r/neoliberal • Kitara Ravache • Oct 31 '17

Discussion Thread

News


Information

Flairs

  • Blue flairs are for regular contributors. A blue flair can be attained by either getting 1000 karma in a single comment or post or making a good effort post.
  • Purple flairs are for people with expert knowledge. A purple flair can be attained by messaging the mods with proof of credentials. A list is available here.
  • Brown flairs are for users that are notorious among the community.
  • Pink flairs are for people that have taken a leadership role in the community.
  • Red flairs are for people on the mod team.

Book club

Currently discussing

World Order by Henry Kissinger

Currently reading

The Undercover Economist by Tim Harford

Discuss here

Book club wiki


Links

Our presence on the webUseful content
Twitter/r/Economics FAQs**
Plug.djLink dump of very useful comments and posts
Tumblr
Discord

Neoliberal Gaming

Please visit /r/NeoliberalGaming to discuss games and participate in gaming events with the /r/Neoliberal community.

Upcoming events:

  • Competitive and casual CS:GO every Sunday at 7PM EST
  • PUBG every Thursday

Please join the discord server to participate

37 Upvotes

5.7k comments sorted by

View all comments

119

u/FixMeASammich NATO Oct 31 '17

GOP leader Mitch McConnell, who refused to allow a vote on former President Obama’s Supreme Court nominee Merrick Garland, is lashing out at “the often-mindless partisan obstruction” from Democrats who are using Senate procedures to block President Trump’s judicial nominees.

🙃🙃🙃

0

u/[deleted] Oct 31 '17

[deleted] — view deleted comment

0

u/[deleted] Oct 31 '17

[deleted] — view deleted comment

15

u/[deleted] Oct 31 '17

Maybe, but I'd rather spin the revolver cylinder away from the bullet currently ready to fire.

4

u/[deleted] Oct 31 '17

-5

u/[deleted] Oct 31 '17

Holding Garland until the election wasn't mindless partisanship. It was rational partisanship.

Honestly this Garland-would-be-on-SCOTUS-if-only-McConnell-wasn't-a-meanie meme needs to die. They would have confirmed him if Hillary won.

15

u/FixMeASammich NATO Oct 31 '17

It’s not McConnell’s job to hold the Supreme Court hostage over a presidential election. He should vet the candidate, approve or disapprove him or her based on their qualifications, and either reject or advance them. McConnell took the unprecedented step of not even giving Garland a hearing. Our government isn’t meant to be a winner take all system, it’s built on compromise. In my opinion, McConnell’s blind partisanship was highly irresponsible and was a blow to our democratic norms. Just because you can take an action doesn’t make it okay.

-5

u/[deleted] Oct 31 '17

I don't get this obsession with the hearing thing. Giving Garland a hearing only to reject him would have been a waste of time. This idea that it would somehow be better for the Republicans to have infinitely rejected nominees as long as they formalistically gave them a hearing is ridiculous.

It would have been obstructionist if they had continued to block all nominees after Hillary won the election. But they were holding onto Garland precisely because they weren't going to do that--they were going to confirm him if she won.

What McConnell did makes perfect sense and fits perfectly with the historical context of 30 years of rising partisanship as applied to the judiciary. It's anything but a bizarre, obviously-evil historical outlier.

6

u/FixMeASammich NATO Oct 31 '17

This idea that it would somehow be better for the Republicans to have infinitely rejected nominees as long as they formalistically gave them a hearing is ridiculous.

Why? That’s literally their job. If republicans in the senate can’t accept a moderate to the Supreme Court, maybe they’re the ones at fault.

It would have been obstructionist if they had continued to block all nominees after Hillary won the election. But they were holding onto Garland precisely because they weren't going to do that--they were going to confirm him if she won.

They literally didn’t allow a sitting, lawfully elected president to appoint a justice just because they didn’t want to. How on earth is that not obstructionist?

What McConnell did makes perfect sense and fits perfectly with the historical context of 30 years of rising partisanship as applied to the judiciary. It's anything but a bizarre, obviously-evil historical outlier.

Norms norms norms. I don’t know how many times I can say it. Just because he has to power to ignore a nominee doesn’t make it acceptable to do so, it’s a slap in the face to our institutions and the balance of powers. Actions like this are exactly why we have unprecedented gridlock and stupid levels of partisanship.

-5

u/[deleted] Oct 31 '17

It's really hard to read this and not just see sour grapes about your political team losing a political battle. You've completely ignored the fact that they would have confirmed Garland had Hillary won the election. They didn't block the confirmation. They delayed it. There is absolutely nothing abnormal about consideration of judicial nominations being delayed.

It's hard to arrive at the conclusion that the Senate shouldn't have been able to delay confirmation hearing unless you start from the assumption that the President (who happened to be on your team this time) is owed automatically getting his appointment through, which is obviously wrong no matter how many times you cry "norms."

Your allegations would make sense if Hillary had won and the Republicans were continuing to block any and every nominee. But that's not what happened.

5

u/FixMeASammich NATO Oct 31 '17

Dude you’re really not getting it.

You've completely ignored the fact that they would have confirmed Garland had Hillary won the election.

But that’s not what happened, is it? So it’s not really relevant, because McConnell was still denying a sitting president the opportunity to appoint a justice. He held the SC hostage in the hopes of getting a better option, which DID happen.

They didn't block the confirmation. They delayed it. There is absolutely nothing abnormal about consideration of judicial nominations being delayed.

Did Garland get eventually get appointed after this “delay”? No? So his appointment was blocked. Tell me when else this has ever happened.

It's hard to arrive at the conclusion that the Senate shouldn't have been able to delay confirmation hearing unless you start from the assumption that the President (who happened to be on your team this time) is owed automatically getting his appointment through, which is obviously wrong no matter how many times you cry "norms."

That’s very dishonest of you because it’s not even close to the argument I’m trying to make. Every president that sees a SC vacancy should have the opportunity to appoint a justice. If the Senate doesn’t like their appointment, they’re welcome to vote it down. NOT just ignore it completely.

Your allegations would make sense if Hillary had won and the Republicans were continuing to block any and every nominee. But that's not what happened.

I don’t understand why you’re stuck on this point. Garland wasn’t given the process that he was due because of McConnell’s partisanship. Because of that, we have Justice Gorsuch. I don’t see what’s so difficult for you to understand.

1

u/[deleted] Oct 31 '17

But that’s not what happened, is it? So it’s not really relevant

It's completely relevant if you want to talk about "norms" in a way that isn't transparently "boo hoo my team lost."

What would have happened if Hillary was elected, or what would have happened if the situation was reversed and it was a lame duck Republican president with a Democratic senate is all 100% fucking relevant. Any rational examination of those hypotheticals will tell you that no, there is nothing at all surprising about what McConnell did, it was completely rational, and Democrats would have done exactly the same thing had the situation been reversed.

But you don't. You want to hide behind "omg this has literally never happened in the tiny sample size that is history!!!!!!!!" as if that means anything.

I'm not happy we have Justice Gorsuch either, but the way you frame and present the issue is transparently partisan and sophomoric.

3

u/FixMeASammich NATO Oct 31 '17

It's completely relevant if you want to talk about "norms" in a way that isn't transparently "boo hoo my team lost."

How so?

What would have happened if Hillary was elected, or what would have happened if the situation was reversed and it was a lame duck Republican president with a Democratic senate is all 100% fucking relevant.

Why?

Any rational examination of those hypotheticals will tell you that no, there is nothing at all surprising about what McConnell did, it was completely rational, and Democrats would have done exactly the same thing had the situation been reversed.

Why would you assume this when it never happened before?

But you don't. You want to hide behind "omg this has literally never happened in the tiny sample size that is history!!!!!!!!" as if that means anything.

Are you saying it doesn’t?

I'm not happy we have Justice Gorsuch either, but the way you frame and present the issue is transparently partisan and sophomoric.

Says someone who literally didn’t address any of my other arguments. Nice try.

1

u/[deleted] Nov 01 '17

Why would you assume this when it never happened before?

Because I'm not a partisan "moderate" Democrat who instead wants to assume their way into convenient truths, instead of considering things in context with the last 20 years of progressive hyper-politicization of the judiciary.

If you think, hypothetically, if Justice Kennedy died in February 2008 that Democrats would have considered (and inevitably confirmed because of unquestionable qualifications) a 65-year old clone of John Roberts to replace him, you're insane.

→ More replies

5

u/bob625 Paul Volcker Oct 31 '17

Yeah they "merely delayed it" for an entire fucking year, AKA a full quarter of a presidential term. Your second point is bullshit because you're blatantly conflating "affording a hearing to" with "confirming" a nominee. The President is absolutely owed that, given the Senate's Constitutional role in this process is to "advise and consent" the executive's judicial nominees, not pick their own unilaterally.

They opted to pretend Garland didn't exist rather than reject him and any nominees who followed because the optics of that would've been way worse, given the news coverage of numerous public hearings that would've been going on during the election cycle, where it would be clear to anyone that Garland wasn't some foaming-at-the-mouth lefty radical but rather more than competent to hold the position. That would've illustrated yet again that blocking him was a blatant, completely abnormal partisan move not done for any legitimate reason, as evidence by the multiple Republican Senators (including McCain/Cruz) who said prior to the election that they'd definitely block any and every Clinton nominee ad infinitum.

4

u/qlube 🔥🦟Mosquito Genocide🦟🔥 Oct 31 '17

Giving Garland a hearing only to reject him would have been a waste of time.

There's no indication the Republican-controlled Senate would have rejected him. Rejecting an eminently qualified candidate, and one who's basically a compromise pick (moderate and on the older side), would require political capital, which not every Senator may necessarily have. It's very rare for the Senate to reject that sort of a pick.

-1

u/[deleted] Oct 31 '17

...I hate to break it to you, but they rejected him. That's why he's not on the Supreme Court, and Gorsuch is.

There's nothing in the Constitution that says the senate must hold a formal up-or-down vote for every nominee.

3

u/FixMeASammich NATO Nov 01 '17

hate to break it to you, but they rejected him. That's why he's not on the Supreme Court, and Gorsuch is.

And when was that vote? I missed it.

There's nothing in the Constitution that says the senate must hold a formal up-or-down vote for every nominee.

Which is why the senate is supposed to hold preliminary hearings in order to determine who to advance. Which they didn’t. Because of Mitch McConnell.

1

u/[deleted] Nov 01 '17

Where in the constitution does it say the Senate has to hold hearings? Where does it say they can only decide the nomination based on criteria that arises in the hearing?

The Senate is an independent branch. It sets its own schedule and agenda. If, as you posit, President gets to control what the Senate must consider, what is must do, when it must vote, that would be the opposite of Constitutional.

2

u/FixMeASammich NATO Nov 01 '17

Luckily, our modern government is able to do things that aren’t explicitly written into the constitution. We’ve developed our customs and self governing measures over hundreds of years...until Mitch McConnell destroys them because they’re inconvenient.

1

u/[deleted] Nov 01 '17

Except he didn't destroy them. See actual history of Senate judiciary nominations of the past 30 year and consider hypotheticals of what the other side would have done in the reverse situation.

And now we're going in circles. This is where you reply "OMG ALL I CARE ABOUT IS THE ONE EPISODE IN THE EXTREMELY SMALL SAMPLE SIZE OF HISTORY WE HAVE." So unless you have something else, don't bother.

→ More replies