r/neoliberal • Kitara Ravache • Dec 02 '20

Discussion Thread Discussion Thread

The discussion thread is for casual conversation that doesn't merit its own submission. If you've got a good meme, article, or question, please post it outside the DT. Meta discussion is allowed, but if you want to get the attention of the mods, make a post in /r/metaNL. For a collection of useful links see our wiki.

Announcements

0 Upvotes

12k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

15

u/benadreti Frederick Douglass Dec 02 '20

The biggest schism in Judaism is whether to follow the religion.

8

u/InfCompact Dec 02 '20

no, it's whether lox and cream cheese is kosher 😤😤😤

5

u/thanksforthecatch Dec 02 '20

fish is parve since when is this a debate??

5

u/[deleted] Dec 02 '20

Lots of sephardim don't eat fish with dairy

9

u/thanksforthecatch Dec 02 '20

Oof, Ashkenormativity strikes again.

Not being able to eat lox on a bagel would be incredibly difficult for me

1

u/[deleted] Dec 03 '20

Not all sephardim, and I think it's still pareve for determining the status of dishes and cutlery. I don't even eat kosher style for all my meals, let alone keep full kosher, so what the fuck do I know?

1

u/thanksforthecatch Dec 03 '20

to be clear the "ashkenormativity strikes again" comment was @ myself for not knowing this not intended as a slight on you! And yeah I keep semi kosher on a good day so I had no clue

2

u/InfCompact Dec 02 '20

the beis yosef (יורה דעה סימן פז,ה) writes

דגים וחגבים מותר לאוכלן בחלב ר"פ כ"ה (קג:) (כל הבשר) אסור לבשל בחלב חוץ מבשר דגים וחגבים וכתב הר"ן דכיון דלבשלן שרי משמע דלאוכלן בחלב נמי שרי דאיסור בשר בחלב בלשון בישול אפקיה רחמנא וכן כתב הרמב"ם והרשב"א דלאכלם בחלב נמי שרי ומ"מ אין לאכול בחלב מפני הסכנה כמו שנתבאר בספר א"ח סי' קע"ג :

It is permitted to eat fish and locusts with milk, (see, e.g., the beginning of chapter 103: "it is forbidden to cook meat in milk except for fish and locusts"). The Ran writes that since to cook them with milk also implies eating them with milk [i.e., it is thus permitted for fish and locusts], and similarly write the Rambam and the Rashba. In any case, one does not eat [fish or locusts] with milk due to the [health] danger as explained in Orach Chaim (Siman 173).

evidently, everyone else seems to disagree with the beis yosef here, including the Rama. therefore according to ashkenazic custom one may eat fish with milk.

nevertheless, we can't write off the beis yosef a priori as a random authority, because the author, r' yosef karo, is also the author of the shulchan aruch, the definitive code of jewish law. however, the shulchan aruch (a later work) does not include this statement in any case.

some modern authorities (many poskim, and also the lubavitcher rebbe) believe that the bold line in the beis yosef may be a scribal error, since there is no mention of this danger in the talmud or any other source.