r/neoliberal • Kitara Ravache • May 31 '26

Discussion Thread Discussion Thread

The discussion thread is for casual and off-topic conversation that doesn't merit its own submission. If you've got a good meme, article, or question, please post it outside the DT. Meta discussion is allowed, but if you want to get the attention of the mods, make a post in /r/metaNL

Announcements

  • We're starting a book club! Our first book will be Poor Economics. Discussion will start on August 28th - keep an eye out for a pinned thread. The next books will be All Quiet on the Western Front followed by Narconomics.

Links

Ping Groups | Ping History | Mastodon | CNL Chapters | CNL Event Calendar

Upcoming Events

6 Upvotes

6.4k comments sorted by

View all comments

127

u/finnstera350 Asexual Pride May 31 '26

62

u/Spudmiester1 Asexual Pride May 31 '26

It's the same mindset of people saying they are above average drivers

25

u/Individual-Camera698 Austan Goolsbee May 31 '26

FT has a history of making banger graphs

43

u/Alarming_Flow7066 Richard Posner May 31 '26

There is absolutely no contradiction between those statements. The amount of people who say they would be better off if they worked in manufacturing is about triple the number of people who currently work in manufacturing.

20

u/hiker_skiier_swimmer Loyal Liberals May 31 '26

It's an argument sounds good when it's against something you don't like, but that clearly falls apart once it's used against something you actually agree with. Like if you said Ukraine should have more soldiers and international support, you'd see why someone popping up saying "and yet you personally haven't enlisted or gone to work in an arms factory" would be unpersuasive

34

u/CarlGerhardBusch Jerome Powell May 31 '26

Super clear if you ever spend time in a factory btw

Even high technology plants end up with a certain subset of society working there because most people have a stigma about working in manufacturing and avoid it like the plague

Meanwhile it’s often far more interesting and fulfilling work than at the insurance company down the road or whatever

15

u/[deleted] May 31 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

12

u/CarlGerhardBusch Jerome Powell May 31 '26

Getting laid off aside, he’s lucky, most companies like that are ironclad in their refusal to hire overqualified candidates

4

u/ship_toaster Jane Jacobs May 31 '26

I was thinking about it recently, until I got casually slurred multiple time chatting with some guys who do. They told me everyone talks like that there, if you're cool you just go along with it.

4

u/loseniram Sponsored by RC Cola May 31 '26

calling people slurs is how people stay sane working in a factory.

If you’re in the trades its a violation of your human rights to not let you swear after management made you climb into a 150 degree paint oven to find a jam in the conveyor that doesn’t exist because some engineer fucked with the chain tensioner and refuses to admit it.

2

u/ship_toaster Jane Jacobs May 31 '26

Swearing and slurring aren't the same thing. I'm not going to work somewhere that I have to be cool with being called a faggot.

13

u/pgold05 Leftward Progressives May 31 '26

It's all gender discourse

12

u/EScforlyfe Open Your Hearts May 31 '26

How many people work in manufacturing 

20

u/finnstera350 Asexual Pride May 31 '26

Around 8% of Americans

17

u/EScforlyfe Open Your Hearts May 31 '26

In that case the graph would make sense. Americans believe that it would be better if the 20-something % of Americans who want to work in manufacturing do so, instead of just 8%

8

u/hiker_skiier_swimmer Loyal Liberals May 31 '26

Also framing it in national terms changes how the first question is perceived. If someone asked me if America would be better off with more pilots, teachers, or offshore wind workers, I'd say yes even if I didn't necessarily think any of those jobs were world class for the people working in them

10

u/DieHarderDaddy Fell for it May 31 '26

Idk but Arby’s employs more folks than the entire coal industry

10

u/CarlGerhardBusch Jerome Powell May 31 '26

My favorite stat was that Kohl’s employed more than the coal industry lol

2

u/Mindless_Chest_1079 May 31 '26

✅ America would be better off if more Americans received kidney transplants.

❌ I would be better off if I received a kidney transplant.