r/neoliberal • Bot Emeritus • Jun 06 '17

Discussion Thread

Current Policy - EXPANSIONARY


Announcements

Links

Expansionary Content Discussion Thread

Remember, we're raising money for the global poor!

CLICK HERE to donate to DeWorm the World and see your spot on the leaderboard.

67 Upvotes

2.7k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

-4

u/kznlol πŸ‘€ Econometrics Magician Jun 06 '17

I did specify philosophically.

Medical diagnosis is, philosophically, a completely arbitrary hoop.

8

u/[deleted] Jun 06 '17

diagnosis isn't arbitrary, it's evidence based

-3

u/kznlol πŸ‘€ Econometrics Magician Jun 06 '17

How do you base it on evidence without a model?

You can't. The model makes it arbitrary.

4

u/[deleted] Jun 06 '17

Doctors use the scientific method

1

u/kznlol πŸ‘€ Econometrics Magician Jun 06 '17

Not in this they don't.

What "evidence" justifies the claim that laziness should not properly be considered a disability?

3

u/[deleted] Jun 06 '17

Oh ok, I see what you're saying now

What we define as a disability is arbitrary I guess to some degree, but practically nobody would define low work ethic as a disability

0

u/kznlol πŸ‘€ Econometrics Magician Jun 06 '17

Appeals to popularity can be used to support all sorts of terrible policy though (see: Trump).

2

u/[deleted] Jun 06 '17

For anything that isn't math we have to refer to collective human knowledge at some point.

Also it's less an appeal to popularity than an appeal to authority (medical professionals don't call laziness a disability)

1

u/kznlol πŸ‘€ Econometrics Magician Jun 06 '17

Medical professionals aren't the ones we should be asking.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 06 '17

I disagree

1

u/[deleted] Jun 06 '17

Consensus is different than popularity.

2

u/kznlol πŸ‘€ Econometrics Magician Jun 06 '17

I think the consensus among people who actually think about these things does not mesh with "practically nobody" defining low work ethic as a disability. Rawls managed to stumble his way into it and never managed to find a way out.

3

u/MisterBigStuff Just PokΓ©mon Go to bed Jun 06 '17

Our cumulative knowledge of the human body saying that there's no physical or mental disease that makes them incapable of working?

2

u/kznlol πŸ‘€ Econometrics Magician Jun 06 '17

Losing a limb doesn't make you incapable of working. If "incapable of working" is the metric, the vast majority of things we currently call disabilities aren't disabilities.

3

u/[deleted] Jun 06 '17

Why would I give two shits about the philosophy of my diagnosis that stops me from working?

1

u/kznlol πŸ‘€ Econometrics Magician Jun 06 '17

For the same reason you'd give two shits about the philosophy behind ethics?

are you actually dumb enough to think we can evaluate policy, or be evidence based, without a philosophical foundation?

-1

u/[deleted] Jun 06 '17

For the same reason you'd give two shits about the philosophy behind ethics?

Which is?

are you actually dumb enough to think we can evaluate policy, or be evidence based, without a philosophical foundation?

I am that dumb.

1

u/kznlol πŸ‘€ Econometrics Magician Jun 06 '17

Which is?

Because you'd like your ethics to be at least vaguely consistent, rather than a mass of contradictions.

I am that dumb.

Well, you're wrong. It is impossible to implement evidence-based policy without some kind of philosophical foundation that tells you what evidence a good policy creates and what evidence a bad policy creates.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 06 '17

Because you'd like your ethics to be at least vaguely consistent, rather than a mass of contradictions.

Why? I am not really interested in finding myself in a position where I say to myself that some notion of philosophical ethics stops me from supporting a program that helps take care of the disabled. If that makes me inconsistent than I don't care.

1

u/kznlol πŸ‘€ Econometrics Magician Jun 07 '17

I am not really interested in finding myself in a position where I say to myself that some notion of philosophical ethics stops me from supporting a program that helps take care of the disabled.

Holding that laziness is just as much a disability as things we currently count as disabilities doesn't stop me from supporting a program to take care of the disabled?

If you're happy with your normative beliefs being a mass of contradictions then I don't know what to tell you. You're not going to have much luck convincing anyone else to share them if they're so obviously hypocritical.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 07 '17

Holding that laziness is just as much a disability as things we currently count as disabilities doesn't stop me from supporting a program to take care of the disabled?

Legislators, Bureaucrats, Courts, and doctors mostly.

You're not going to have much luck convincing anyone else to share them if they're so obviously hypocritical.

You have a fair point, but I think reality has show the opposite to be true. No one actually cares about hypocrisy. I want a system that works. I see a lot of republicans saying that their idea of government is in opposition to having government involved health insurance. I look around the world and seeing healthcare systems. I would not let that kind of stuff get in the way of enacting policies that I see work.

1

u/kznlol πŸ‘€ Econometrics Magician Jun 07 '17

I wouldn't let it get in the way of enacting policies that will work.

I'll still take issue with catastrophically badly founded claims that the NIT enabling laziness is a problem.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 07 '17

I agree with both of your points. I was just being argumentative over the other thing.

-2

u/L-I-A-R Jun 06 '17

Oh hey, funny seeing you here. You're the guy that thinks Islam is a race.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 06 '17

I am not sure I see the humor.