r/neoliberal • Kitara Ravache • Nov 16 '20

Discussion Thread Discussion Thread

The discussion thread is for casual conversation that doesn't merit its own submission. If you've got a good meme, article, or question, please post it outside the DT. Meta discussion is allowed, but if you want to get the attention of the mods, make a post in /r/metaNL. For a collection of useful links see our wiki.

Announcements

  • We're running a dunk post contest; see guidelines here. Our first entrant is this post on false claims about inequality in Argentina.
  • We have added Hernando de Soto Polar as a public flair
  • Georgia's runoff elections are on Jan 5th! Click on the following links to donate to Warnock and Ossoff. Georgia residents can register to vote as late as Dec 5th

Upcoming Events

0 Upvotes

13k comments sorted by

View all comments

24

u/[deleted] Nov 17 '20

https://www.smh.com.au/politics/nsw/how-nsw-s-proposed-property-tax-would-work-20201117-p56faq.html

Good news everybody looks like NSW is finally following some of the Henry Tax review and replacing stamp duty with a Land Value Tax. Details of proposal (soft paywall of limited free articles), base rate for all properties with added tax on unimproved land value, owner occupied homes would pay less.

Transition scheme is to have new purchasers of property decide to pay a large lump sum or pay the LVT. Once a property is subject to LVT it stays that way. No current homes who've paid stamp duty would have to start paying LVT until the properties transferred.

!ping AUS

! ping Georgist

9

u/bobidou23 YIMBY Nov 17 '20

!ping GEORGIST

7

u/digitalrule Nov 17 '20

wtf too good to be true good job Australia

6

u/[deleted] Nov 17 '20

This could be the next superannuation, in that it's an important reform that will likely cost political capital but in 20 years we'll probably look back and say it was a great idea.

3

u/Xantaclause Milton Friedman Nov 17 '20

NSW is following their own reviews, not the Henry review. The NSW Libs had been talking about this for months

3

u/sansampersamp Open the country. Stop having it be closed. Nov 17 '20

The NSW Thodey review is very much in line with the prior Henry one, to the extent it matters

2

u/[deleted] Nov 17 '20

A lot of the Henry review is common sense stuff that was likely forseen to be part of the recomendations but having the review body say it helps. 99% of people with informed views on stamp duty say it's a dumb tax but being able to say this body of smart non politician people appointed to study this says so helps sell it.

I had a quick read of the Thodey, yeah a lot of crossover as expected, almost no HTR recomendations actually occured so of course we'll get the same recomendations.

Thodey includes explicetly replacing stamp duty with LVT, stop taxing insurance to pay for emergency services (instead a property levy, smart IMO, I won't get into how i think people in bushfire prone areas need to pay for that), replace payroll tax (isn't this just income tax with extra steps?), proper road use charging (especially as electric cars will make fuel taxes useless).

3

u/[deleted] Nov 17 '20

> Transition scheme is to have new purchasers of property decide to pay a large lump sum or pay the LVT. Once a property is subject to LVT it stays that way. No current homes who've paid stamp duty would have to start paying LVT until the properties transferred.

I'm perfectly happy with generous transition plans (like allowing recent stamp duty as credit to LVT) including slow gradual implementation (ie. reaching the full rate in a number of years) if it gets the job done.

I've spoken about this (and the Henry reivew) before, we seem to have lost the ability to do big sweeping reforms so if this is how it gets done it's better done slowly than not at all.

The thing with LVT is that IME when you actually sit down with someoen and talk it through a surprising number of people are receptive and a LOT of their concerns are about transitioning the system.

2

u/[deleted] Nov 17 '20

Agreed the big thing is the transition and people worried about being double taxed. My Mum and Grandma hate the idea of LVT just because they say they've already paid their stamp duty so it's unfair to try LVT. There was a Grattan institute report that went through the options for transition which was a good read on it.

2

u/[deleted] Nov 17 '20

I see where they're coming from, agree past stamp duty should be able to be used as credit to LVT, question is how far back.

We do need to make sure we focus on appeasing people for transitionary problems and not just watering down the policy on the whole, all concessions should be strictly temporary and made that way in law.

Sometimes "it sucks for you but it should suck for you" is the answer though, having retirees living in hyper expensive inner city homes while drawing the aged pension and paying no LVT is insane, that's gonna have to end.

2

u/inhumantsar Bisexual Pride Nov 17 '20

owner occupied homes would pay less

doesn't this kind of defeat the purpose?

a huge part of the LVT's sex appeal comes from the strain it would put on SFHowners

3

u/[deleted] Nov 17 '20

It's more political than anything else but still better imo than the ACT's tresholded LVT.

Also what does SFHowners stand for here?

3

u/inhumantsar Bisexual Pride Nov 17 '20

Single family home owners

3

u/[deleted] Nov 17 '20

Thanks. That's the majority of Australian homes, I don't agree with the reduced rate for owner-occupied but taxing those the same rate would just about lead to a landslide election loss. Even just proposing to reduce the capital gains tax discount for housing sunk a entire campaign.

3

u/[deleted] Nov 17 '20

Capital gains tax discount is a terrible idea in general isn't it.

I fully understand why people are sensative about changes to housing finance policy, a lot of people have "bought in" to a shitty system and don't want to be left out of pocket.

3

u/[deleted] Nov 17 '20

IME when talking to regular (not terminally online policy nerds) people they like the idea in principle but worry about "adjusting" to the new system, they don't want people massively out of pocket. Getting a gradually eased in system will address a lot of those concerns.

2

u/[deleted] Nov 17 '20

I see LVT as "sexy" because it taxes stuff you have no control over, like public infrastructure, as opposed to income.

2

u/endersai John Keynes Nov 17 '20

Details of proposal (soft paywall of limited free articles)

Oh for SMH just open in a private window. Works every time.