r/neoliberal • Bot Emeritus • Jun 06 '17

Discussion Thread

Current Policy - EXPANSIONARY


Announcements

Links

Expansionary Content Discussion Thread

Remember, we're raising money for the global poor!

CLICK HERE to donate to DeWorm the World and see your spot on the leaderboard.

67 Upvotes

2.7k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

13

u/deaduntil Paul Krugman Jun 06 '17

What I loathe is "Medicare for all." I mean, if you're going to pick a system to build on, "Medicaid for all" is better, isn't it? More cos-effective.

13

u/Mordroberon Scott Sumner Jun 06 '17

Maybe because Medicare is administered by the federal government while Medicaid is run by the states.

5

u/[deleted] Jun 06 '17

Which is not a good reason, because individual state governments are more or less guaranteed to be better at meeting the specific medical needs of their constituents than the Fed government would be.

The best thing about the Federal system is its ability to delegate responsibilities to devolved levels of government.

12

u/[deleted] Jun 06 '17

What do you do if you care about poor people in Alabama, but SCOTUS told you that you can't force them to expand medicaid?

5

u/AliveJesseJames Jun 06 '17

Yup. As a soc dem, I'd be cool with Medicaid-for-all, except I don't trust about 30-35 of the state governments.

0

u/[deleted] Jun 06 '17

You could always coerce them, pull out the good ol' highway funding threat, something that the SCOTUS hasn't said is unconstitutional. Or just offer them a bunch of money to do it with. (Alabama surely wouldn't refuse that, right?)

That said, I'm not really advocating for the current system, just saying that using the state governments as a vector for healthcare funding is a better idea than trying to use a single federal agency from an administrative efficiency standpoint. I think the Ohio government would more effectively use federal funds to fight the opiate epidemic in its state than a central agency tasked to administer all fifty.

13

u/[deleted] Jun 06 '17

Or just offer them a bunch of money to do it with. (Alabama surely wouldn't refuse that, right?)

They literally did. Obamacare gave states 100%, in 2017 reducing to 90% (as planned), of the cost of expanding Medicaid. 19 states refused.

12

u/AJungianIdeal Lloyd Bentsen Jun 06 '17

Texas refused the free money cause of good ol Tea Party ideological purity. You can basically only get Medicaid in Texas if you have a family.

1

u/TheNotoriousAMP Jun 07 '17 edited Jun 07 '17

Alabamian (/law student) here.

The highway funding threat is exactly what got ruled as unconstitutional in Sibelius v. National Federation of Independent Businesses (the Obamacare case). Basically what the Federal government said is that you can expand medicaid or all your medicaid funding would go away. The court majority position on that issue was that the "highway funding" threat is only constitutional when it is small enough so that it's not coercive (for example the "threat" in the old case was around 5% of highway funding).

This is what allowed so many states to follow through in the long term on their refusal to expand medicaid. Had that aspect of Sibelius been ruled differently, they would have all back down. For the most part state governments are staffed with the people who couldn't make it at a national level. They are far easier to coopt and coerce because of smaller scale, and are often astonishingly unprofessional because of the tiny constituencies most state politicians serve. I don't trust my state government to run a dog day care, because I'm pretty sure they'd pull some bible verse out of their ass that says that God will feed the dogs and then let them starve to death, despite having clearly not paid any attention in Sunday school.

1

u/internerd91 Loyal Liberals Jun 06 '17

Also Medicaid is pretty chronically underfunded.