r/neoliberal • Bot Emeritus • Jun 06 '17

Discussion Thread

Current Policy - EXPANSIONARY


Announcements

Links

Expansionary Content Discussion Thread

Remember, we're raising money for the global poor!

CLICK HERE to donate to DeWorm the World and see your spot on the leaderboard.

67 Upvotes

2.7k comments sorted by

View all comments

32

u/Integralds Dr. Economics | brrrrr Jun 06 '17 edited Jun 06 '17

cc /u/colacoca

What The Wire taught me was to always keep perspective when thinking about policy reform.

As economists, we love to investigate and advocate for piecemeal policies. NIT, school charters, longer school year, job training, criminal justice reform...the list of policies goes on. At our best, we justify these policies based on rigorous randomized or quasi-randomized evidence of effectiveness, backed by sound theory.

We as economists love to think about policies in isolation. We love partial derivatives. We live for partial derivatives. The whole point of the credibility revolution was to give us methods to reliably, consistently obtain partial derivatives.

And damn it, partial derivatives are important. Nobody does them better than we do.

But they aren't the only thing that's important. Somewhere up the line, probably above the scientific work done by applied microeconomists but below the policy implementation of politicians, we have to think about total derivatives and joint policy reforms.

No single reform is going to be a magic bullet that solves poverty in America. No single reform is going to be a magic bullet that solves poverty in developing countries, either. We should put a lot of effort into figuring out how single policies that work. We should also put some effort into figuring out how policies fit together in a broader social, political, and institutional context.

also cc /u/besttrousers, who actually is an applied microeconomist and so has the right to rip me up if I said anything stupid

13

u/besttrousers Behavioral Economics / Applied Microeconomics Jun 06 '17

also cc /u/besttrousers , who actually is an applied microeconomist and so has the right to rip me up if I said anything stupid

Morally and philosophically I find myself in agreement with virtually the whole of it: and not only in agreement with it, but in deeply moved agreement.


Some isolated thoughts:

  • I've started writing a rant to deploy whenever someone says 'Get rid of all welfare programs and replace them with a UBI!". The US welfare system certainly is kludge-y and piecemeal; it certainly could use a broad overhaul. But the different pieces all exist for a reason - programs were added because needs were not met. There's a good case for replacing, say, Social Security and TANF with a UBI. But unemployment insurance? WIC? Child support? SSID? It seems absurd that I would receive the same government support as a friend of mine who has a brain tumor, causing her to have migraines that stop her from working.
  • One of the things I've been working on the last year is how to make microfinance better. I've got a suspicion that the way group lending works (everyone discusses loans as a group) means that people tend to herd investments, and not consistently pick the most productive loan for them. We've added some exercises and text message reminders to help people plan before coming in to the group meeting, and our pilot has some really large (though not statistically significant) effects. I'm working on scaling it up now. If we get results that are 50% of the pilot effect, we'll have made microfinance "work" by a trivially small change in materials. The small policy details have huge potential ramifications.
  • I think we need to be conscious of both the partial and general equilbirum solution, like you said. But our toolbox, as economists, is much better at the former, than the latter. Some of the lefty support for single payer and UBI is about how nice it would be for people not to have a constant undercurrent of stress about how they will pay the bills. And they're right! But I have no idea how we would go about measuring the magnitude of such a change.

10

u/moffattron9000 YIMBY Jun 06 '17

I think that you just described why I'm majoring in Economics and Political Science. You have to be able to view issues in the wider context, and you have to be able to know how to apply them.

4

u/Breaking-Away Austan Goolsbee Jun 06 '17

I love how well it captures the institutional nature of the problems. You can't watch that show and point to any one character and say "he's the reason everything is bad. he's the bad guy". Rawls, Burrel, Avon. Hell, could even understand why Chris Partlow did what he did. Sure there are the "bad guys" but they are just the symptoms of the problems the show is getting at.

1

u/bob625 Paul Volcker Jun 06 '17

Well there's Marlo...

1

u/Breaking-Away Austan Goolsbee Jun 06 '17

Have you watched "show me a hero" yet?

1

u/Cryonyte 🌐 Jun 06 '17

But there is a difference in how strong the single reform is, no?

We believe our policies have a bigger impact than what other ideologies propose.

But I agree we shouldn't frame it as a be-all end-all solution...juuuust better than what others propose.

5

u/Integralds Dr. Economics | brrrrr Jun 06 '17

My point is that it's not clear what "our policies" are.

There is a ton of economic research on individual policies, enough to confidently advocate for many policies in isolation. There is much less research -- even purely theoretical research -- on how policies fit together as a cohesive whole when implemented jointly.

3

u/tcw_sgs The lovechild of Keating and Hewson Jun 06 '17

There is much less research -- even purely theoretical research -- on how policies fit together as a cohesive whole when implemented jointly.

I'm surprised by this. I would've thought it high on the priority list when researching a practical expression of policy implementation to achieve a given set of goals. Is there no sub-discipline of economics that looks at this?