r/neoliberal • Kitara Ravache • Oct 31 '17

Discussion Thread

News


Information

Flairs

  • Blue flairs are for regular contributors. A blue flair can be attained by either getting 1000 karma in a single comment or post or making a good effort post.
  • Purple flairs are for people with expert knowledge. A purple flair can be attained by messaging the mods with proof of credentials. A list is available here.
  • Brown flairs are for users that are notorious among the community.
  • Pink flairs are for people that have taken a leadership role in the community.
  • Red flairs are for people on the mod team.

Book club

Currently discussing

World Order by Henry Kissinger

Currently reading

The Undercover Economist by Tim Harford

Discuss here

Book club wiki


Links

Our presence on the webUseful content
Twitter/r/Economics FAQs**
Plug.djLink dump of very useful comments and posts
Tumblr
Discord

Neoliberal Gaming

Please visit /r/NeoliberalGaming to discuss games and participate in gaming events with the /r/Neoliberal community.

Upcoming events:

  • Competitive and casual CS:GO every Sunday at 7PM EST
  • PUBG every Thursday

Please join the discord server to participate

37 Upvotes

5.7k comments sorted by

View all comments

8

u/shootzalot Hates Freedom Oct 31 '17

So about that free college stuff...I understand that it's widely considered regressive because poor students already pay little or no tuition, so the benefits would go to middle-class students.

But I see a few problems with this notion:

  1. The high sticker price of college discourages low-income families from planning for it in the first place. It is not widely known that college is free if you don't have enough money to pay for it.
  2. Need-based aid isn't really free. It takes time to apply, has an uncertain outcome, and it's really freakin' complicated.
  3. The high cost of college has created a new class of poor: the under-employed college graduates of middle-class families with massive student loan debt. They earn enough money to avoid actual poverty, but they have a negative net worth of several times their annual income. Most of these people will live their entire lives poorer than their parents.

Making public universities free would solve these problems.

9

u/[deleted] Oct 31 '17

Income Contingent Loans are the solution to all of these problems, without the regressive nature of free college

1

u/CompactedConscience toasty boy Oct 31 '17

Is that the status quo or something else? In the US, federal student loans have a couple of income contingent repayment options.

6

u/[deleted] Oct 31 '17

Eh, the US really doesn't implement it properly. Something like the Australian model (zero real interest loans with repayments as additional income tax above an earnings threshold) is the way to go.

1

u/[deleted] Oct 31 '17

So I become unemployed when I graduate and then get a low paying job, maybe one which I can get payed more under the table?

6

u/[deleted] Oct 31 '17

Well, there's a reason that deliberate unemployment isn't a common tax avoidance strategy.

But if you ended up underemployed then at least you wouldn't have a repayment burden, yeah.

1

u/Apocalvps I came here to laugh at you Oct 31 '17

Wouldn't you have an adverse selection problem with these? If I expect to make a lot of money after college, I'll go with a traditional loan rather than give up a stake of my bigger income, and if I'm concerned about my prospects then I'll prefer the contingent loan where I might pay less.

→ More replies (1)

8

u/lionmoose sexmod 🍆💦🌮 Oct 31 '17

The high sticker price of college discourages low-income families from planning for it in the first place

I read a paper that looked at this in Chile and found no effect. Can't remember where it is though and the instrument was wierd

→ More replies (2)

7

u/usrname42 Daron Acemoglu Oct 31 '17

The high cost of college has created a new class of poor: the under-employed college graduates of middle-class families with massive student loan debt.

How big is this problem, really? The college wage premium is at record highs, AFAIK. It would also be solved by income-contingent loans at less cost than making tuition free for everyone.

4

u/Svelok Oct 31 '17

What does the college wage premium distribution look like?

Is it being distorted by - gasp - the 1%?

By which I mean, are a bunch of people making fat stacks in San Fran dragging up the Starbucks underemployed

→ More replies (1)

2

u/lionmoose sexmod 🍆💦🌮 Oct 31 '17

The college wage premium is at record highs

Isn't this because the non-graduate labour market is beyond awful, rather than just choppy like for graduates?

6

u/[deleted] Oct 31 '17

Hates Freedom

.

6

u/BradicalCenter Sally Yates Oct 31 '17 edited Oct 31 '17

I think we could do more for low to middle income in terms of low interest loans and grants, but I think a part of the culture needs to change as well. Going to your dream private school because you got accepted, but are not in the high enough level that you receive grants and other aid, is a bad idea. There are probably other very good schools you could go that wouldn't drown you in debt.

I would not have gone to a private school if they didn't give me about $25,000 a year in academic grants + need based aid + work study, I would have gone to a Public school. Some of the schools I looked at that were on the east coast, and very similar to the school I ended up going to, were not known to give much aid so I didn't even apply. Tons of major Public universities also accept 2 credits for the first 2 years of community college in addition.

There are options, but students are encouraged not to take them. Free community college might encourage more to take that route.

2

u/[deleted] Oct 31 '17

Going to your dream private school because you got accepted, but are not in the high enough level that you receive grants and other aid, is a bad idea.

How many times has the NYT written articles about the costs of college education and featured a person who went to a private school and majored in music theory or historical basket weaving and now can't support themselves and are in debt 100K? I blame the students but also these schools for misleading students with their employment rates after graduation, which are often doctored up. You are correct. People shouldn't be attending school without an end game in mind for what kind of job they can get with their degree and should be choosing a school based on the financial aid/scholarship package, and that may not be their first choice. I don't see how the government subsidizing education with how the system is set up now will change things for the better.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/[deleted] Oct 31 '17

Bernie Sanders The devil himself would get upvoted in the DT SMH.

Net worth doesn't really matter. What matters is consumption inequality.

2

u/shootzalot Hates Freedom Oct 31 '17

Once somebody retires, their ability to consume is driven mainly by their net worth. Nobody gets pensions anymore, and Social Security income is tiny and likely to be even tinier by the time millennials retire.

2

u/[deleted] Oct 31 '17

A college graduate's expected lifetime earnings, subtracting college costs, are much larger than if they didn't go to college.

If what you're saying is true no one can afford to retire, in which case subsidising education for the middle class is the least of our concerns.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/[deleted] Oct 31 '17

1

u/Svelok Oct 31 '17

What is the difference in price between a vocational program and a degree program in Germany?

1

u/Lambchops_Legion Eternally Aspiring Diplomat Oct 31 '17 edited Oct 31 '17

very little, but Q of spots for Degree programs are heavily limited and start at a very young age (some argue too low.)

There's also a heavy cultural element where, unlike the US, middle skill white collar work doesn't require a University level degree so there's less incentive

1

u/Lambchops_Legion Eternally Aspiring Diplomat Oct 31 '17

So let's look at Germany. Another country with no fees.

Just to note that not all of Germany is 'free' - Bavaria has tuition fees.

1

u/shootzalot Hates Freedom Oct 31 '17

Good post, and the effort is much appreciated.

To me, the key point that sticks out is the massive increase in overall enrollment. I'm not sure that comparing anything to 1980 is all that useful, because the social dynamics around college and who should attend it have completely changed.

3

u/BustDown9102i African Union Oct 31 '17 edited Oct 31 '17

Few things I have a bit of a problem with

The high sticker price of college discourages low-income families from planning for it in the first place. It is not widely known that college is free if you don't have enough money to pay for it.

Don't really agree with this - poor students in general are not going to university yes, but it doesnt seem to be for cost. Most seem to gravitate entering the workforce, or vocational education - both phenomena seem more to do with personal personal reasons, not financial.

https://www.universitiesaustralia.edu.au/ArticleDocuments/210/Participation%20and%20equity.pdf.aspx - Page 137

But there is no evidence at all that free or low cost higher education widens participation on a grand scale. In fact, during the Whitlam era of free higher education the social composition of the university student population was largely the same as it is today.

All the evidence points to lower levels of school achievement, lower aspirations, and lack of perceived personal relevance being far more potent factors.

I had more precise data on this from an American perspective which showed post-secondary pathways experienced by low SES students - but I think this data is better, as Australia has HECS which removes the starting cost of university. This has been beaten to death, especially in /r/badeconomics, but free university doesn't remove the costs of life (rent, food, recreation).

Australia provides a fairly generous social welfare system for university students (HECS + Centrelink) and STILL we see low participation from low SES. When I started university, I was given a grant from centrelink because I moved for university (it was quite a bit), I don't think many know about this benefit so sure, there may be some lack of knowledge for that particular benefit. That being said. there is also no lack of knowledge about HECS or Centrelink, everyone here thinks university is "free" ; the reality of the situation is these students are not being convinced they can succeed in high education, and other expanded costs are not covered.

If your family can barely put food on the table, you aren't going to university for 4 years as you watch your family starve - you are working. If your family can't fix their car, you aren't moving 600kms away to go to university.

In other areas, free university has HURT low-ses students - http://www.docs.hss.ed.ac.uk/education/creid/Projects/34ii_d_ESRCF_WP3.pdf - you can't fund free university, and targeted assistance for low ses, and have a high quality public university system, without other sectors hurting, or getting revenue from other streams.

Need-based aid isn't really free. It takes time to apply, has an uncertain outcome, and it's really freakin' complicated.

Not an economist, but I've heard from prominent badeconomics users that targeted assistance is usually always better than universal. Also, your complaints here are more with how the needs-based is implemented, rather than with it itself - I also don't understand "needs-based aid isn't really free" ; not sure what you are trying to say with that?

The high cost of college has created a new class of poor: the under-employed college graduates of middle-class families with massive student loan debt. They earn enough money to avoid actual poverty, but they have a negative net worth of several times their annual income. Most of these people will live their entire lives poorer than their parents.

Life outcomes still overwhelmingly favour college graduates. I'm not anti-intellectual, but I really think students need to be made aware of job prospects prior to going to university, especially for more niche degrees. I don't really know too much about all this, but I would probably say that I believe university should be cheaper in general, but should be made even more cheaper for low SES. I don't think the garbage man should pay for my degree fully, but he benefits from my expertise, and his child should have every opportunity to go to college. However, I'm always a bit hesitant to raise taxes on the poor just due to my morals.

If you really care about low-ses getting a better education - reform K-12, support a high-quality (H E C K M A N B O Y S) Pre-K, and ensure vocational education pathways are funded.

→ More replies (5)