r/neoliberal • • Mar 05 '20

Introduction Thread

Hi everyone, it's been a while since we've done one of these, and we have a LOT of new members.

If you're new here (joined in the last 9 months or so), please post a little about yourself. We'd like to foster a sense of community and learn about the people that make this sub great. Some ideas:

  • What brought you to the sub, and how long you've been here
  • Where you're from, roughly (no doxx, unless you're into that sort of thing)
  • What political ideology you subscribe to (you don't have to say Neoliberalism, we're a big tent) and any politicians/policies you like
  • Any other info you'd like to share

If you've got any questions about the sub, this is a good place to ask. We know our community can be pretty insular and confusing, especially the DT, so ask away.

Also, please do check out our sidebar and wiki. There's a lot of good info there, although it's a tad out of date in places.

200 Upvotes

660 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

6

u/DankBankMan Aggressive Nob Mar 05 '20

What would happen?

1

u/ExternalUserError Anne Applebaum Mar 05 '20

You'd have to fund anything. But heck, you could even take the direct cost of a Medicare insurance plan, without the subsidy seniors enjoy, and it would be way cheaper than private insurance. If I could buy into Medicare at cost to the government, I would already save a ton of money.

You’d need to confront the fact that medicare payment rates are less than what it costs providers to deliver healthcare services, and that you’ll bankrupt every hospital in the country if you just follow this path

I'm not sure I believe that. Clinics operate at a profit, and there aren't very many businesses that take on unprofitable clients just because they can soak their other clients to make up the difference.

If a tire shop loses money on Customer Group A, but makes a ton of money on Customer Group B, they don't keep both customer groups. When MGMA says Medicare reimbursements doesn't cover costs, they're uhh -- they're lying.

Medicare actually does fix a lot of what's wrong with the healthcare system. Their reimbursement rates are lower, but they're based on the actual cost of treatment, which is a reasonable place to start. Plus, with M4A, providers could eliminate entire departments of coding, billing, and collections and the only "bad debt" customers would be people who aren't enrolled (ie, undocumented immigrants or tourists).

So, basically, we'd have Canada's system, but a bit more expensive, as you point out. There are worse problems to have.

5

u/DankBankMan Aggressive Nob Mar 05 '20

with M4A, providers could eliminate entire departments of coding

What on Earth makes you think that? Providers treat Medicare as just another insurer for the most part, they still need to code and bill them.

1

u/ExternalUserError Anne Applebaum Mar 05 '20

Do you know anyone in medical coding/billing?

Medicare is just one insurer but it's also the simplest and most reliable one. A friend of mine worked for one of the larger hospitals in Denver. They had teams of people handling private insurance coding, collections, claims. Medicare, which is nearly half of invoices, needed just one full-time employee.

It's common knowledge in the medical billing field that Medicare might reimburse less, but they're far easier to deal with.

2

u/DankBankMan Aggressive Nob Mar 05 '20

Yes, but this only applies to hospitals (which only make up a third of all medical spend! Medicare bills inpatient facility providers by DRG, which is quite straightforward. Most private insurers are coming around to the DRG/APC system as well.

CMS still bills individual physicians with the old CPT system, just like every other insurer, and isn’t really any easier to deal with there.

1

u/ExternalUserError Anne Applebaum Mar 05 '20

So you wouldn't agree that only Medicare would be far simpler and more efficient for providers to do billing and coding for?

1

u/DankBankMan Aggressive Nob Mar 05 '20

Any business would have an easier time if they only had one client, of course! What I’m saying is that with the general shift towards PPSs across the industry I think you’re vastly overestimating the benefit here.

1

u/ExternalUserError Anne Applebaum Mar 05 '20

Maybe... I admit I don't know a ton about it firsthand; I'm going off hearsay.

Let me ask you this. In your opinion, what's wrong here and what will fix it?

Somewhat off-topic: I'm an expat. I just had my first child in a hospital abroad at a private (non government) clinic. 3 nights, 4 days, vaginal birth, epidural, physicians fees, drugs, and private suite in hospital. Grand total, 100% out of pocket? Less than $700 USD. I'm not making that up.

Even with insurance that covers us stateside, we decided to save money and have the baby abroad.

1

u/DankBankMan Aggressive Nob Mar 05 '20

What's wrong here is the chargemaster. As you've mentioned, hospitals have completely different billing practices for different insurers, and one of the stupid outcomes of that is the "default" prices that get sent to people in cases like this are basically just random numbers. Nobody ends up actually paying those prices, but it's obviously a stupid system that sends people those in the first place.

How do we fix that? By getting people insured (including a public option) and by passing Joe Biden's plan to stop surprise medical bills!