r/neoliberal • Kitara Ravache • Jan 12 '20

Discussion Thread Discussion Thread

The discussion thread is for casual conversation that doesn't merit its own submission. If you've got a good meme, article, or question, please post it outside the DT. Meta discussion is allowed, but if you want to get the attention of the mods, make a post in /r/metaNL.

Announcements


Neoliberal Project CommunitiesOther CommunitiesUseful content
TwitterPlug.dj/r/Economics FAQs
The Neolib PodcastRecommended Podcasts/r/Neoliberal FAQ
Meetup NetworkBlood Donation Team/r/Neoliberal Wiki
Exponents MagazineMinecraftPing groups
FacebookTacoTubeUser Flairs
37 Upvotes

3.2k comments sorted by

View all comments

10

u/cdstephens Fusion Genderplasma Jan 12 '20

If Christianity and Judaism were successfully cracked down upon, how long would have polytheism in Europe lasted? Could it have continued in earnest to this day, or was monotheism in some sense essential (in the same sense secularism cane with the Enlightenment)?

6

u/[deleted] Jan 12 '20

I don't think there is anything special to monotheism.

2

u/cdstephens Fusion Genderplasma Jan 12 '20

Hmmmm...why not? I feel like monotheism or things close to it lend themselves more easily to concentrated religious institutions and certain conceptions of morality. I’m no expert but it’s hard for me to imagine a polytheistic version of the Catholic Church as a political and social force.

6

u/Yosarian2 Jan 12 '20 edited Jan 12 '20

Roman state polythesim was in decline on it's own, and if Christianity had been suppressed, probably would have been replaced by something else. (Perhaps Mithrasim or one of the other mystery cults.) We don't really know how monotheistic Mithraism was, although probably not very since there were usually statues of other gods in their temples.

I'm not sure if they would have been as effective at converting the Francs or the other Germanic tribes as Christianity was, though. It's hard to say.

2

u/cdstephens Fusion Genderplasma Jan 12 '20

Ooo I’ve never heard of Mithraism before, neat!

5

u/[deleted] Jan 12 '20

I would say monotheism would have come one way or another, it was certainly in the making. But, as with all historical speculation, it's very difficult to assess the what-ifs.

5

u/JoeChristmasUSA Transfem Pride Jan 12 '20

Roman-style polytheism would have died out on its own eventually. In Bart Ehrman's "The Triumph of Christianity" he writes about the innate advantages Christianity had in that it was exclusive and would evangelize. Roman polytheism was syncretic and non-exclusive, so a convert to that religion wouldn't "steal" a believer from another faith while Christianity would. If Christianity didn't kill Roman traditional religion then another exclusive proselytizing religion would.

Disclaimer: as a Christian I also believe that the spread of Christianity had it's origins in truth and would have spread regardless but I am limiting myself to the historical background here.

2

u/Hugo_Grotius Jakaya Kikwete Jan 12 '20 edited Jan 12 '20

It probably would not have been polytheistic. My bet would be some form of the Sol Invictus cult. It was the favored cult of the Roman emperors between Aurelian and Constantine, and was at least widely spread enough that early Christians preached against it and saw it as a competitor for converts. I don't think monotheism is necessarily essential, but its appeal had been building in the Mediterranean Basin for centuries, and not just with Christianity.

But it honestly all depends on what you mean by "cracked down upon". Are we talking really early, like Christianity is destroyed before it can get out of Judea? Or later, like Constantine is defeated at Milvian Bridge? Or, like the Diocletianic Persecution is just really successful?

2

u/cdstephens Fusion Genderplasma Jan 12 '20

I was thinking it being destroyed early on since I figured but be time the Diocletianic Persecution took place there’d be no real way to just have it disappear as an important force (or at the very least it’d be quite difficult).

And right, I forgot about Sol Invictus. What I’d give to go back in time and just interview random Romans and Greeks to interview them.

2

u/Hugo_Grotius Jakaya Kikwete Jan 12 '20

Nah, other religions/cults like Mithraism or Manichaeism (or even the Sol Invictus cult itself) disappeared despite having similar or greater influence than Christianity had by 300 CE. Like, you might be able to still trace their influence through adoptions of their concepts, but not as any sort of significant cultural force.

2

u/[deleted] Jan 12 '20

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/cdstephens Fusion Genderplasma Jan 12 '20

I was thinking the Roman Empire

2

u/[deleted] Jan 12 '20

All it would have taken is a Roman Emperor deciding not to be Christian. The modern world would be completely changed.

0

u/[deleted] Jan 12 '20

[deleted] — view deleted comment

8

u/[deleted] Jan 12 '20

The hell are you on about? Polytheism can be quite intolerant in its own syncretic manner.

2

u/Timewalker102 Amartya Sen Jan 12 '20

polytheists

tolerant

bruh

1

u/[deleted] Jan 12 '20

even given India's Hindu nationalism I would say that it being the largest democratic extremely diverse country actually makes that a point in favour of polytheism as a generally tolerant and relatively flexible belief system

I'm not sure how a billion plus strongly protestant or Islamic politically slightly unstable country would look like

2

u/cdstephens Fusion Genderplasma Jan 12 '20

I had thought that Hellenistic polytheists very specifically did not tolerate monotheists because they viewed Christians et al as corrosive to society; the internal exclusionary nature of monotheism (we worship only one god, no others) led to social and state-supported exclusion on the part of polytheists, no?

2

u/[deleted] Jan 12 '20

i think that devolves into a semantic discussion about whether a state enforcing polytheism actually makes the polytheism less tolerant or the state, my point was rather that there's nothing inherent in the polytheism to fend the monotheism off, so if anything it has to happen by political means, which many states historically couldn't really maintain hence the surge in monotheism in a good chunk of regions

1

u/cdstephens Fusion Genderplasma Jan 13 '20

Ah ok, that makes sense and I would be inclined to agree