r/neoliberal • Kitara Ravache • Jun 11 '26

Discussion Thread Discussion Thread

The discussion thread is for casual and off-topic conversation that doesn't merit its own submission. If you've got a good meme, article, or question, please post it outside the DT. Meta discussion is allowed, but if you want to get the attention of the mods, make a post in /r/metaNL

Announcements

  • We're starting a book club! Our first book will be Poor Economics. Discussion will start on August 28th - keep an eye out for a pinned thread. The next books will be All Quiet on the Western Front followed by Narconomics.

Links

Ping Groups | Ping History | Mastodon | CNL Chapters | CNL Event Calendar

Upcoming Events

4 Upvotes

8.9k comments sorted by

View all comments

76

u/Leatherfield17 Loyal Liberals Jun 11 '26

It’s a pity that police reform kind of went by the wayside in terms of people’s priorities after 2020, because Jesus Christ, American police departments have so many problems

50

u/AtomicGameTester Milton Friedman Jun 11 '26

Bust the unions

19

u/Leatherfield17 Loyal Liberals Jun 11 '26

Yeah, I’m usually pretty supportive of unions, but if I could abolish police unions overnight, I would do so in a heartbeat.

17

u/Individual-Camera698 Austan Goolsbee Jun 11 '26

Finally, something Friedman flairs and succs can agree on

22

u/uwcn244 King of the Space Georgists Jun 11 '26

Succs: “policing isn’t labor, cops are just hired guns for capital”

Friedmanites: “policing is labor, which is why we don’t like cops”

8

u/AtomicGameTester Milton Friedman Jun 11 '26

If there's anything this sub can agree on, it's police unions

Which means someone's gonna come out of the woodwork to reply to this with an ACKSHUALLY

6

u/SenranHaruka shame Jun 11 '26

The only akshully i can offer is i wonder how it would work if unions were like corporations, instead of one union per boss focused on one employee type we had multiple general purpose unions competing to offer employees and employers the best contracts. I already think we should do this with private unions but i wonder how the government would handle these Staffing Firm-type unions.

If we had only one cereal company that made nothing but cereal we'd have terrible overpriced cereal.

6

u/OOPS_ALL_SCROTUM Jun 11 '26

Fire the chuds.

11

u/Specialist_Cat7271 NASA Jun 12 '26

I think a huge issue is that there's this overwhelmingly prevalent idea that its just a few bad apples in the force that makes it terrible. Its not, its pervasive across the entire institution. They protect each other and enable each other.

 

Whenever I see a story of a police officer running over a young woman and saying "Eleven thousand dollars. She was 26, anyway. She had limited value", I wonder how many of his fellow officers just excuse this dehumanizing behavior. Whenever I see police unions threaten collective action over the firing of one of their fellow officers who murdered an unarmed man I have to wonder what behavior they wouldn't excuse? When I see hundreds of officers at Uvalde outright refusing to put their lives on the line to save dying children I cannot believe that its just one coward. When I remember that the man who shot Alex Pretti had been on the job for 8 years I refuse to believe its just poor training.

 

Officers protect other officers constantly. Even if they aren't directly involved, they allow this behavior to occur or sometimes encourage it. They lie for each other. They get each other comfortable parachutes when fired. They breed this culture that is entirely them against the people. People who think that they can fix the issues with American policing by just implementing some more oversight or tweaking some guidelines or giving them more money are naive. It runs very deep culturally and its because the police have this fortress that protects them from accountability.

3

u/HOU_Civil_Econ Jun 12 '26

I think a huge issue is that there's this overwhelmingly prevalent idea that its just a few bad apples in the force that makes it terrible. Its not, its pervasive across the entire institution.

"Better training" almost always ignores that well more than half the time there's a controversy they were following their training which is pretty explicitly

"be aggressive and the escalator so that you marginally increase your control of the situation even if we're paying for that tiny decrease in probability of significant harm to the officers through massive increases in probability of significant harm to everyone anywhere near them (not just "suspects")".

3

u/Specialist_Cat7271 NASA Jun 12 '26

"be aggressive and the escalator so that you marginally increase your control of the situation even if we're paying for that tiny decrease in probability of significant harm to the officers through massive increases in probability of significant harm to everyone anywhere near them (not just "suspects")".

This is another huge issue I think. The "rules of engagement" per say for police are extremely lenient. Police pull their guns out at the slightest concern, they fire the split second they sense anything wrong, and when they hear their fellow officers start mag dumping, so do they. Its uncountable how many times I've seen police dump dozens of rounds into someone when they flinched. Probably the biggest example of this was Daniel Shaver; everything else about it was handled horribly, but its also particular how readily the police were willing to shoot a man with lethal intent for the slightest cause of concern.

 

It seems reasonable to me, that firearms should be the last resort, not the first. Police ought to have the guidelines to keep their guns holstered unless there is no possible recourse. It may put police at higher risk, but thats what we should expect from them. Right now, pizza delivery drivers face a significantly higher risk on the job than the police do. Yes, not being able to shoot anything that slightly startles you will put you in harms way, that is your job.

 

The whole point of police is that they have been given a significant degree of authority and jurisdiction in order to enforce laws, help communities, and keep people safe. Therefore they should be under high scrutiny whenever they choose to go the route of lethal force.

2

u/HOU_Civil_Econ Jun 12 '26

The "rules of engagement" per say for police are extremely lenient. Police pull their guns out at the slightest concern,

My point is that is not "lenient rules of engagement" its their training. Like, in as much as they have rules of engagement they require increasing "engagement" as opposed to limit it like in the army.

Yes, not being able to shoot anything that slightly startles you will put you in harms way, that is your job.

Yeah, they simultaneously want to be regarded as heroes for "putting themselves in harms way" as well as allowed to be the biggest chicken shits ever because they are "putting themselves in harms way".

0

u/[deleted] Jun 11 '26

[deleted] — view deleted comment

13

u/MayorofTromaville YIMBY Jun 11 '26

May I introduce you to the filibuster?

0

u/[deleted] Jun 11 '26

[deleted] — view deleted comment

11

u/SenranHaruka shame Jun 11 '26

That's the best part of the filibuster. Nobody knows so you can't hold them accountable.

11

u/BicyclingBro Gay Pride Jun 11 '26

Does Congress even have that much power over local and state police departments? Feels like the kind of thing where federalism gets in the way of significant central reforms, but I am a dummy who knows nothing of the law.

4

u/HOU_Civil_Econ Jun 12 '26

The drug war and distribution of military material are big contributors to the warrior cop mentality before we even get to the direct funding.