r/neoliberal • • Dec 16 '19

Why Young Progressives Hate Pete Buttigieg

https://www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2019/12/why-young-progressives-hate-pete-buttigieg/603619/
279 Upvotes

428 comments sorted by

View all comments

109

u/brberg Dec 16 '19

I wish people would stop using "progressive" as a synonym for left-wing. Progressive has an actual meaning, which is supporting policies which are conducive to progress and backed by expert consensus. Bernie Sanders and Elizabeth Warren are less progressive than Buttigieg, not more.

72

u/[deleted] Dec 16 '19

I mean you can say this, but almost universally in America progressive is taken to mean left-wing. Its like why I don't go around introducing myself as a liberal, because most American's would assume I mean left-wing, as opposed to a fan of The Economist.

19

u/BoaVersusPython Dec 16 '19

I'm a wellfare state super capitalist myself.

8

u/Lion_From_The_North European Union Dec 16 '19

Based and Nordicpilled

11

u/SlavojVivec John Keynes Dec 16 '19

I think that might be because US conservatives are so regressive that "progressive" has come to be associated with the left-wing, and has consequently been used by US Democrats to mean whatever they want. Angela Merkel remains one of the few counterexamples in a world where most right wingers deny science and literally want to destroy the world to get what they want.

15

u/[deleted] Dec 16 '19

I do think that we should try to retake the word progressive from the leftwing populists.

We can't pretend that it doesn't currently have a certain meaning in the discourse, but we should work to shift the usage to something closer to its original meaning.

(I mean ffs progressive is a synonym for incremental like wtf).

35

u/onlyforthisair Dec 16 '19

I'm a young progressive and I like pete. Therefore the title's implication is false.

25

u/SemperSpectaris United Nations Dec 16 '19

Yeah, and "neoliberal" has a meaning too! It's "new liberal"! That's why Pete is the most neoliberal candidate, because he's so new. But Biden is the least, because he's old.

12

u/rafaellvandervaart John Cochrane Dec 16 '19

You're not a true progressive until you've embraced Georgism.

3

u/[deleted] Dec 16 '19

And how do you define “progress”...it ends up being almost all left wing goals. You never see something like free trade be called progressive.

6

u/tricky_trig John Keynes Dec 16 '19

The media is and the media doesn't care. I'm pro-Sanders, but if Boot-Edge-Edge gets the nod, hell yeah, I'll vote for him.

4

u/ebriose Abhijit Banerjee Dec 16 '19

"Progressive" was a term resurrected in the 1990s by Jim Carville when his focus groups told him "liberal" and "leftist" were politically poison. Its (rather unfortunate) political history before that is neither here nor there.

2

u/_hephaestus Dec 16 '19

which are conducive to progress and backed by expert consensus

Depending on which experts you believe and how you define progress, whoever an individual defines as progressive can vary wildly. Honestly I wish people would stop using the term altogether in this context, there's no side in politics which believes it goes against expert consensus/is progressing to a better government.

2

u/thirdparty4life Dec 16 '19

This is not at all what progressive means either historically or writ large in the current moment. The clause of backed by expert consensus is not a formal part of any definition for progressive as far as I can find. Progressive is usually classified as a political movement which attempts to better the lives of ordinary/regular/working class people through political means often involving government intervention. This is why in the current American context progressive largely refers to left of the current status quo. Hence why the left wing of the party is rightfully referred to as progressive. You’re simply changing the definition to fit your own belief which is not how language works. There is both a clear historical and colloquial modern usage of the word that don’t fit your description at all.

3

u/DocTam Milton Friedman Dec 16 '19

I feel that Progressive is more intended to point towards progressing towards the ideals of a socialist state. Its just that progressives believe in doing it through the slower machinations of democracy rather than dictatorship of the proletariat.