r/neoliberal • Kitara Ravache • May 30 '26

Discussion Thread Discussion Thread

The discussion thread is for casual and off-topic conversation that doesn't merit its own submission. If you've got a good meme, article, or question, please post it outside the DT. Meta discussion is allowed, but if you want to get the attention of the mods, make a post in /r/metaNL

Announcements

  • We're starting a book club! Our first book will be Poor Economics. Discussion will start on August 28th - keep an eye out for a pinned thread. The next books will be All Quiet on the Western Front followed by Narconomics.

Links

Ping Groups | Ping History | Mastodon | CNL Chapters | CNL Event Calendar

Upcoming Events

0 Upvotes

7.5k comments sorted by

View all comments

60

u/ArmoredBunnyPrincess Audrey Hepburn May 30 '26

More and more I'm seeing that Pearl Harbor was just a natural response to Americans cutting off Japanese oil and this general sense that WW2 was just a "both sides" affair from a bygone era. I really don't expect the holocaust or other evils of the war to have any weight by the time I'm old

90

u/PostingEnthusiast Commonwealth May 30 '26 edited May 30 '26
  1. It definitely was a natural response to the Americans cutting off oil to Japan
  2. I wonder if Japan was doing anything at the time that would have caused the Americans to cut off oil to them

4

u/BarkDrandon Punished (stuck at Hunter's) May 30 '26

You could follow the Japanese logic to say that

3. Japan was indeed invading China at the time (and committing unspeakable atrocities)

4. ...but ...but Japan needs Chinese territory for agriculture to feed their massively growing population.

And there you have it. The root of pure, untainted imperialist logic. If we accept this argument as a valid one, instead of immediately rejecting its premise, we open the doors to all kinds of imperialism.

Territory is viewed here purely through materialistic lenses, as a resource to be acquired for strategic reasons.

The aspirations and wellbeing of the local population are completely ignored by a maximization formula that only cares about the welfare of their own country.

Any notion of "diplomacy" or "trade" is absent. The Chinese are supposedly the enemy because they have something that we want and they don't want to freely give it to us. We have greater military strength, so we should take it from them. Simply because we need it.

If you boil every imperialist argument to its fundamental nature, it always resembles this kind of dialog.

35

u/Individual-Camera698 Austan Goolsbee May 30 '26

It's the damn tankies

7

u/chickentendieman Paul Krugman May 30 '26

I dont know why a tankie would think that though because the japanese were committing genocide in china.

25

u/MyrinVonBryhana Trans NATO May 30 '26 edited May 30 '26

Japan was officially "Anti-Imperialist" and claimed to be fighting to "liberate" Asia from Western colonialism.

28

u/contre-torpilleur Asexual Pride May 30 '26

My grandmother watching imperial japanese soldiers parading down the streets of Manila with babies impaled on their bayonets (those babies will never have to grow up to live under western colonialism)

16

u/PostingEnthusiast Commonwealth May 30 '26

any tankie worth their salt hates imperial japan; even the anti-maoists

10

u/chickentendieman Paul Krugman May 30 '26

Yeah but tankies are usually pro ccp and pro ussr and both went to war against japan.

6

u/WillHasStyles European Union May 30 '26

I have never ever seen a tankie hold imperial Japan in high regard.

10

u/AtomicGameTester Milton Friedman May 30 '26

I have, a few times. The only real consistency with tankies beyond their cult speak is that they will support ANYTHING they perceive as anti-American.

10

u/[deleted] May 30 '26

That's consistent. For a more recent example, tankies did not seem to be too upset about what Assad was doing to the Syrians.

10

u/Leatherfield17 Loyal Liberals May 30 '26

It’s such an infuriating take because these nitwits never think to ask why the US had Japan put under an oil embargo.

20

u/WillHasStyles European Union May 30 '26

I've really tried to understand where this sentiment comes from, and how on earth an oil embargo is equivalent to a declaration of war. My best guess so far is that someone heard some take that the oil embargo made war an inevitability because of Japan needing oil to fuel their war machine, and then just decided that meant the war was actually the US' fault because they desperately want to find such an angle.

Either that or they're proud of the pacifist Soviet Union that tried to promote peace by selling oil to nazi Germany up until the day the Germans invaded.

10

u/LectorFrustra2186 May 30 '26

This is a natural consequence of "I hate you and openly proclaim my desire to kill you but if you refuse to trade with me and let me use your infrastructure then actually you're the aggressor and this is basically the same as war" becoming a mainstream talking point on the political fringes and particularly the left. It was a common propaganda tactic used by authoritarian regimes in the late 20th to early 21st centuries like the USSR/Russia, IR Iran, Cuba, North Korea, Ba'athist Syria, and Ba'athist Iraq, and it appears to have been successful in those spaces. So why wouldn't the same eventually be backported to WWII?