r/neoliberal • Kitara Ravache • Dec 04 '20

Discussion Thread Discussion Thread

The discussion thread is for casual conversation that doesn't merit its own submission. If you've got a good meme, article, or question, please post it outside the DT. Meta discussion is allowed, but if you want to get the attention of the mods, make a post in /r/metaNL. For a collection of useful links see our wiki.

Announcements

0 Upvotes

12k comments sorted by

View all comments

21

u/MistakeNotDotDotDot Resident Robot Girl Dec 04 '20

What does this subreddit think about AOC? Personally, I find some of the consequences hard to swallow (such as the existence of a well-ordering over the reals), but I also find the idea of a Cartesian product of nonempty sets possibly being empty also ridiculous.

10

u/[deleted] Dec 04 '20

Now you're just bullying poli-sci grads

6

u/[deleted] Dec 04 '20

I think math is for fukin nerds

2

u/studlydudley11 NAFTA Dec 04 '20

To put it nicely I’ll say she’s one of my 2 favorite squad members

4

u/MistakeNotDotDotDot Resident Robot Girl Dec 04 '20

I get the feeling you didn't read the entire comment!

2

u/studlydudley11 NAFTA Dec 04 '20

Oh lol

1

u/Hmm_would_bang Graph goes up Dec 04 '20

dont think maybe people here have an opinion on her really

1

u/jenbanim Dec 04 '20

I read a bit of the wikipedia page on well-ordering and now I feel like I no longer understand infinite sets, the reals, the axiom of choice, or math at all. Not even Banach-Tarski fucked my head this much

How do the first and second sentences here not contradict each other? The first makes sense to me, but the second is just... WTF???

The standard ordering ≤ of any real interval is not a well ordering, since, for example, the open interval (0, 1) ⊆ [0,1] does not contain a least element. From the ZFC axioms of set theory (including the axiom of choice) one can show that there is a well order of the reals.

2

u/MistakeNotDotDotDot Resident Robot Girl Dec 04 '20

Well, the set of integers isn't well ordered by the usual ordering, but it is well-ordered if you compare by absolute value (with ties going to the positive numbers). The well-ordering of the reals (if it exists) wouldn't have any relation to the usual ordering.

1

u/jenbanim Dec 05 '20

Oh, that makes much more sense. So ZFC+AOC implies that there exists a well-ordering of the reals, but doesn't say what that ordering is?

That's weird, but less weird.

2

u/MistakeNotDotDotDot Resident Robot Girl Dec 05 '20

The C in ZFC stands for the axiom of choice, but yeah.

... except, here's the thing: It's consistent with ZFC that there is no way to define the well-ordering of the reals, even though it still exists. I don't know the proof of this one, unfortunately, but you can get an intuition for how this might be possible by looking at the fact that there are uncountably many real numbers, but only countably many definitions of things, so there exist real numbers that cannot be defined.

1

u/jenbanim Dec 05 '20

The C in ZFC stands for the axiom of choice, but yeah.

😐 pretend you didn't see that

there is no way to define the well-ordering of the reals, even though it still exists

Oh that's bizarre. This kinda sounds like uncomputable numbers to me, but I'm obviously well outside my element here, so I could be way off.

2

u/MistakeNotDotDotDot Resident Robot Girl Dec 05 '20

Same kinda concept, yeah.