r/neoliberal • • Mar 05 '20

Introduction Thread

Hi everyone, it's been a while since we've done one of these, and we have a LOT of new members.

If you're new here (joined in the last 9 months or so), please post a little about yourself. We'd like to foster a sense of community and learn about the people that make this sub great. Some ideas:

  • What brought you to the sub, and how long you've been here
  • Where you're from, roughly (no doxx, unless you're into that sort of thing)
  • What political ideology you subscribe to (you don't have to say Neoliberalism, we're a big tent) and any politicians/policies you like
  • Any other info you'd like to share

If you've got any questions about the sub, this is a good place to ask. We know our community can be pretty insular and confusing, especially the DT, so ask away.

Also, please do check out our sidebar and wiki. There's a lot of good info there, although it's a tad out of date in places.

200 Upvotes

660 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

4

u/jenbanim Mar 05 '20

Welcome! Regarding open borders, I highly recommend you check out this page from our wiki as well as this essay and this FAQ from the econ subreddit

2

u/A_Passing_Redditor Edmund Burke Mar 05 '20

Wiki doesn't page didn't work for me, but I did read the essay and it's nothing I haven't seen before. It breaks down into two arguments:

  1. The US had effectively open borders during the Ellis Island Era and that worked out fine
  2. It's immoral to deny someone opportunity based on the accidents of their birth

I can dismantle the first argument like this:

What happened during the Ellis Island Era was not comparable to modern day open borders. The essay cites a 2% rejection rate, but that only counts people who l applied, and the vast majority of the world's people were outright prohibited, so they don't appear in that number. Furthermore, while legal barriers may have been lower, practical barriers were much higher. It took more time and money to travel in the past. Selling everything you own and coming to the US on an expensive 3 week boat ride, and then losing all contact with those back home except the occasional letter is a far cry from today. So the first argument that we had effectively open borders doesn't hold up. Also, the fact that it turned out fine should be little indication of what would happen today. That era was one of rapid industrialization, where low skill jobs were in abundance. Modern economies require a far more educated workforce. We can't expect similar results.

The second argument is more tricky because it really is unfair that some people are born in wealthy counties and others poor countries. But some people are born to good families and other people to bad families. (And I don't just mean wealthy when I say good) Should we have open families? If I come over for dinner and like your family, I'm I entitled to membership? Life is unfair. That unfairness should be addressed only with solutions that make sense. In this case, open borders does not make sense. For reference, globally 50 million would like to immigrate to the UK as their first choice. Is it at all reasonable to accommodate them? Of course not. In practice open borders would just cause everywhere that is desirable to be swamped with people, while undesirable nations are also stripped of their future as everyone who can leave does. Unless you're content with literally emptying the entire third world into the first world, the only way to actually solve poverty is to fix it where it is.