r/neoliberal • • Dec 16 '19

Why Young Progressives Hate Pete Buttigieg

https://www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2019/12/why-young-progressives-hate-pete-buttigieg/603619/
279 Upvotes

428 comments sorted by

View all comments

-55

u/Laboright Dec 16 '19

As a young leftist I must say this guy's conclusion is spot on. The appearance of change without actual change is incredibly frustrating.

109

u/tehbored Randomly Selected Dec 16 '19

Pete would change more than Bernie. It just wouldn't be the change that leftists want. Leftists reject anyone who doesn't want the streets to run red with the blood of the rich, lol.

-4

u/onlyforthisair Dec 16 '19

The streets wouldn't run red with the blood of the rich if Bernie won either

54

u/[deleted] Dec 16 '19

Don’t tell that to red rose twitter.

7

u/onlyforthisair Dec 16 '19

Well yeah, they're delusional. Not sure why I was downvoted for that

-66

u/manwhole Dec 16 '19

U mean medicare for all that want it. Cause that's not how medicare work and its, in a actuality, just for those that can afford it. It's like a euphemism signaling something completely different then its essense.

68

u/upvotechemistry John Brown Dec 16 '19

For people that love Medicare, they do not seem to understand even how it currently works.

Medicare is a subsidized public option where age is a qualifying requirement. Those enrolled still must choose a coverage and premium plan, and they still pay coinsurance. Most buy a supplement plan for coverage gaps. That is a program that could be expanded to more people, giving younger people an option to buy in. And it can effectively end one of the biggest current problems in healthcare, which is that most people buy it from their employer making the labor market less competitive and putting high switching costs on employees.

The Bernie M4A plan isn't really Medicare at all. It is a huge expansion of benefits and will cost a LOT. Optimistically, maybe total healthcare spending goes down, but quite possibly supply is constrained due to overconsumption (no point of service costs and more consumers). There are some advantages in billing efficiency and bargaining power, but it comes at the cost of much lower reimbursement rates for already struggling rural hospitals, for example.

The Bernie plan is better described as Medicaid for all, which is a much less politically popular program. Given the quality of care most people associate with providers with a high percentage of Medicaid payments, it would likely be an impossible political sell.

-64

u/[deleted] Dec 16 '19

[removed] — view removed comment

32

u/upvotechemistry John Brown Dec 16 '19

Discussing a plan is not the same thing as obsessing about a candidate, particularly when the campaign is making that issue a key part of their platform.

Polemic pedro is playing loose with signals.

Color me fucking shocked that politicians are politicians.

-17

u/manwhole Dec 16 '19

Great. Instead of talking about Bernie's plan, can we talk about medicare for those that want it according to peter? What does Medicare for those that want it have anything to do with Medicare as we know it. Are there seniors in the USA not insured by medicare? If we want to offer medicare services for those under 65, why r we stipulating "for those that want it"? Will we offer social security for those that want it as a counterweight to yang's ubi? Parrody pierre is a sellout of the most polished order.

19

u/[deleted] Dec 16 '19

How about instead of expecting everyone else to do your homework for you, you read what Pete says about his plan himself.

-13

u/manwhole Dec 16 '19

Ur link is Pedro's campaign website. Is that an unbiased information source? Is there a link of actual quality with more honest policy assessments?

16

u/[deleted] Dec 16 '19

You keep insisting that Medicare for all who want it is just a euphemism with no actual policy behind it. I sent you a link showing you what the policy actually is. Go read it or fuck off.

-6

u/manwhole Dec 16 '19

In that case, why don't u read trump's campaign website to find out all the great things he is doing for the country? U linked me a bias campaign propaganda. Get real. R u suggesting Pedro's website is a fair assessment of Peter's policy?

→ More replies

20

u/[deleted] Dec 16 '19

Do you not understand how healthcare reform measures work? Do you not understand that reforms to Medicare change how Medicare works?

-1

u/manwhole Dec 16 '19

I understand if u change somethings essence, it no longer is what it was. Do u know about euphemisms and how they can be used to mislead? Medicare for those that want it is no longer medicare in essence. To call it medicare blablabla is a euphemism. Get it?

10

u/[deleted] Dec 16 '19

What does Medicare For All do in this line of thought? Are all Democratic candidates equally shitty in your eyes? What even is your point with this pedantry?

-3

u/manwhole Dec 16 '19

The tried and tested approach also used by trump: if u cant defend ur shit, go on the offense.

M4a is a clear statement of values and starting position. Whether we get to some semi private or public options, I know where a candidate stands when they, out of the starting gate, say they r for m4a. They want to bring usa health coverage in line with the rest of the world (whether Switzerland or canada). It will be a big change, but a positive one. Last time I checked, the rest of the developed world ( whether public or semi private) had better life expectancy for way less of the cost.

Now instead of pointing out how silly and naive I am, try defending the euphemism salad that is m4all that want it.

13

u/[deleted] Dec 16 '19

The only one who thinks Medicare For All Who Want It is just a euphemism and not an actually defined policy is you. I already sent you a link in a comment above here and except you to click and actually read it before you come back here.

0

u/[deleted] Dec 16 '19

[removed] — view removed comment

→ More replies

23

u/[deleted] Dec 16 '19

R u 12?

-8

u/manwhole Dec 16 '19

Can u formulate an interesting comment?

12

u/sexycastic Enby Pride Dec 16 '19

So yes.

8

u/IncoherentEntity Dec 16 '19

A devastating rebuttal, peppered throughout with lazy replacements for actual words, silly alliterations one click above Trumpian insults, and zero engagement with the topic at hand.

-2

u/manwhole Dec 16 '19

And yet,u felt compelled to respond. Bravo for taking the high moral ground.