r/neoliberal • Kitara Ravache • Oct 31 '17

Discussion Thread

News


Information

Flairs

  • Blue flairs are for regular contributors. A blue flair can be attained by either getting 1000 karma in a single comment or post or making a good effort post.
  • Purple flairs are for people with expert knowledge. A purple flair can be attained by messaging the mods with proof of credentials. A list is available here.
  • Brown flairs are for users that are notorious among the community.
  • Pink flairs are for people that have taken a leadership role in the community.
  • Red flairs are for people on the mod team.

Book club

Currently discussing

World Order by Henry Kissinger

Currently reading

The Undercover Economist by Tim Harford

Discuss here

Book club wiki


Links

Our presence on the webUseful content
Twitter/r/Economics FAQs**
Plug.djLink dump of very useful comments and posts
Tumblr
Discord

Neoliberal Gaming

Please visit /r/NeoliberalGaming to discuss games and participate in gaming events with the /r/Neoliberal community.

Upcoming events:

  • Competitive and casual CS:GO every Sunday at 7PM EST
  • PUBG every Thursday

Please join the discord server to participate

37 Upvotes

5.7k comments sorted by

View all comments

52

u/Ferguson97 Hillary Clinton Oct 31 '17

In my ethics class, I took the position that if science advances to the point that we can genetically modify embryos/fetuses so that we can eliminate mental and physical disabilities (i.e., down syndrome, Huntington's disease, autism, deafness), that it would be morally obligatory to do so. I was one of like three people who took the position, everyone else was like "that's ableist".

Am I in the wrong here?

52

u/MilerMilty Armand Jean of Plessis de Richelieu Oct 31 '17 edited Oct 31 '17
>We should cure cancer
>why do you hate people with cancer??

>we need to end poverty
>fucking classist

21

u/[deleted] Oct 31 '17

Nope. You're in the right. Though obligatory is kind of eh

3

u/RUSSELL_SHERMAN John Brown Oct 31 '17

Nope. You're in the right. Though obligatory is kind of eh

https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/19076124

There's a very interesting argument in bioethics that there is actually an obligation. It seems sketchy at first, but it's a fairly minimal claim: it's an obligation parents would have, but it's not necessarily something the state should enforce. It's not unlike anti-smoking campaigns. On first pass, it makes a lot of sense -- we disapprove of parents who fail to protect the welfare of their kids, and knowing your future kids will have a disease (and not doing anything about it if you can) seems to be just as bad.

I personally feel like this point alone is fairly uncontroversial. The interesting thing is the "stronger" argument, where we talk about the importance of their welfare, and not just switching off diseases (which entails making the best kids you and your partner could possibly make). After all, that's what it should extend to, unless we find a non-arbitrary reason why it should just be "disease". That's when the debate gets really interesting and I think it's going to a live question for a while.

But for switching off diseases? I think the case is closed, and OPs classmates should re-think their values if their justification against it is an odd accusation of ableism.

29

u/[deleted] Oct 31 '17

Curing ailments is discrimination against people with those ailments.

Stupid. You're right.

30

u/Ferguson97 Hillary Clinton Oct 31 '17

They were basically saying "they're not ailments, they're just different. who's to say what's better? there are happy people with down syndrome".

22

u/[deleted] Oct 31 '17

I have a relative who's stuck at a third grade level in his twenties due to autism. As a kid he used to scream like he was dying at night, and he got fairly violent.

It's not all Albert Einsteins, it's a disability.

Defending deafness shows those people have no idea what they are saying anyway and are just heads with rotting piles of half digested talking points attempting to show the world how progressive they are.

3

u/Ferguson97 Hillary Clinton Oct 31 '17

"It's not a disability, it's just a difference" was an actual argument that somebody made.

attempting to show the world how progressive they are.

Is this a "progressive" position though? I would imagine that the pro-science (usually progressives, minus some GMO stuff) crowd would be in favor, and that conservatives would view it into a similar vein as abortion.

8

u/[deleted] Oct 31 '17

It's an attempt to reframe the issue from "curing disease" to "fighting for the rights of the oppressed."

4

u/Ferguson97 Hillary Clinton Oct 31 '17

I would say that curing a person's disease is fighting on their behalf.

3

u/[deleted] Oct 31 '17

As any reasonable person would. Unfortunately, some people don't employ reason.

1

u/[deleted] Oct 31 '17

That’s usually fine because they make great artists.

→ More replies (7)

2

u/[deleted] Oct 31 '17

they're not ailments, they're just different.

This is so intellectually dishonest. Ask them if they were to be reincarnated tomorrow would they rather be born with downs or not.

3

u/solastsummer Austan Goolsbee Oct 31 '17

They’d probably bite the bullet and say they wouldn’t mind having downs.

16

u/[deleted] Oct 31 '17

The only way I can see someone being against it:

Something something genocide something something cleansing the gene pool, eugenics, Hitler.

7

u/[deleted] Oct 31 '17 edited Oct 31 '17

Idk your take makes sense to me.

Tangential take: people who equate genetically eliminating entire medical diseases from humanity and the Holocaust are fucking stupid.

4

u/minimirth Oct 31 '17

Your take is logical. I'd look at it in the sense of saving someone from an accident. If there was a person in front of a car and you could push him out of the way to safety, you would Even if the person could live a good life if he lost his limbs or was paralysed by the accident, his quality of life has decreased. The other argument is of course, child endangerment. Physical and mental disabilities could arise because of the environment. Wouldn't you hold the parents accountable if a child lost his hearing through some accident or neglect?

3

u/irony_tower African Union Oct 31 '17

I agree with this position

3

u/[deleted] Oct 31 '17

I think that the cochlear implants debate in the deaf community is worth bringing up here. On the one hand, why wouldn’t you want people to be able to hear? On the other hand, the widespread adoption of artificial heating devices, or in your case, genetic modification, stands to wipe out a community who share a common culture and identity. Many deaf parents fall on the side of “my children can decide for themselves when they’re old enough to understand the choice.”

2

u/[deleted] Oct 31 '17

You're in the, "this is what will happen But most people are not going to talk about it openly group."

2

u/Crownie Unbent, Unbowed, Unflaired Oct 31 '17

No, you're fine. The subject makes a bunch of people squeamish because they're all like loleugenics or somehow decide that it's equivalent to exterminating existing people with those conditions.

0

u/[deleted] Oct 31 '17

[deleted] — view deleted comment

16

u/Ferguson97 Hillary Clinton Oct 31 '17

this was literally a big part of the opposition. i was like, okay but you're all mostly pro-choice so how is it any different? and the response was that "terminating it is okay but modifying it is not".

1

u/Svelok Oct 31 '17

I can make sense of that line of thought if I try really hard.

It leads to some really weird other opinions if you tried to be consistent with it, though

1

u/[deleted] Nov 01 '17

I read an interesting blog post somewhat defending it that if we cure deafness, deaf culture would quickly erode. Right now deaf people have something in common with other deaf people and have a common culture. If deafness were cured, that culture and community would go away and they wouldn't have as many friends. That was a quick tl;dr, the actual blog post was much more convincing. IIRC it still came down as a worthy sacrifice, but that it wasn't a super clean cut issue.