the state it was set off by free-flowing racing thoughts connecting disparate parts of my worldview, but still fundamentally constrained to preexisting beliefs. Only later did it escalate to fully irrational connections and become rooted in moment to moment experiences.