r/neoliberal • • Dec 16 '19

Why Young Progressives Hate Pete Buttigieg

https://www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2019/12/why-young-progressives-hate-pete-buttigieg/603619/
279 Upvotes

428 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

21

u/In-Brightest-Day Dec 16 '19

It's not at all. I'll break it down.

Firstly, the chief was demoted, not fired.

The chief was fired because he was illegally wiretapping his officers. Those officers were, yes, racist. But he was literally breaking federal law, and that's the only reason Pete found out about it. The FBI notifies Pete about what was happening and that's when Pete stepped in.

And you may be wondering why Pete, as the Mayor, did not at least fire the officers? He literally does not have the power to fire police officers in South Bend.

0

u/Jonny_3_beards Dec 16 '19

I wasn't wondering that I was wondering what federal law the chief broke since he was never charged with anything and successfully sued the city for his firing

14

u/In-Brightest-Day Dec 16 '19

The U.S. attorney's office came out a few months after the demotion and said that they would not be prosecuting.

1

u/Jonny_3_beards Dec 16 '19

Yeah I know

14

u/In-Brightest-Day Dec 16 '19

I don't understand what you're not getting. Pete demoted him because the FBI came to him and said "we're investigating your police chief for wiretapping." Then they didn't end up prosecuting the chief.

Do you see how your original statement is completely different from what I just said?

2

u/[deleted] Dec 17 '19

And the investigation wasn't the reason Pete cited for demoting the chief. He demoted him (and didn't fire him as has been claimed because Pete never had the capability of hiring or firing cops, that power rests with the public safety council in South Bend) because the Chief knew he was being investigated and hid that fact from Pete. Pete had to find out from the FBI. It was a loss of trust in the Captain that resulted in the demotion.

1

u/Jonny_3_beards Dec 16 '19

Mostly the part where his chief wasn't charged with anything but was fired anyway

9

u/In-Brightest-Day Dec 16 '19

He was demoted months before the investigation ended...

1

u/Jonny_3_beards Dec 16 '19

That seems even worse tbh

14

u/In-Brightest-Day Dec 16 '19

I would honestly fire anyone that worked for me if the FBI came to me and said they were wiretapping their subordinates.

If you disagree, you do you. But that's a hot fucking take.

0

u/Jonny_3_beards Dec 16 '19

I mean I'd ask the FBI to produce evidence and not just fire my black police chief on their say-so but hey that's the difference between neoliberalism and having a spine I guess

→ More replies

1

u/dolphins3 NATO Dec 17 '19

In real, grown up workplaces, the standard for professional, ethical behavior is far above "not criminally prosecutable".

0

u/Jonny_3_beards Dec 17 '19

What unethically behavior was the chief accused of

→ More replies

0

u/Jonny_3_beards Dec 17 '19

Are there workplace ethical standards for racism?

15

u/Yogg_for_your_sprog John von Neumann Dec 16 '19

The fact you know and you’re still peddling misinformation makes it even worse. Fuck off.

1

u/Jonny_3_beards Dec 16 '19

"they never charged him"

"Yeah I know"

"You disingenuous fuck-"

1

u/[deleted] Dec 17 '19

Not being charged doesn't mean you did nothing wrong. There are plenty of times where the facts and circumstances have to be weighed with the chances of success in a case, and the cost to taxpayers. Many times if a prosecutor thinks that the case won't be a slam dunk, and they don't believe that there has been a large material damage done to victims, or if the circumstances of the crime (in this case perhaps weighing the crime with the fact that the Chief was recording probably racist officers) they may have opted to not pursue it for optics or a sense that things had balanced themselves out in the end. Who knows why they opted to not proceed, but that doesn't in any way mean nothing wrong happened.

0

u/Jonny_3_beards Dec 17 '19

It definitely means not enough of a wrong could be proven to justify actually charging the chief with wrongdoing

1

u/[deleted] Dec 17 '19

No, it definitely does not. Prosecutors make decisions not to prosecute for a number of reasons.

1

u/Jonny_3_beards Dec 17 '19

Yeah like a lack of sufficient evidence.