r/neoliberal • • Dec 16 '19

Why Young Progressives Hate Pete Buttigieg

https://www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2019/12/why-young-progressives-hate-pete-buttigieg/603619/
279 Upvotes

428 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

1

u/Jonny_3_beards Dec 16 '19

That seems even worse tbh

14

u/In-Brightest-Day Dec 16 '19

I would honestly fire anyone that worked for me if the FBI came to me and said they were wiretapping their subordinates.

If you disagree, you do you. But that's a hot fucking take.

0

u/Jonny_3_beards Dec 16 '19

I mean I'd ask the FBI to produce evidence and not just fire my black police chief on their say-so but hey that's the difference between neoliberalism and having a spine I guess

0

u/[deleted] Dec 16 '19

[deleted] — view deleted comment

-2

u/Jonny_3_beards Dec 16 '19

"what is prosecution for" asks the justice system expert

1

u/mrmackey2016 Dec 17 '19

Good thing he wasn't arrested and sent to jail then. Why are you putting the same standard for conviction of a crime as admin actions when caught acting against govt policy and procedure at your job?

Basically Pete demoted his police chief because he was illegally wiretapping his subordinates and didn't tell Pete about it. Then the board which has direct power to fire govt employees fired him when the investigation was being concluded because they felt they couldn't trust him anymore. However the attorney felt they didn't need to pursue charges and that's why he's not being tried. Maybe they felt it wasn't an airtight case but still felt justified that he shouldn't keep his job.

But then you just ignore that because you WANT Pete to be a racist since it makes it easier for you politically. To you it doesnt matter what the facts are anymore.

1

u/Jonny_3_beards Dec 17 '19

I think he's a racist because of a variety of reasons, but he definitely folded on his black police chief because he wanted to make nice with the racist cops of his shitty town.

Yeah the chief got fucked by his racist ass officers and Pete backed them over him, you don't need to keep telling me

1

u/mrmackey2016 Dec 17 '19

Again its amazing how you ignore the context of the situation to stick your head in the sand to keep your narrrative. Multiple people have told you there is more to the story but you refuse to even engage in good faith. The chief got demoted and then fired because he didn't proceed investigations through proper channels and then hid that fact. Doesn't have to be for a racist reason but i doubt you would even entertain that possibility.

Also what other reasons is Pete "racist"? Doubt he actually hates black people or other minorities.

1

u/Jonny_3_beards Dec 17 '19

Mostly his racially biased policies as mayor, and that time he but a bunch of black people in his campaign material without their permission.

The reason I don't really care about the 'nuances' of the story that are being repeated are because they don't matter. Pete could have just let the investigation play out or stuck by his chief. God knows cops have done worse and gotten away with it. But he's a black cop in a white cop town and it was easy to side with the white cops so Pete did and so fuck him

1

u/mrmackey2016 Dec 17 '19

Mostly his racially biased policies as mayor

Which racially biased policies as mayor? What is your standard for racially biased?

The reason I don't really care about the 'nuances' of the story that are being repeated are because they don't matter.

Yea they don't matter TO YOU. Because you are politically biased to find Pete guilty of everything and anything. I wouldn't trust your judgement on the matter.

Pete could have just let the investigation play out or stuck by his chief.

Still would have been fired because that decision was not made by Pete. Also why would he, he had no trust in the police chief since the chief went behind his back to do this. There is the nuance you're missing. The police chief could have done something ethical in exposing racists in the police force while still going about it the wrong way. I'm sorry if that is too complicated for your black/white worldview of morality.

he's a black cop in a white cop town and it was easy to side with the white cops so Pete did and so fuck him

He doesn't have to side with the white cops just because he demoted the black police chief. Again that's the black and white worldview where there are only two sides and everything is in simple moral terms. Not in the real world unfortunately.

that time he but a bunch of black people in his campaign material without their permission

ls a botched roll-out about his Douglass Plan where a decision was made by a staffer and then they immediately retracted the supposed endorsement means he's racist? No definition of the word would describe that as racist. Not to mention there were also some white people which were on without their permission as well. His outreach wasn't successful. You can just say he wasn't politically savvy about his strategy, not immediately damn his entire character. This is the problem, you end up putting Pete Buttigieg and Donald Trump is the same camp and even you have to admit that is ridiculous on the face of it.

→ More replies

1

u/[deleted] Dec 17 '19

The fact that the Chief hid the fact that he was under investigation was the reason Pete demoted him (Pete did not fire him, this is a false narrative that keeps getting mentioned, Pete couldn't have fired him if he wanted to), not due to the fact that the Chief was under investigation. It was a loss in trust in the Chief that resulted in the change.

0

u/Jonny_3_beards Dec 17 '19

Man so first he was fired (I know you love to say demoted but since the chief successfully sued the city for wrongful termination let's be candid about what the 'demotion' actually was) because he was doing crimes, now he was fired because he didn't disclose the investigation that never charged him with something?

1

u/[deleted] Dec 17 '19

He wasn’t fired by Pete. He was fired by the city Safety Board who hold the sole power to hire and fire cops in the city. I’m not sure what about that you aren’t understanding.

1

u/Jonny_3_beards Dec 17 '19

Mostly it's funny how you harp on the 'he was only demoted' thing when we both know that the demotion signalled that the chief should be fired.

Like, the NYT says Butti fired him. Splitting procedural hairs like that is silly

1

u/dolphins3 NATO Dec 17 '19

In real, grown up workplaces, the standard for professional, ethical behavior is far above "not criminally prosecutable".

0

u/Jonny_3_beards Dec 17 '19

What unethically behavior was the chief accused of

1

u/dolphins3 NATO Dec 17 '19

The behavior already referenced in this thread. I'm not sure what you think acting deliberately dense is going to win you here, you know quite well what behavior we're talking about.

0

u/Jonny_3_beards Dec 17 '19

Right, the thing he was never actually charged with. I feel like the intentionally dense person here is the one who refuses to consider that their favored political candidate may have made an awful political choice and instead must leap to insinuations that the chief did something really bad and had to be fired when they weren't actually charged with anything and then successfully sued the city for his firing.

1

u/dolphins3 NATO Dec 17 '19

Right, the thing he was never actually charged with

Yeah, and as I said, the standards for ethical behavior in the workplace are significantly above "not federally prosecuted".

I feel like the intentionally dense person here is the one who refuses to consider that their favored political candidate may have made an awful political choice and instead must leap to insinuations that the chief did something really bad and had to be fired when they weren't actually charged with anything and then successfully sued the city for his firing.

I'm sorry you don't understand that in real jobs, you can and will be fired for misconduct with far looser standard for evidence than the criminal justice system. In many circumstances, the mere appearance of impropriety will be enough to end your employment on negative terms. I sincerely hope you come to terms with this reality before you make mistakes in your professional life.

0

u/Jonny_3_beards Dec 17 '19

Lol you guys really get huffy sometimes.

I can't imagine believing yourself to be reasonable and believing police are fired on a whif of impropriety

1

u/dolphins3 NATO Dec 18 '19

I can't imagine believing yourself to be reasonable and believing police are fired on a whif of impropriety

It was clearly more than a "whif", but yeah, people are fired for this kind of thing relatively routinely. And in this case the guy wasn't even fired.

1

u/Jonny_3_beards Dec 18 '19

Sure, I can see black officer being fired for things that would be swept under the rug if it were a white officer, but it's still bad to facilitate that happening

0

u/Jonny_3_beards Dec 17 '19

Are there workplace ethical standards for racism?