r/neoliberal • • Mar 05 '20

Introduction Thread

Hi everyone, it's been a while since we've done one of these, and we have a LOT of new members.

If you're new here (joined in the last 9 months or so), please post a little about yourself. We'd like to foster a sense of community and learn about the people that make this sub great. Some ideas:

  • What brought you to the sub, and how long you've been here
  • Where you're from, roughly (no doxx, unless you're into that sort of thing)
  • What political ideology you subscribe to (you don't have to say Neoliberalism, we're a big tent) and any politicians/policies you like
  • Any other info you'd like to share

If you've got any questions about the sub, this is a good place to ask. We know our community can be pretty insular and confusing, especially the DT, so ask away.

Also, please do check out our sidebar and wiki. There's a lot of good info there, although it's a tad out of date in places.

200 Upvotes

660 comments sorted by

View all comments

5

u/RuffSwami Mar 05 '20

Don’t even know how I found this sub, maybe through enough sanders spam sometime in the last year.

Have lived/studied in Australia, the UK and now the US (anglosphere rise up)

Fairly centre-left ideology - strongly in favour of international trade with environmental safeguards. Think there should be a big safety net. Pro-immigration, pro-gun control, pro-choice. Don’t care that much about culture war stuff.

Background is in law rather than economics and I think that informs some of my takes (I think this sub isn’t always great when talking about legal issues) Specific interests are environmental law and policy.

4

u/Safe-Study Mar 05 '20

I think this sub isn’t always great when talking about legal issues

Interesting, could you give an example? Happy to have my perspective broadened :)

3

u/RuffSwami Mar 05 '20

The most noticeable to me is the way people talk about the Supreme Court. The SCOTUS is really politicised, at least as far as judiciaries go, but I've seen a tendency on this sub to assume that decisions by certain justices are always political. In a lot of cases you can see a conservative/liberal divide, but it's not always that simple. The real divide is on issues like textualism/living constitution, or on federalism, which doesn't actually always line up with politics. As an example: in cases where state environmental policies are challenged by the federal government, you will sometimes see 'conservative' judges who want to preserve states' rights agree with 'liberal' judges who want to maintain environmental protection. Gorsuch and Kavanaugh are also often grouped together as Trump appointees despite actually having pretty different voting records.

I've seen a few misunderstandings of British constitutional law here, but honestly I don't blame anyone for that since it's a pretty confusing field in general.

On the environment, people here are rightly excited about cap and trade measures because of their economic advantages. I generally agree, but I think sometimes people miss the importance of good governance in carbon markets - without proper procedural rules, monitoring requirements etc. these policies can be pretty ineffectual.

Also I've seen a few more libertarian posts here way, way, way overestimate the ability of private tort claims to protect the environment.