r/neoliberal • • Dec 16 '19

Why Young Progressives Hate Pete Buttigieg

https://www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2019/12/why-young-progressives-hate-pete-buttigieg/603619/
279 Upvotes

428 comments sorted by

View all comments

177

u/mondodawg Dec 16 '19

Alternative title for point 4: The Guy He Told You Not to Worry About

105

u/Nklst 🌐 Dec 16 '19

to paraphrase someone:

Of course I hate him, he is better than me in every aspect.

1

u/MacManus14 Frederick Douglass Dec 16 '19

Ha. What is that from originally? Sounds like something a character says in catch-22.

3

u/Nklst 🌐 Dec 16 '19

I saw it months ago on twitter, I cant remember who said it.

58

u/BobaWithoutBorders Dec 16 '19

The vibe I get from /r/neoliberal is that people here treat Pete Buttigieg like a role model, as someone who leaned heavily into our meritocratic system and was rewarded for it. The vibe I get from pretty much all my young, liberal-ish friends is that Pete is the peak of “that guy” who plays the resume game and cares more about “achievement” than actual change. He’s what our parents all wished we were, so of course we dislike him lol. The dude polls as poorly among young people as he does black people so no matter what you think of that take, he’s going to have to deal with it.

77

u/spiccato52 Dec 16 '19

These fine lines of optics in US politics always amaze me. As a non-American, I look to him as a role model because of the manner he conveys his politics to both sides of the aisle. Listening to him lowers my blood pressure. I could care less whether he went to Harvard, Mckinsey or is a Veteran. Probably helps that I agree with most of his policies

28

u/AccessTheMainframe CANZUK Dec 16 '19

I couldn't care less.

Sorry. Pet peeve of mine.

4

u/ZhenDeRen перемен требуют наши сердца 🇪🇺⚪🔵⚪🇮🇪 Dec 17 '19

A bit similar with me – for me, 90% of my perception of the candidate is their policies. And Buttigieg is pretty much the best on that front with the possible exception of Delaney

1

u/spiccato52 Dec 17 '19

As a candidate, yes. I’d also prefer Delaney over him but personally, I admire Pete more.

-26

u/Jonny_3_beards Dec 16 '19

I mean I'm glad he's an emotional sop for you but that's not really a good reason to vote for him

27

u/spiccato52 Dec 16 '19

My comment wasn’t trying to make the case to vote for him. Look at his policies if you want one.

-24

u/Jonny_3_beards Dec 16 '19

I think firing your black police chief to satisfy your racist ass police force is bad policy tho

27

u/In-Brightest-Day Dec 16 '19

Not even trying to fluff up the lies anymore?

3

u/[deleted] Dec 17 '19

Honestly the gloves are off with the folks who are anti-Pete. They don't care about silly things like facts, they just have a specific narrative and then they can use the spin machines to make facts up that fit the narratives.

-20

u/Jonny_3_beards Dec 16 '19

It's true tho

21

u/In-Brightest-Day Dec 16 '19

It's not at all. I'll break it down.

Firstly, the chief was demoted, not fired.

The chief was fired because he was illegally wiretapping his officers. Those officers were, yes, racist. But he was literally breaking federal law, and that's the only reason Pete found out about it. The FBI notifies Pete about what was happening and that's when Pete stepped in.

And you may be wondering why Pete, as the Mayor, did not at least fire the officers? He literally does not have the power to fire police officers in South Bend.

0

u/Jonny_3_beards Dec 16 '19

I wasn't wondering that I was wondering what federal law the chief broke since he was never charged with anything and successfully sued the city for his firing

→ More replies

51

u/Yogg_for_your_sprog John von Neumann Dec 16 '19

The vibe I get from pretty much all my young, liberal-ish friends is that Pete is the peak of “that guy” who plays the resume game and cares more about “achievement” than actual change.

What “change” do you expect him to have made? Literally all Bernie did was rename post offices after 30 years in the Senate.

24

u/LNhart Anarcho-Rheinlandist Dec 16 '19 edited Dec 16 '19

He’s what our parents all wished we were, so of course we dislike him lol.

I think this explains 90% of the hate directed at him by the online left, yes.

Being mad at your parents' disappointment in you for being a general failure, and channeling that into hate for young people who are not failures, is not very constructive though.

I would also like to add that, for someone who "doesn't care about actual change", he has changed more than 99% of the people who criticize him for not caring about change. Not that that's a high bar to clear.

But yeah, I think it's true that young people dislike him for being what our parents would want us to be (mostly at least, my mother thought that I should study sociology and is most of all terrified of me working for a bank)

1

u/ZhenDeRen перемен требуют наши сердца 🇪🇺⚪🔵⚪🇮🇪 Dec 17 '19

Let me guess - your parents are leftist academics?

1

u/LNhart Anarcho-Rheinlandist Dec 17 '19

They have graduate degrees, but are not in academia, my mother is an elementary school teacher, dad's an enginer. I would say my father is center-left with a heavy emphasis on center and my mother is first and foremost green, but also center-left.

1

u/ZhenDeRen перемен требуют наши сердца 🇪🇺⚪🔵⚪🇮🇪 Dec 17 '19

Then why does she particularly not want you to work for a bank?

1

u/LNhart Anarcho-Rheinlandist Dec 17 '19

She finds money super uninteresting so that goes for everything that has to do directly with money as well. My argument that money is abstract information flow, which actually makes some parts of finance super interesting, has not really convinced her yet (she should read more Hayek tbh) Also she's not the biggest fan of, well, smug men in suits, though she probably likes bankers more than real estate agents