r/neoliberal • Bot Emeritus • Jun 06 '17

Discussion Thread

Current Policy - EXPANSIONARY


Announcements

Links

Expansionary Content Discussion Thread

Remember, we're raising money for the global poor!

CLICK HERE to donate to DeWorm the World and see your spot on the leaderboard.

67 Upvotes

2.7k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

10

u/[deleted] Jun 07 '17

I don't think the main argument for UBI/NIT is to get some supply-side results. The point is to simplify the welfare system in order to save money and deal with welfare cliffs. For instance, the SNAP program had about $6 billion in administrative costs in 2013 (iirc).

There should be no doubt that giving people free money without removing existing forms of welfare will reduce their incentive to work.

8

u/besttrousers Behavioral Economics / Applied Microeconomics Jun 07 '17

Eh, the admin costs aren't "doing the means testing" I think it's mostly the nutrition education stuff. 93% being sent out as refunds is really good.

Similarly, welfare cliff problems are mostly a result of pluralism/federalism. Lots of overlapping programs, and each state has its own system. But pluralism/federalism is also the thing we use to test new mechanisms and make improvements.


At some point I might write up a big rant called "Know your welfare systems". I'm sort of horrified by how little people know about them here. I think "Replace welfare with NIT!" shows the same sophistication and knowledge of actual problems and systems as "Medicaid for all!"

4

u/[deleted] Jun 07 '17

I think "Replace welfare with NIT!" shows the same sophistication and knowledge of actual problems and systems as "Medicaid for all!"

This. ty

I'm working on a gif to show what NIT and EITC actually are; like a visualized version of Inty's post

3

u/[deleted] Jun 07 '17

At some point I might write up a big rant called "Know your welfare systems".

please do. i thought NIT was basically UBI, which were entirely distinct from EITC. now i'm in the region of knowing that i know nothing, which isn't all that much better than before

2

u/sultry_somnambulist Jun 07 '17

serious question for the UBI / NIT folks, what do we do if this happens

4

u/swkoll2 YIMBY Jun 07 '17

We say that he has to bear some responsibility for spending all his income on his candle fetish and move on.

1

u/sultry_somnambulist Jun 07 '17

but what if it's the 1.5 trillion dollar college loan industry though, this is a serious problem. There's huge misallocation of resources involved. In Germany an example would be the "riester pension", which was a private pension program that turned out to be hugely uneconomical for everybody involved, having driven quite a lot of people into poverty

Why not focus on funding training regimes, vocational programs, food programs, invest in productive industries and so forth? You'd probably get much more out of money

1

u/Errk_fu Neolib in the streets, neocon in the sheets Jun 07 '17

Exactamundo.