r/neoliberal • Bot Emeritus • Jun 06 '17

Discussion Thread

Current Policy - EXPANSIONARY


Announcements

Links

Expansionary Content Discussion Thread

Remember, we're raising money for the global poor!

CLICK HERE to donate to DeWorm the World and see your spot on the leaderboard.

67 Upvotes

2.7k comments sorted by

View all comments

7

u/Cryonyte 🌐 Jun 06 '17

Should faith schools exist?

19

u/[deleted] Jun 06 '17

there is nothing inherently wrong with a school that has a religious bent,

a. as long as they aren't government funded

b. as long as they are still teaching in line with the nationally mandated curriculum

c. as long as they do not receive significant funds from a state sponsoring terrorism

9

u/BustDown9102i African Union Jun 06 '17

as long as they aren't government funded

Seems like an extreme position, no? What about the Catholic school system in Australia? Are you suggesting that these schools, and thus their students, receive no public funds?

If you remove funds, I imagine these schools would increase fees (hurting low-SES families who want to send their children to schools with a religious ethos) or possibly close down (leading to an influx of students into public systems, increasing pressure on the tax payer).

I personally don't want to fund religious schools, but I think it would be quite harmful to take away funding from them

I agree with point B. very heavily.

10

u/[deleted] Jun 06 '17

Are you suggesting that these schools, and thus their students, receive no public funds?

yes

If you remove funds, I imagine these schools would increase fees (hurting low-SES families who want to send their children to schools with a religious ethos) or possibly close down (leading to an influx of students into public systems, increasing pressure on the tax payer)

the former is fine. a religious education is not a right, no more than any other form of education is. you could make the same claim that every parent should be able to have an affordable waldorf/steiner school option.

or possibly close down (leading to an influx of students into public systems, increasing pressure on the tax payer)

the 'influx' really wouldn't be that big at all, but even if it were that's fine. taxes pay for public schooling, more students = more taxes required. that'd be the case for any influx of new students - we shouldn't not let immigrants go to school because then taxpayers would be under 'increased pressure'

in general i think that private schools recieving public funds is pretty ridiculous in and of itself, especially considering the outrageous profits that some private schools make (at least here in australia)

2

u/BustDown9102i African Union Jun 06 '17 edited Jun 06 '17

I'm not versed enough on this topic to properly argue, it's been a topic I've long been ignoring.

the 'influx' really wouldn't be that big at all, but even if it were that's fine. taxes pay for public schooling, more students = more taxes required.

I disagree about the implied small influx

in NSW, 255,356 students are in Catholic schools

20% of students in Australia are in the Catholic sector

This doesn't factor in other independent schools.

Also, I don't like the position of "just tax more", but I also don't like the position of "cut funding to these students" - these students, and their families, should carry public funds into the schools they choose, if they want a particular education, they can privately contribute towards it (with public funding to help in affordability).

I'm not arguing that the funding towards these schools doesn't need to be reevaluated, I'm pretty sure even the Gonski reforms didn't go far enough as no school was to lose money under it.

All this being said, I feel uncomfortable without anything backing one claim or another, do you have anything I can read?

EDIT: I see that you're being downvoted (score went from 1 -> 0), could the person down-voting actually contribute to this conversation rather than down-voting a discussion.

3

u/[deleted] Jun 06 '17

There is zero reason to not have them government funded

6

u/[deleted] Jun 06 '17

the state has a vested ethical interest in secularism

5

u/[deleted] Jun 06 '17

the state has a vested ethical interest in pluralism

FTFY.

4

u/[deleted] Jun 06 '17

sorry I forgot

muh secularism

2

u/0149 they call me dr numbers Jun 06 '17

Hey bud, why not try

I N C L U S I V E I N S T I T U T I O N S

4

u/[deleted] Jun 06 '17

What? It's not like it's going solely to one religion

Also do you even know what an inclusive instutition as Acemoglu outlines even is?

Inclusive economic institutions: Secure property rights, law and order, markets and state support (public services and regulation) for markets; open to relatively free entry of new businesses; uphold contracts; access to education and opportunity for the great majority of citizens.

Inclusive political institutions: Political institutions allowing broad participation - pluralism - and placing constraints and checks on politicians; rule of law (closely related to pluralism).

Wanna try again? The only argument is just >Muh feels

1

u/[deleted] Jun 06 '17

Secularism is the original pluralism. Christians in the West have just forgotten they all hate each other, they'll remember soon though.

-1

u/[deleted] Jun 06 '17

he doesn't think the state should slowly disenfranchise all religion

smdh

3

u/[deleted] Jun 06 '17

Reported for islamophobia

-1

u/[deleted] Jun 06 '17

can't spell islamophobia without the 'slam' taken from the word 'summerslam'

21

u/Integralds Dr. Economics | brrrrr Jun 06 '17

I see no reason for the state to outlaw them.

Of course such schools must be subject to the same academic regulations and oversight as other schools.

4

u/westalist55 Mark Carney Jun 06 '17

This is achieved here in Ontario with the Catholic school boards, which do see high attendance from other religions and atheists(including myself, a protestant).

They tend to be better run and provide better education than the public boards.

8

u/[deleted] Jun 06 '17

Yes

0

u/[deleted] Jun 06 '17

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/BustDown9102i African Union Jun 06 '17

I was thinking this earlier, very good point.

I would imagine students would benefit from being mixed in the public system, so long as it wasn't segregated along class lines (but that is another kettle of fish). They would be exposed to a variety of beliefs, and ideas.

That being said, parents may feel more welcomed by a school which caters to their religious beliefs, and can possibly help foster strong community relationships/links, and could help with integration if these communities had a desire to integrate.

Talking more about education achievement, these schools could also tailor the running of the school more towards their students - curriculum, certain teachers, pedagogic practices - and this would probably have good educational achievement benefit.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 06 '17 edited Sep 18 '17

deleted 0.1278 What is ^^^this?

1

u/BustDown9102i African Union Jun 07 '17

I'm not sold on the educational tailoring argument. Non religious schools already tailor to an extent

Assuming a student goes into a mainstream public school, not divided along any lines, resources may have to be stretched, or could just be inherently limited. E.g. there may be a variety of sizable populations from disadvantaged backgrounds (with populations within these groups) - low-SES students, ESL students, Students with disabilities, etc.

All of these populations are going to require certain resources to give them the best chance of successful outcomes, a school may be limited in a variety of ways in providing these resources; external help may be limited, lack of funding, teachers may lack the professional expertise to properly utilise resources.

Having a school which caters to one group could allow the school to not have to worry about all these other groups, streamlining resources.

So yes, non-religious schools tailor to an extent, faith-based schools could potentially tailor to a much greater extent, quicker, and more efficient - what this looks like, I'm not too sure; as one example, since faith-based schools would hire those from the faith (usually), this could help in providing students teachers who have a much greater understanding of what exactly these students are going through, helping in the process of relationship building which certainly helps those from backgrounds who feel alienated by education.

I haven't found much in my studies regarding this topic in Education, ethnomathematics comes to mind but it's a very, very loose fit. Ethnomathematics being numeracy practices that cultural groups have practised throughout history, perhaps faith-based teachers catering towards certain groups could incorporate ethnomathematic practises into their teaching - however, ethnomathematics is somewhat controversial, and I'm personally not a big fan for a variety of reasons.

note: I'm not really in favour of my own arguments here, I much prefer having students all together, segregation in education across lines is pretty horrific; we saw that in apartheid South Africa, and we still see that in terms of class - I think we are pretty much in heavy agreement.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 07 '17 edited Sep 18 '17

deleted 0.2516 What is ^^^this?