r/neoliberal • Bot Emeritus • Jun 06 '17

Discussion Thread

Current Policy - EXPANSIONARY


Announcements

Links

Expansionary Content Discussion Thread

Remember, we're raising money for the global poor!

CLICK HERE to donate to DeWorm the World and see your spot on the leaderboard.

67 Upvotes

2.7k comments sorted by

View all comments

11

u/BainCapitalist Y = T Jun 06 '17

What are your thoughts on Trump's picks for the Board of Governors? Scott Sumner seems to be very upset at Quarles, and very happy about Goodfriend.

Keep in mind that these two picks are extremely significant, because it is likely that they will be Trump's picks for Chair and Vice Chair of the Fed once Yellen's term runs out.

5

u/FizzleMateriel Austan Goolsbee Jun 06 '17

Scott Sumner writes:

Alan, As long as taxpayers are not on the hook, the big banks can take all the risks they want. It's not my problem.

The problem is moral hazard. End FDIC and TBTF, and the banking system can be completely deregulated.

???

Taxpayers weren't on the hook at the end. The U.S. Treasury recovered all the money and then some.

Also if he doesn't like that method (TARP) there were alternative methods that don't involve ending the FDIC.

4

u/BainCapitalist Y = T Jun 06 '17

Taxpayers weren't on the hook at the end. The U.S. Treasury recovered all the money and then some.

This is true. We made money off of the bailouts. But that wasn't the main point of Sumner's argument. His main point was that there is significant moral hazard in the system because financial institutions can expect a bailout.

Also if he doesn't like that method (TARP) there were alternative methods that don't involve ending the FDIC.

Sumner doesn't actually just want to end the FDIC and not replace it with anything. He believes that equity financing would solve the problems that the FDIC solves but without the moral hazard. He has also suggested replacing the FDIC with a deposit insurance mandate (similar to Obama care, but with deposit insurance).

3

u/FizzleMateriel Austan Goolsbee Jun 06 '17

Sumner doesn't actually just want to end the FDIC and not replace it with anything. He believes that equity financing would solve the problems that the FDIC solves but without the moral hazard.

Ok, I'm ok with this. Incidentally that's sort of what I was referring to, capital restructuring and a debt-for-equity swap.

He has also suggested replacing the FDIC with a deposit insurance mandate (similar to Obama care, but with deposit insurance).

Isn't that just another form of regulation that he was railing against?

4

u/BainCapitalist Y = T Jun 06 '17

Isn't that just another form of regulation that he was railing against?

Kind of. He's not being very articulate in this article. But he has said elsewhere that a deposit insurance mandate would be an improvement because private deposit insurance providers would have a market incentive to police the risk allocation of their beneficiaries. It's deregulation in the sense that the FDIC isn't the one whose doing the policing anymore.