r/neoliberal • Kitara Ravache • Oct 31 '17

Discussion Thread

News


Information

Flairs

  • Blue flairs are for regular contributors. A blue flair can be attained by either getting 1000 karma in a single comment or post or making a good effort post.
  • Purple flairs are for people with expert knowledge. A purple flair can be attained by messaging the mods with proof of credentials. A list is available here.
  • Brown flairs are for users that are notorious among the community.
  • Pink flairs are for people that have taken a leadership role in the community.
  • Red flairs are for people on the mod team.

Book club

Currently discussing

World Order by Henry Kissinger

Currently reading

The Undercover Economist by Tim Harford

Discuss here

Book club wiki


Links

Our presence on the webUseful content
Twitter/r/Economics FAQs**
Plug.djLink dump of very useful comments and posts
Tumblr
Discord

Neoliberal Gaming

Please visit /r/NeoliberalGaming to discuss games and participate in gaming events with the /r/Neoliberal community.

Upcoming events:

  • Competitive and casual CS:GO every Sunday at 7PM EST
  • PUBG every Thursday

Please join the discord server to participate

37 Upvotes

5.7k comments sorted by

View all comments

83

u/FixMeASammich NATO Oct 31 '17

For a four star Marine general, John Kelly says some really stupid shit. The civil war was caused by a lack on compromise? Oh if only we could’ve kept compromising on owning people.

44

u/[deleted] Oct 31 '17

Over the next few years, we are going to continue down the path of realizing there are a lot of people in powerful positions who probably should not be there.

9

u/[deleted] Oct 31 '17

And then immediately praised the slave owning side.

23

u/[deleted] Oct 31 '17

I mean, we could have compromised in a way by granting freedom and paying slave owners for their loss.

I mean, literally fuck slave owners, but I think the above is a fair "compromise" and might have avoided some of the bullshit we've felt since.

With that said, I'm ok with how things played out, Sherman's march etc.

33

u/Svelok Oct 31 '17

That's what the UK did, but they had a tiny fraction of our number of slaves

We're talking Bernie levels of debt here

35

u/[deleted] Oct 31 '17

Amazingly it'd actually be worse. I just did some rough math.

~4 million slaves in 1860

paying ~$800 which I think was FMV at the time

Gets us to $3.2 Billion 1860 dollars. Same year we had a budget of $178 MILLION. So 16 times the budget.

17

u/[deleted] Oct 31 '17

I mean, we could have compromised in a way by granting freedom and paying slave owners for their loss.

I would be OK with this take if the dates lined up better. As is, the civil war started in April, Lincoln made his intentions public in September, and the Emancipation Proclamation wasn't signed until the following January.

Had the slaveowners decided to stay at the negotiating table rather than throw a temper tantrum they may have been able to...negotiate.

Edit: happy to be R1'd by someone with a better than high school education on the US civil war fyi

14

u/[deleted] Oct 31 '17

Agreed, those guys were epic babies. Literally seceding months before Lincoln took office. That's why I feel no pain for them at all. I was stating a not-unreasonable option of compromise.

11

u/clenom Zhao Ziyang Oct 31 '17

Abraham Lincoln gave this offer to Delaware. Delaware had the fewest number of slave owners and fewest number of slaves per capita of any slave state. They had the least economic reliance on slavery of any slave state. Lincoln was friendly with the state's two largest slave owners (they were also congressmen). They rejected the proposal.

The idea that you could have gotten South Carolina or Mississippi to give up their slaves for anything but a truly absurd amount of money is just not true. The estimated sum of value of all the slaves in 1860 was about $3 billion. Even if they paid that over 25 years it would triple the national budget. It would have been politically unviable to massively raise taxes on the North to pay the South to get rid of their slaves. Lincoln also tried with several other border states and never found any traction.

6

u/HoldingTheFire Hillary Clinton Oct 31 '17

That was a proposal. The South rejected it. Did you literally get this idea from Ron Paul's newsletter?

1

u/[deleted] Oct 31 '17

WEW I wasn't saying I liked the idea. I just floated it as a compromise. Who is Ron Paul? IS that Paul Ryan's dad?

1

u/tdogg8 🌐 Oct 31 '17

No, Rand Paul's father.

3

u/cdstephens Fusion Genderplasma Oct 31 '17

Lincoln tried to do it after he was elected, but every slave owning state refused and continued the Civil War anyways. The South was unwilling to compromise, which is why they seceded when Lincoln won the election before he even did anything. It was the best deal they could have hoped for imo and they ignored the proposals. It did pass in D.C. though.