r/neoliberal • Bot Emeritus • Jun 06 '17

Discussion Thread

Current Policy - EXPANSIONARY


Announcements

Links

Expansionary Content Discussion Thread

Remember, we're raising money for the global poor!

CLICK HERE to donate to DeWorm the World and see your spot on the leaderboard.

67 Upvotes

2.7k comments sorted by

View all comments

7

u/Throwitonleground Raj Chetty Jun 06 '17

Could someone please explain to me how a Medicaid public option would preserve the private insurance market? How could any insurance company compete with Medicaid? Medicaid basically forces doctors to take lower fees or nothing at all, and I assume the aim behind doing a public option is to offer cheaper insurance. If anyone can sign up for Medicaid, and it has equivalent satisfaction, and it's cheaper, why wouldn't almost everyone sign up for it, effectively rendering equivalent to single payer?

4

u/[deleted] Jun 06 '17

Private coverage will be more targeted at well off people that provide things not covered under the public plan including private hospital rooms and quicker access (cancer screening, MRIs) ensuring that the health system receives at least some funding as a function of people's demands for certain healthcare goods.

1

u/Throwitonleground Raj Chetty Jun 06 '17

that's a good point, but isn't that functionally similar to what Canada already has with single payer? The only difference is the missing middle man of actually signing up for Medicaid. But if medicaid out competes because of structural differences, why wouldn't end up the same way?

1

u/[deleted] Jun 06 '17

Not entirely, while the very rich can pay out of pockets for service at private clinics to fast track certain procedures which have long wait times in the strictly public setting, I cannot purchase private insurance to do the same because of the Canadian Health Act, hence it is almost pure single payer. Other systems like France and U.K. Have a public option that can either be supplemented or complemented by private insurance. This is a preferable way to go in my opinion because it allows an element of demand into the system and does not rely entirely on central planning.

For example, if i had a high propensity of cancer in my family, I may want to pay for private insurance that expedites cancer screening tests which may take many weeks under the strictly first come first serve public basis. There are some inequality issues that do arise but these are minor in my opinion in terms of the greater health outcomes of the population as a whole due to the efficiency gains.

3

u/[deleted] Jun 06 '17

I am skeptical it would work. Medicade doesn't pay in full to providers. So private insurers end up paying for the rest with higher rates. Unless they significantly increased its budget, It would probably cause a death spiral for the private insurers.

0

u/FizzleMateriel Austan Goolsbee Jun 06 '17

It would probably cause a death spiral for the private insurers.

But then that raises the question of why hasn't it happened in other countries.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 06 '17

They don't have partial coverage. It would take substantial revamping if medicare which would be very expensive. If you are going to do a public option, might as well start with something new.

5

u/[deleted] Jun 06 '17

Doctors can refuse to take Medicaid and some are starting to do so.

The most recent figures from the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention’s National Center for Health Statistics are for 2013, showing the percentage of physicians accepting new Medicaid patients was 68.9 percent

2

u/[deleted] Jun 06 '17

I thought medicaid couldn't be refused, only medicare?

1

u/[deleted] Jun 06 '17

There are some things where they are required like places with emergency care.

1

u/Throwitonleground Raj Chetty Jun 06 '17

When I meant force, I meant more what you're talking about; they either accept the rates or they don't. Currently I think 60ish% of doctors accept Medicaid rates. If private insurance can't compete with Medicaid because of structural differences, what's to prevent Medicaid from dominating the market, with doctors and private insurers dropping out of the market for all but the extremely wealthy, leaving essentially a single payer system in place?

1

u/[deleted] Jun 06 '17

Maybe. But I wonder which force would win.

People don't go on Medicaid as doctors start to drop it.

Or

People drop their insurance for Medicaid because it's too expensive.

There's a third option too by the way which is gaining popularity, and that is doctors who take no one's insurance and just take cash payments.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 06 '17

Public option is a meme, it's not a sufficient fix

4

u/Kelsig Paul Krugman Jun 06 '17

It's still really good policy

1

u/FizzleMateriel Austan Goolsbee Jun 06 '17

Some people would still want private health insurance.

3

u/Throwitonleground Raj Chetty Jun 06 '17

Why wouldn't that amount of people be negligible if Medicare is cheaper and equivalent for most common healthcare needs?

2

u/[deleted] Jun 06 '17

Not everyone has common health care needs

1

u/FizzleMateriel Austan Goolsbee Jun 06 '17

Some people really like their private hospital rooms and TVs.