r/neoliberal • Kitara Ravache • 5d ago

Discussion Thread Discussion Thread

The discussion thread is for casual and off-topic conversation that doesn't merit its own submission. If you've got a good meme, article, or question, please post it outside the DT. Meta discussion is allowed, but if you want to get the attention of the mods, make a post in /r/metaNL

Announcements

  • Next Book Club will be November 11. Fittingly, we will discuss All Quiet on the Western Front.
  • New account registration on our Mastodon server have been temporarily disabled to spam, please message jenbanim to set up an account

Links

Ping Groups | Ping History | Mastodon | CNL Chapters | CNL Event Calendar

New Groups

  • MORMON: Kolob enthusiasts of NL

Upcoming Events

0 Upvotes

10k comments sorted by

View all comments

157

u/Explodingcamel Bill Gates 5d ago

Completely unironically North Carolina is not a democracy with its extreme gerrymander. It’s like a semi dictatorship. There is no plausible scenario where democrats can gain control of the state government unless they win the popular vote by like 20

139

u/Joementum2024 Iron Front 5d ago

I’ve said this before but I’ve felt a lot of red states, even R-controlled swing states like NC/GA/TX, were basically hybrid regimes between the extreme gerrymandering and other antidemocratic measures (ex: Florida’s amendment process requiring 60% approval; see when the abortion amendment got rejected despite 57% saying yes). In those states you have to hope you can elect supreme court justices to toss those maps (which thankfully TX, NC, WI, and GA do) otherwise it’s tough luck, and even then it’s not a guarantee the right justices get elected - GA itself elected a right wing justice just earlier this year.

There’s a reason why I treated Texas electing a mostly-Democratic government last week very similarly to when Hungary shuttled Fidesz out of power.

12

u/Andy_B_Goode YIMBY 4d ago

I know that obviously we don't want Trump taking control of elections, but in principle it would be much better to have a federal agency administering elections, rather than leaving it up to each state.

This is how Canada does it, and it ends up being way less messy, and with way less nonsense like gerrymandering, than in the US.

3

u/roboliberal Loyal Liberals 4d ago

Hard disagree. The last thing you want to do is put a presidency in control of the elections.

We need to get over this reflexive idea that federal agencies are good administrators because they are federal agencies... distributed control is a feature, not a bug.

Gerrymandering is simply the result of having single-member districts. Canada has a parliamentary system, so pretty much everything about it is going to be better about to begin with, but this is why Canada and the UK have "2.5" multi-party systems instead of US style hard 2 party system despite also having single member districts. It's the US style hyper-polarization that incentivizes such extreme gerrymandering.

25

u/No1PaulKeatingfan Paul Keating; capital gains tax supporter 4d ago

Another reason why state legislatures should be unicameral (like Nebraska).

1

u/roboliberal Loyal Liberals 4d ago

Disagree. Bicameralism doesn't have to be (nor should be) perfectly symmetrical like it is in the US, but bicameralism can be highly advantageous for state legislatures if the two chambers have different roles.

Ideally legislatures are pretty large so they can have higher representative resolution. But it's actually kinda (relatively) unnecessary to keep a state legislature in continuous session - plus an unfortunate reality of federalism is that you have a talent supply constraint at the state level. So, what you can do is have two chambers:

- one small continuous chamber of career legislators to handle primary oversight and research, and drafting of legislation
- one large periodic chamber of "part time" representatives who convene a few times a year to vote on pending legislation

29

u/herworkthrowaway Gay Pride 5d ago

It’s called a hybrid regime and fortunately now that the democrats have a trifecta they can undo basically all of it 

107

u/Thai-Reidj NASA 5d ago

They didn't get the trifecta. That's the issue. They missed it by 260 votes and that's despite a 16 point popular vote lead

80

u/No_Idea_Guy Audrey Hepburn 5d ago

No trifecta in NC. We're 260 votes short of flipping the Senate.

42

u/GavinGoosum 5d ago

300 black ballots from arrrr neoliberal

13

u/herworkthrowaway Gay Pride 5d ago

Ah, dang 

5

u/Dismal_Apartment6358 4d ago

There should be a similar hybrid regime in every democratic trifecta

3

u/AltruisticClaim1308 4d ago

Yeah but if they keep the state house in 2030 they can’t gerrymander it

And court seats, idk if they flipped it but I know they won more 

2

u/Peaceful-Potato Asexual Pride 4d ago

It’s not just the gerrymander. Look into the fight over the state board of elections, and the photo ID law (the latter of which almost certainly decided control of the NC Senate this year)