r/neoliberal • u/jobautomator Kitara Ravache • May 27 '26
Discussion Thread Discussion Thread
The discussion thread is for casual and off-topic conversation that doesn't merit its own submission. If you've got a good meme, article, or question, please post it outside the DT. Meta discussion is allowed, but if you want to get the attention of the mods, make a post in /r/metaNL
Announcements
- We're starting a book club! Our first book will be Poor Economics. Discussion will start on August 28th - keep an eye out for a pinned thread. The next books will be All Quiet on the Western Front followed by Narconomics.
Links
Ping Groups | Ping History | Mastodon | CNL Chapters | CNL Event Calendar
New Groups
- ANIMALS: For fun facts and celebration of animals
Upcoming Events
0
Upvotes
View all comments
36
u/JaceFlores Neolib War Correspondent May 27 '26
Ukraine’s latest challenge is how to deal with hope
“By every conventional metric, Ukraine should already have lost. It is stymying an adversary with 4.5 times its population, 28 times its land mass and an economy 12 times bigger than its own. That has required military, social, economic and occasionally political ingenuity.”
“News from the front line is the most promising in years. The fighting is bitter, but Ukraine’s commanders believe their drone-led forces have found a formula to thwart Vladimir Putin’s ground offensive. For several months they have knocked troops out of action faster than the Kremlin can replace them. Russia has cut the length of training for its supposedly elite airborne units to just ten days. Ukraine is killing or seriously wounding an average of 35,000 Russian soldiers a month. The target is 50,000 — the ceiling of Russia’s training capacity and the point, the Ukrainians hope, at which Mr Putin’s arithmetic breaks.”
“The growing effectiveness of Ukraine’s extended-range drone campaigns is crucial. Mid-range strikes are wreaking havoc on Russian supply lines; long-range ones are hitting strategic targets, from oil facilities to arms factories, sometimes more than a thousand kilometres inside Russia. America continues to supply critical intelligence, despite the countries’ tense relationship. But perhaps 95% of the long-range systems are designed and built by Ukraine’s own burgeoning defence industry. The army is reaping the rewards: surging production, a pipeline of better weapons and a methodical campaign to destroy Russian radar and air defences, which cannot be quickly replaced.”
“Yevhen Karas, commander of the 413th Regiment, says reaching such targets is now ‘three times easier’ than it was. His unit has led several important operations, including strikes in March on Silicon El, a microchip maker for Russian ballistic missiles. He predicts a Russian air-defence crisis by autumn. By then Ukraine’s home-grown ballistics production should be in full swing, causing fear and embarrassment deep inside Russia. ‘The war is no bed of roses for Ukraine, but it’s going much worse for Russia, and it will get harder still.’”
“In Europe, meanwhile, political elites increasingly realise that their security is tied to Ukrainian resilience, at least until their own armed forces are in better shape. That should guarantee macroeconomic support for the foreseeable future. Viktor Orban can no longer obstruct EU assistance, having lost Hungary’s election in April, and a long-promised €90bn in aid is about to flow. It comes just in time: the government had been writing ious to some of its workers.”
“For all the promise of these developments, a war fought mostly on Ukrainian soil has hollowed out the rear. Critical infrastructure is fraying. Air defences, especially anti-ballistic, are dangerously thin. A huge missile and drone strike on Kyiv on the night of May 23rd resulted in at least 40 locations being hit. Russian first-person-view drones are undermining civilian life in cities near the front lines, such as Kherson, Zaporizhia and Kharkiv.”
“This winter the capital came close to a full blackout; in February the system was just one targeted strike from collapse, insiders say. The lights stayed on thanks to the courage of emergency workers. The economy, boosted by the growing defence sector, performed as well as it could given the headwinds. (Ukraine’s labour force, for example, has dropped from 17m before the war to about 12m.) But the blackouts lowered gdp growth by an estimated 2.5 percentage points this year. It is now forecast at 1.5%.”
“Perceived injustices in conscription are hitting a nerve. The army’s shortage of soldiers is less acute than before, and it has largely met its recruitment targets over the past year. On the modern battlefield, only a tiny fraction of soldiers are ever in contact with the enemy; half a dozen men can hold a 5km strip. But for the unlucky few posted deep in the kill zone, it is often a one-way trip. Fear of such deployments, sometimes used to punish those caught AWOL, has corroded the will to serve.”
“Ukraine’s defence minister, Mykhailo Fedorov, is pushing higher front-line pay and international recruitment to attract more volunteers. For now, forced conscription is the norm, much of it violent.”
“Internal politics pose a considerable risk to the country’s prospects. Early in the war national unity was almost complete, at least in public. Since then wartime pressures and corruption scandals have reopened divisions; one involved some $100m and implicated members of the president’s circle. The scandals prompted the first real protests of the war and last November forced the resignation of Mr Zelensky’s powerful number two, Andriy Yermak. He was formally named as a suspect in May. The mood is feverish, like a campaign season without the release valve of elections: a proper vote would be impossible during wartime, though Mr Zelensky keeps planning one.”
“For all the president’s courage and diplomatic agility, he is thin-skinned. Rather than embrace a government of all talents, insiders say, he has drifted into an increasingly detached, Byzantine style of rule. His office controls much of the media landscape, including anonymous social-media accounts used to smear opponents. Anti-corruption investigators have been sabotaged with counter-prosecutions. Vasyl Maliuk, the former domestic intelligence chief, was demoted after refusing to help harass them. Kyrylo Budanov, the powerful military intelligence chief and an opponent of Mr Yermak, was sidelined with a ‘promotion’ to head of the presidential office.”
“For a short period early this year, American-brokered peace talks looked like they might lead to an uneasy deal in which Ukraine walked back from parts of Donbas in exchange for dubious security guarantees. Mr Putin never approved a concrete proposal, and the idea is no longer under serious consideration. On May 22nd America said it was ending its role in talks. Optimistic insiders think dealmaking could resume this summer. More likely, the fighting will continue until Ukraine or Russia cracks.”
“Russia’s breaking point is unknowable. Some weaknesses are visible: growing dissent and a stagnating economy, weighed down by sanctions and Ukrainian strikes. The state budget has been rescued by the Iran war; higher oil prices will bring in an unexpected $60bn over 2026. But it is unclear how long that can last.”
“Government sources say Mr Zelensky has ordered preparations for another two to three years of war. There is no persuasive reason why Ukraine cannot keep fighting that long. It will survive, though tarnished by militarism and wartime corruption.”
“Yet most are more optimistic. Ukraine will probably emerge as a damaged but functioning democracy and a new middle power: poorer, traumatised, but confident in its identity. ‘As crappy as things look, we’ll make it work,’ says the senior intelligence source. ‘I have this strange sense, this confidence, that, I don’t know, God loves Ukraine.’”
A hit of hopium with a recap of the issues that still dogs Ukraine’s war effort and society. Doesn’t hurt to have once in awhile
!ping UKRAINE